3 ms·
Ask HN: Can we stop blaming the wrong things, please?
We continually have stories of forced "upgrades" that break things, all in the name of "security" and "best practices" and a large range of other absolutely important, how dare you question it reasons.
The root cause of everything is the broken security model from Unix that underlies everything in our ecosystem.
How we managed to avoid reality and keep this co-dependent relationship going this long is a sad, sad tale.
We need an intervention. It shouldn't be unreasonable to want to be able to download some code, tell your system to run that code against a set of capabilities, and be able to trust that those capabilities are the only things that will be affected.
We have a modern electric grid, which lets you take any random lamp from a thrift store, or curbside garbage can, and plug it in to your house, and know that doing so won't burn your house down, no matter how poor the shape of the lamp. Why? Because of modern circuit breakers designed to protect the user and the wiring of the house.
Why can't we have capability based security? It was invented 50 years ago! It can protect the user, and the operating system, all in a usable, friendly manner.
- PaulHoule 5y agoHasn't it been tried and not succeed in the past? For instance Intel thought this was the future https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432 but it was really the 286. A counterexample is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_AS/400 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_AS/400 which is a nice system and still around today but definitely niche.
- mikewarot 5y agoIt's always been passed off as too slow, or too complex, or completely unnecessary. Modern microkernels are fast enough, proven secure, and we just need to start building the stuff to use them. Imagine if you woke up in a world without household or industrial circuit breakers or fuses. There would be stories in the news every day about some foolish person who plugged in their own old appliance and didn't upgrade to the newest model, and thus burned down their house. How could a user have been so foolish? Clearly we need to license all devices that will plug in to houses so that the fires can be prevented. Any efforts to institute circuit breakers would be considered too complicated, or too much resistance added to a circuit, stealing power. Any number of rationalizations would be internalized by electrical users and electricians everywhere. This is the software world we live in.