4 ms·
Funny how both the right and left are trying to burn books in the US...
by nottorp 5y ago
Funny how both the right and left are trying to burn books in the US...
- shankr 5y ago
- dataviz1000 5y agoedit: Agreed, there is a difference between a government censoring and private citizens protesting and boycotting.
- benwad 5y agoSo... someone wrote an article criticising it? That's not the same as banning it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- klyrs 5y agoWas there a book-burning you meant to link to? Because I just read an article about the exercise of free speech, wherein the twitterati criticized the words of a famous author. What "due process“ do you imagine the government requiring of critical writing?
- finite_jest 5y agoIn the sense of school boards removing books from curricula, "To Kill a Mockingbird" is a recent example. [1] In the sense of removing books from bookstores, Amazon did ban a broad category of books. [2] In the sense of literally burning books, I'm don't know of any recent instances in the US by either side. But I know of one example in Canada. [3] [1]: https://www.newsweek.com/schools-drop-kill-mockingbird-required-reading-list-1672563 https://www.newsweek.com/schools-drop-kill-mockingbird-requi... [2]: WSJ: "Amazon Won’t Sell Books Framing LGBTQ+ Identities as Mental Illnesses" https://archive.fo/v5rWn https://archive.fo/v5rWn [3]: https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/book-burning-at-ontario-francophone-schools-as-gesture-of-reconciliation-denounced https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/book-burning-at-ontario...
- shankr 5y agoNone of which amounts to state actively banning these books. Even though I don't agree, dropping from reading list isn't exactly same as government removing it from the school library. In the sense, it's not the exact same thing. On the other hand, this happened https://twitter.com/cjtackett/status/1486788612511383553 https://twitter.com/cjtackett/status/1486788612511383553
- finite_jest 5y agoThanks for the link. Also corroborated by the statement on the school's website: [1]. That seems overly paternalistic and prudish to me. [1]: https://www.granburyisd.org/site/default.aspx?PageType=3&DomainID=23&ModuleInstanceID=37797&ViewID=6446EE88-D30C-497E-9316-3F8874B3E108&RenderLoc=0&FlexDataID=56433&PageID=22101 https://www.granburyisd.org/site/default.aspx?PageType=3&Dom...
- sascha_sl 5y agoI have never understood why anyone thinks the left burns books. The last time I remember people prominently burning books in mainstream conciousness was the Nazis, including irreplacable knowledge like the IfS library by Magnus Hirschfeld. The notion is so widespread among the right, Dave Rubin named his entire book after it. I have not seen anyone actually try to burn it, even though it is barely worth the paper it is printed on in my humble opinion (and the opinion of most critics).
- DeWilde 5y agoCommunist China and the Soviets would like to disagree.
- sascha_sl 5y agoSorry, I didn't want to devolve this into a history discussion. I invoked the Nazis not as an example of right wingers, but at the last prominently known book burning during which irreplacable knowledge was lost. Hitler, Stalin and Mao are obviously bad representatives for most (unfortunately not all) of the political spectrum today. Unless you want to include edgy atheists burning holy books, but that is provocation and not an attempt at censorship.
- freemint 5y agoThey are not primarily left. They are authoritarians foremost which use the names of Marx (very much not authoritarian) and Lenin (somewhat authoritarian) concatenated as Marxism-Leninism to justify very much authoritarian systems.
- sascha_sl 5y agoThe issue is really that left and right as politial stances are not based on a stable framework, and everyone can place every political system into either category if they really want to (as often happens when people claim the nazis were left wing because they used the word "socialism"). What's actually important is that none of the above fit well within contemporary US-centric understandings of "left" and "right". I say US-centric because some people center-left in the US would be considered center-right where I live - this is how fragile this dicotomy is.
- nottorp 5y agoOk sorry they're taking down more statues than burning books. From my outside the us perspective, both sides look psychotic right now. Or maybe psychopatic? Or both?
- mcphage 5y agoHow many statues of Osama Bin Laden do you think we need, in order to remember 9/11?