4 ms·
The problem is that the entire car hyper-focused model is unsustainable. Cities are expected to maintain huge amounts of infrastructure for people who don't pay
by acdha 5y ago
The problem is that the entire car hyper-focused model is unsustainable. Cities are expected to maintain huge amounts of infrastructure for people who don't pay much, if anything, in taxes for it but since cars don't scale well there's a constant demand for even more expansion.
Recognizing that involves telling a lot of people that they need to switch from driving cars to using transit, biking, etc. and there are a lot of people who don't want to hear that, especially if most of their personal net worth is equity in a building which is too far away at anything less than freeway speeds. It's much easier just to keep pretending that a one-time tax or bond issue will solve it, and so we keep doing the same cycle over and over again.
- voisin 5y agoI agree that this is the problem. But the problem is possible in part because governments are not forced to set aside funds for the future maintenance. If they had to fund an annuity to cover lifetime maintenance, then the budget would prove unattractive relative to public transit projects which suffer currently from the appearance of higher up-front costs (but most likely have lower total lifetime costs).
- rootusrootus 5y ago> the entire car hyper-focused model is unsustainable I disagree. There's nothing magic about the car. What is unsustainable is not budgeting for real costs nor planning for the future. E.g. we install pipes that are supposed to last 100 years, which just means that everyone alive figures they can ignore it and let the people three generations from today figure out how to deal with it.
- brewdad 5y agoThat's just saying the same thing in a different way. It is unsustainable given our current model of taxation and government spending. Good luck convincing the populace to pay significantly more in taxes while the government "hoards" their money for some future expense beyond the average person's lifetime.
- Kye 5y agoGeorgia uses SPLOSTs for stuff like this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special-purpose_local-option_sales_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special-purpose_local-option_s... Here's an example of the result in this local interchange conversion from an intersection that wasn't designed for all the traffic going through it: https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9462412,-83.7533688,476m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9462412,-83.7533688,476m/dat... It looks sparse in traffic now, but it used to take 5-30 minutes to cross! Another underway closer to Athens: https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9400062,-83.7207463,3a,75y,20.86h,101.24t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sLa9wkJ8NEAGu3a_4gCEmYw!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DLa9wkJ8NEAGu3a_4gCEmYw%26cb_client%3Dsearch.revgeo_and_fetch.gps%26w%3D96%26h%3D64%26yaw%3D61.264313%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@33.9400062,-83.7207463,3a,75y,2... This is part of a years-long project to turn highway 316/University Parkway between Athens and I-85 into a controlled-access highway to handle the next few decades of growth as what used to be sprawl from Atlanta turns into major population centers.
- rootusrootus 5y agoMy point is that switching to urbanized infrastructure isn't going to suddenly make the population more willing to fork out more in taxes. It just moves the problem.
- acdha 5y agoThey will, however, be seeing significant economies of scale. A suburban street with 20 houses on it has similar maintenance costs to an urban block but the latter expense can spread across hundreds of taxpayers and living in a city means they need less parking because many people don’t need a personal car to function.
- acdha 5y agoCars aren't magic but they're very inefficient. Supporting the model where everyone owns a car and drives themselves around means that each person uses hundreds of square feet of road, buildings are usually required to maintain hundreds of square feet of car storage space per resident, business are often required to pay for storage as well (even if it's something like a bar which we really shouldn't have people driving to), and the high safety risks mean that beyond the basic road itself you end up with a lot of expensive dedicated infrastructure which is protecting people from cars or reducing congestion. All of that adds up to a lot of built-in carrying cost that people don't see directly but requires upfront payment and ongoing maintenance. Owning a car isn't just the $10-12k average annual expense but also things like paying a double-digit percentage more for housing to get off-street parking, having all of the prices at local businesses be higher to subsidize the bundled parking, etc.
- throwaway894345 5y agoThis viewpoint makes sense for dense urban areas where space really is at a premium, but most of the united states is sparse and land is relatively cheap. > Owning a car isn't just the $10-12k average annual expense but also things like paying a double-digit percentage more for housing to get off-street parking I'm very skeptical of these figures. $10-12K is more than I'll pay for my brand new Tesla, and it's a hell of a lot less than that when you amortize those figures over its expected lifetime. Yeah, there's also the cost of fuel and maintenance, but I'm very skeptical that these costs added onto the car payment bring the cost up to $10k on average. Moreover, the average cost isn't very useful--it's influenced by people like me and people even wealthier than me who can afford to splurge. It doesn't tell you anything about the actual cost required to own and maintain a car--chip shortage aside, a used Toyota Camry with decent miles probably costs about $10-15k total and amortized over its ~20 year lifetime including fuel and maintenance it's probably on the order of $2k/year. And of course, if we're worried about people who can't afford that, as with anything, the government can subsidize those people. Similarly, off-street parking isn't an issue outside of large cities (virtually everyone else has a driveway, and the minimum viable cost of maintaining a driveway isn't anywhere near $1k/year). Ultimately, this conversation illustrates one of the major problems with federalizing infrastructure. You get people from urban centers making policies based on incorrect assumptions about other areas of the country.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThere's nothing about using transit that would decrease the number of bridges in a city like Pittsburgh. The transit needs bridges to cross rivers and hollows too. An awful lot of these bridges started as footpaths and ox-cart turnpikes.
- acdha 5y agoThe question is twofold: how many bridges do you need with much better efficiency? A two lane bridge with buses costs less than the 10 lane car bridge you need to carry the same number of people. If you go on a road diet your maintenance costs go down because you’re building fewer lanes, not having tons of bypasses and bridges which exist only to take pressure off of congestion at chokepoints, etc. Those reductions mean you can spend correspondingly more on the necessary core infrastructure.
- shadowgovt 5y agoBroadly-speaking yes, but none of that would have addressed this collapse. This was a two-lane bridge between two major neighborhoods. People need to get to those neighborhoods and they'd have to divert about a mile north to do it without this bridge. Pittsburgh is built at the intersection of three rivers and atop the folded spine of the Alleghenies. Any way you slice it that city's gonna have either a lot of bridges or a lot of grumpy people who can't get anywhere.
- selimthegrim 5y agoIsn’t this bridge four lanes?
- steveklabnik 5y agoTwo lanes on each side + protected sidewalk on each side, yeah.
- acdha 5y agoYes, the point was just that if you use infrastructure more efficiently your maintenance dollar won't have to be stretched as much. They'll still have plenty of bridges but if they focused maintenance on the things used by residents rather than people driving in from the suburbs that'd free up a lot of funding.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Recognizing that involves telling a lot of people that they need to switch from driving cars to using transit, biking, etc. The issue here is latency, availability, and comfort. Cars are great for these three. Can transit compete? > and there are a lot of people who don't want to hear that, especially if most of their personal net worth is equity in a building which is too far away at anything less than freeway speeds If you offer them a better investment, they will. But then, you will have to convince people who put most of their personal net worth into tiny cramped downtown condos that it’s ok for them to lose it due to the massive amount of housing you plan to build.
- acdha 5y ago> > Recognizing that involves telling a lot of people that they need to switch from driving cars to using transit, biking, etc. > The issue here is latency, availability, and comfort. Cars are great for these three. Can transit compete? It's not that simple: cars are great for those when nobody else has them. When you live in a place with enough people to get traffic, they're terrible on the first two and the third is a question of how bad the outside is and how much you enjoy sitting for long periods of time without moving. Similarly, you need to factor in things like parking: car availability and latency both take a huge hit when you can't park in front of your destination, and comfort takes a hit if that means walking in uncomfortable weather, too. That makes the underlying decisions more obvious: if you reserve lanes for transit or build separate right-of-way, taking the bus is a lot better than driving because the 50 people on the bus don't have to wait behind the 3 blocks of 50 people driving cars but if you focus on cars, the bus will be stuck in traffic as well. > But then, you will have to convince people who put most of their personal net worth into tiny cramped downtown condos that it’s ok for them to lose it due to the massive amount of housing you plan to build There's a lot of hyperbole in that sentence, and it's missing the key point that car travel is so inefficient that this pressure is always there even without overt public policy. Urban living is expensive because people like to live in places with fun things to do (i.e. which improves as a function of density) and they don't spend long periods of time stuck in traffic. Removing the public subsidies for suburban commuters will only make it more pronounced.
- xnx 5y agoThis problem might be a subset of the entire premise of every current economic system: they only keep working if growth is assumed
- acdha 5y agoIt's a big challenge with climate change facing us, too: one of the best things we could do is continue lowering the average birthrate but doing so would break one of the fundamental principles that our economy is based on.