3 ms·
>> By my age, Einstein had completed general relativity, Turing had founded CS, won WWII, and proposed the Turing Test, and Galois, Ramanujan, and Ramsey had be
by YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago
>> By my age, Einstein had completed general relativity, Turing had founded CS,
won WWII, and proposed the Turing Test, and Galois, Ramanujan, and Ramsey had
been dead for years.
I fee confused when an article begins with a blatant exaggeration about a
subject I am cognisant in right off the bat because then Idon't know how much I
can trust it when it speaks of subjects I don't know.
To wit, Turing did not win WWII and didn't found CS. Turing wrote a seminal
paper in early computer science, but he didn't found the field of research
called "computer science". To be honest, I have no idea who would rightfully
deserve to be recognised as the founder of computer science, when there have
been many contributions of the same value as Turing's, the most obvious examples
being Church and Von Neumann, less well-recognised ones being Charles Sanders
Peirce and Henry M. Sheffer, Claude Shannon, Conrand Zuse and others (Church
described a theory of computation equivalent to UTMs; Von Neumann proposed the
accursed Von Neumann architecture; Peirce and Sheffer described logic gates and
showed the completeness of the NAND gate; Shannon proved the completeness of
Boolean logic circuits; Zuse made the first programmable computer -Babbage only
designed the first). And so on. In my mind, trying to ascribe feats to heroes
that they never performed, diminishes, rather than exalts, the hero. Turing
doesn't need any extra serving of praise for things he didn't do to be known for
ever as one of the greats of CS.
- ericpauley 5y agoPerhaps this comes down to having more context on Scott Aaronson's work and writing, but this section to me came off as humorous front matter, not some attempt to precisely characterize the history of computer science. See the front matter of his book (Quantum Computing Since Democritus) for more context on this. On the actual meat of the post, Scott Aaronson is a definite authority figure (among others) on these topics especially as they relate to computing.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoMnyea, you're probably right and that just flew over my head. No surprise- I remember being told that my sense of humour was removed at birth...