2 ms·
The objections seem like quibbling. So, maybe there was also a longish drought 4500 years ago, at least in some places? Fine. And, maybe drought started in som
by ncmncm 5y ago
The objections seem like quibbling. So, maybe there was also a longish drought 4500 years ago, at least in some places? Fine. And, maybe drought started in some places 100 years before the society there collapsed? Fine. So, maybe the 300-year drought wasn't uniformly global? Fine. Egypt didn't entirely collapse? Fine.
It just seems really strange to say highly-stratified societies dependent on agricultural surplus cannot be assumed to have been affected by loss of such surplus. The notion of such a society switching over to meat seems even stranger: where would fodder for the livestock come from, in a place where nothing is growing? Objecting that not everybody in these collapsed empires died is weirder still; surely if most people need to leave to be able to continue eating, that would make it a cause of their empire vanishing? Are they supposed to re-constitute it wholesale somewhere else? Has that ever happened? Wouldn't we see an empire in a new place as a new empire?