3 ms·
So... the headline invokes an inappropriate image. The author attracted the attention of the FBI in 1942, when "cryptography" meant wartime codebreaking, and h
by ajross 5y ago
So... the headline invokes an inappropriate image. The author attracted the attention of the FBI in 1942, when "cryptography" meant wartime codebreaking, and his amateur cypher got lost and then found and turned in by a genuinely concerned citizen.
I mean, OK. Sure, it's bad that kids interested in math get caught up in this. But come on, it was the middle of the biggest war in history and real spies were indeed doing real work with codes like that. This says nothing about modern enforcement regimes, nor should it.
- vkou 5y agoThis is the important take-away, here. If he were dabbling with radios at the age of 11, in 1942, he'd have ran into the same kinds of problems. Hell, simply being of the wrong ethnicity was more than enough to dump a world of problems on your head in that time period. 120,000 people were sent to internment camps for doing literally nothing, and we're wringing hands over a kid getting a house call from the FBI.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoHell, simply being of the wrong ethnicity was more than enough to dump a world of problems on your head in that time period. 120,000 people were sent to internment camps for doing literally nothing, and we're wringing hands over a kid getting a house call from the FBI. Actually, wring hands at both things. The camps were atrocities, even if they didn't match quite the enemies' atrocities. But they were also doing this sort of thing to many different sorts of folks.
- vkou 5y agoOn the scale of hand-wringing, this doesn't even register. Nothing bad happened to him. The police looked into it, decided this was probably not an issue, filed it, and moved on. No laws were broken. No procedures were violated. Nobody's fundamental human rights were curtailed. The procedures or laws in place weren't unfair or excessive. This isn't the Rosa Parks, or the Rodney King, or the George Floyd of police abuse. This isn't the springboard for broad, or even narrow reform. This is the system working. I understand that a tinkerer may feel offended by the fact that the police even looked into this in the middle of a world war[1], but if that's the poster child of your problems with the police, you are in a staggeringly privileged position, compared to on-going, actual problems, affecting millions of people every year (outside of the context of, well, a world war.) [1] That was in large part won by intelligence and counter-intelligence.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoMost importantly, there is something modern enforcement could learn from the story: nothing bad (aside from a stressful meeting) actually happened to the suspected but ultimately innocent kid
- unethical_ban 5y agoAs it relates to the man's story, the most offensive part about it is the demeanor of the agents angry at the kid and being abrupt with the mother. The FBI rightfully investigated at the time what seemed to be a coded key, which is very uncommon. The boy did nothing wrong, and he wasn't punished. But if the FBI wants to be pissy for hitting a false positive, do it at the water cooler, not toward innocent people. They should have offered the kid a job.