3 ms·
Hint: they do.
by ncmncm 5y ago
Hint: they do.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoWhere do you live that your government requires you to pay for those specifically? Those all come out of general taxes. The closest equivalent would be gas taxes, but that only covers a portion of road costs.
- obmelvin 5y agoIsn't that what this discussion is about? The OP said that it costs the taxpayers $1. I don't know about this specific situation - but the claim does not seem to be about paying directly for things.
- specialist 5y agoAngelers pay govt fees for priviledge to fish. The government subsidizes commercial fishers. Add everything up, positive ROI for angelers, negative ROI for commercial.
- rmbyrro 5y agoNot even that. Where I live, gas taxes or even car property taxes are not dedicated to road maintenance.
- mywittyname 5y agoI live in a place that charges taxes specifically earmarked for all of those items. We call them levies. Ostensibly, we vote on them, but some levies stay in place for 30 years. For example, a levy for a new police station that covers the mortgage for 30 years.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoBut those aren't based on use. Everybody has to pay them no matter what. However, the amount of gas tax you pay is dependent on how much you drive.
- specialist 5y agoYup. I've long been against any and all usage fees. They just exfiltrate money to cronies, transfer wealth from urban to suburban areas. Witness Bob Moses' innovative manifold money laundering schemes, as detailed in Caro's book The Power Broker, and since replicated every where. But now I'm open to alternative arrangements that make the bookkeeping painfully clear. Because too many people are hostile to collective action, the greater good. Maybe radical transparency meets universal basic income. Charge everyone full price in the front, pay as you go. Achieve progressive policies by just giving people cash to cover the cost in the back. In other words, the opposite of suuply side economics. So if you're a working parent, you just get cash to cover rent, gas, daycare, whatever. Might be feasible with today's mobile payment systems. Certainly wasn't feasible (logistically) until very recently. However we can make it work, sign me up. I'm just so sick of all the Freedom Markets™ wankery, err, sophistry.