4 ms·
I'm actually not a huge fan of the Beatles* but wow, I really enjoyed this essay. * I think it's because they are simply so good (an the sense explained in thi
by gumby 5y ago
I'm actually not a huge fan of the Beatles* but wow, I really enjoyed this essay.
* I think it's because they are simply so good (an the sense explained in this essay) that I just heard them too much over the last 50+ years and they have become as much a universal cultural cliche as, say, Shakespeare. I have certainly listened to them a lot, with pleasure, but not so much in the past couple of decades.
- lapetitejort 5y ago> they have become as much a universal cultural cliche Same thing happened to me when I first listened to U2's Joshua Tree and Fleetwood Mac's Rumours. The first halves just sound like Greatest Hits records. But nope, they're just so ubiquitous that I've already heard half the album through cultural osmosis.
- js2 5y agoBono doesn’t think he’s a very good singer. https://www.vulture.com/2022/01/bono-embarrassed-by-u2.html https://www.vulture.com/2022/01/bono-embarrassed-by-u2.html
- sockpuppet69 5y ago
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoIronic nickname, then ("Bono Vox" being the original form)
- not1ofU 5y agoTIL what that actually means (the wiki bit below). Its also the name of a hearing aid company in Ireland [0], making it even more ironic. Pretty sure this is where the name originated from. Found out that (according to wikipedia)[1]: "is an alteration of bonavox, a Latin word which translates to "good voice"." [0] - https://www.bonavox.ie/ https://www.bonavox.ie/ [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bono https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bono
- tssva 5y agoHe is far from alone in thinking that. Even among music critics that are generally positive about U2 there has always been a fair amount of criticism of his voice.
- WalterBright 5y agoOne can get tired of hearing any song, no matter how good, after listening to it too many times. This fatigue cannot be cured by decades of not hearing it.
- soneca 5y ago” This fatigue cannot be cured by decades of not hearing it.” But it also can. I caught myself enjoying old one hit wonders that I hated at the time due to listening to it so much. Then decades later, I could enjoy them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- grujicd 5y agoIt helps if you play an instrument. And especially if you switch from let's say a guitar to a bass or a keyboard or drums. You don't have to be good. But pretty soon you'll hear new layers in old songs you thought you know fully. I can enjoy a lot of music I wouldn't otherwise like, if I listen to one of two instruments within. In my opinion, playing an instrument, not matter how badly, greatly expands the joy you get from music.
- WalterBright 5y agoYou're right that listening to the layers can extend the life of enjoying a song. I've also found that listening to a different take on the song, like hearing a live version, can extend it, too.
- grujicd 5y agoThat too. For songs I listened the most I even prefer cover versions now. The more the cover strays from the original - the better. You still have the song you love but it's also fresh in some ways.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- irrational 5y agoI was a teenager in the 1980s. For some reason, the Beatles were never on the radio (at least not the stations I listened to). So, I grew up not really familiar with the Beatles music. I watched the documentary and was surprised by how enjoyable a lot of their music is. I was also surprised at how very little I recognized. You would think that with such a popular band I would have heard their music at least occasionally over the past 50 years.
- stevenwoo 5y agoThere were quite a few deep cuts and some of their influences there that unless one listened to every Beatles record and saw their interviews one might not recognize, only the big hits got airplay on genre stations (some pop, some classic rock, some countdown best of) 10-20 years later. I'm about the same age but had all their albums. The last few albums had eclectic mix of songs compared to earlier pop hits centered albums.
- nefitty 5y agoI listened to everything by the Beatles that I could get my hands on to make a playlist for my wife. The theme was "Beatles-adjacent but as good or better". The Beatles finally clicked for me. I still ultimately prefer The Monkees.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoSometimes an artist is so influential that to go back to discover them for the first time, from a modern perspective, they can sound cliche ... when in fact they invented the cliches. Right? I have chatted with coworkers after "The Lord of the Rings" films came out who had not read Tolkien but after seeing the movies thought that the story was fairly derivative. Maybe not such a surprising take if you allow that nearly all fantasy since Tolkien has been so heavily influenced by him that his fingerprints are everywhere — in D&D, films like "Willow", etc. I remember hearing Raydio's hit "Jack and Jill" [1] back in 1978 when it came out (I was 14 years old) and it was probably the first synthesizer I had ever heard in a song. I cannot even describe to you how alien and wonderful that sounded when I first heard it. Electronics in music would become so mainstream of course that it is hard to "shock my ears" any longer and even harder for someone used to it to go back and hear this song from over 40 years the way my "virgin ears" heard it. [1] https://youtu.be/43OVNx4EXQg https://youtu.be/43OVNx4EXQg
- TillE 5y agoThere are a number of artists where if you hear them on the radio at the supermarket or whatever, it sounds like boring pop background noise, but if you actually sit down and listen, you understand how special it is. Cat Stevens was like that for me. It's become fashionable to say that the Beatles are bad (maybe you don't enjoy the music, but they were revolutionary) or to trivialize them as a boy band (they were, but even early on they were so much more). I don't particularly love them, but it's hard not to be fascinated by their fairly brief career.
- agumonkey 5y agoABBA comes to mind. Dancing Queen is a kind of pop masterpiece. Everything is tight, tailored, and flows with the rest.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoI always felt that even if ABBAs songs might be catchy and perfectly put together, they lacked depth. They were shallow. They had very little to say to their fellow human beings except "I am super trooper dancing queen"
- agumonkey 5y agoIt's pop (shallow I can see), but it's a masterpiece. The drum groove, the piano locks, the bass, the harmonies, the recording it's all just perfect fit and flows from start to finish.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoMy favorite Swedish band was Army of Lovers. Well-done pop-music as well but it also gives the impression, maybe just an illusion of depth. https://youtu.be/cUo0YkLyrjU https://youtu.be/cUo0YkLyrjU
- euroderf 5y agoTheir only song worth the effort is Waterloo, but hey what a song. It was the year of dinosaur bands doing more dinosaur music, and Waterloo was such a tremendous breath of fresh air. Really wonderful, it was.