5 ms·
I don't understand why Europe is being so bearish on nuclear. It'll solve all of their energy woes without becoming dependent on Russia. Europe doesn't have si
by echelon 5y ago
I don't understand why Europe is being so bearish on nuclear. It'll solve all of their energy woes without becoming dependent on Russia.
Europe doesn't have significant earthquake or tornado risks either. It's about the best place for nuclear you could imagine.
Germany shut their plants down and is now buying LNG. That's a downgrade.
Nuclear is the quickest path to green, and it's staring us right in our faces.
- pgalvin 5y agoGermany has a strong cultural and political opposition to nuclear power, particularly in their Green Party, for many different reasons that I’m not qualified to discuss. I suspect the initial cost is also a barrier to much of Europe, if only for political reasons.
- mantas 5y agoI bet Russia would pay through the roof to keep West Europe hooked… wonder which German politician will get a sweet Gazprom seat this time.
- mediaman 5y agoDoes anyone have a good political explanation for Europe's hostility to nuclear power? Is it really just post-Fukushima nuclear concern? There are so many pressing issues at stake - CO2 production, dependency on an increasingly aggressive foreign adversary for fuel - that it seems like there must be some logic, but I can't figure it out. Even if wind/solar are cheaper than nuclear, it doesn't seem that they can become the only type of of energy supplied in Europe due to variability issues.
- pfortuny 5y agoOh, no, it started in the seventies, around that. It is a mixture of "look what happens if we let everybody have nuclear power: now Pakistan and India have it, and there is a great chance of a nuclear conflict" (simplifying). And at the same time the ecologists, saying "NO to nuclear power" (I remember this in my childhood in Spain, it was huge). Fuckushima has turned it into what seems a non-negotiable idea at any costs. But notice that some weeks ago the European Commission decided to push for calling nuclear "green" (I agree with this) but also liquified gas (!!).
- jfk13 5y agoYes, it was pretty big. I remember the slogan as "Nuclear power? No thanks!" in the UK.
- ciabattabread 5y agoSo how did France end up being a giant producer of nuclear energy?
- ArnoVW 5y agoThe UK, Germany and the Netherlands had respectively oil, coal and gas reserves. France only had uranium reserves in Africa. Also, de Gaul figured out quickly that without nukes, France would cease to count geopolitically. To build nukes you need a nuclear industry.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> To build nukes you need a nuclear industry. The corollary being, if you want to reduce the chance of nuclear war, you should phase out civilian nuclear power. At the very least, we should limit nuclear energy to only countries that are declared nuclear weapon states. If necessary, the ban could apply to only building new nuclear power plants after some agreed date (e.g. 2045), to give some time to improve battery and other energy storage technologies. Also, the nuclear weapon states should commit to using 10% of their installed capacity on atmospheric carbon capture, as a tax on the privilege of operating that dangerous technology. This would effectively be a carbon dividend for countries that had to forego using nuclear energy.
- pedrocr 5y ago> Nuclear is the quickest path to green, and it's staring us right in our faces. This is held as self-evident in all these discussions on HN and yet all the simulations I've seen have nuclear as way too expensive compared to the alternatives. After someone points that out the discussion shifts to how it's also evident that nuclear is only expensive because of red tape but no one can explain how. We're stuck there as far as I can tell.
- hunterb123 5y ago> ... nuclear is only expensive because of red tape but no one can explain how. Noone ever or you haven't seen it? The over regulation by the NRC and EPA is well documented. https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/costs-benefits-nuclear-regulation/ https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/costs-benefits-...
- pedrocr 5y agoI was trying to synthesize the discussion I've seen here. Your link is interesting but still in line with the discussion I've seen so far. People can point out examples of excessive red-tape in some countries. But no one agrees how much can be removed, because everyone agrees the downside to failing nuclear is grave and needs to be regulated. And since nuclear needs something like a 5 to 10x improvement in cost to be competitive it doesn't seem feasible that just deregulation is the answer. My hypothesis is that nuclear was our best bet to decarbonize the grid 20 or 30 years ago but meanwhile wind and solar have improved so much and are still on such a steep improvement curve that nothing else makes sense. But I'm happy to be convinced otherwise. It would be cool to have a fourth good source of energy in the clean mix and SMRs do sound better than traditional plants.
- fsflover 5y ago> yet all the simulations I've seen have nuclear as way too expensive compared to the alternatives Links? There is evidence that it's expensive because nuclear has to compete with cheap, environment-damaging gas: https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html#conclusions https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html#conclusions.
- leecarraher 5y agoi've been saying this for some time in the US and think it is similar to the reasons we cannot build high speed rail here. Too many points of opposition for a not immediate and obvious benefit (namely lower energy prices, and fewer negative environmental effects). Individual and municipal solar with expensive batteries seems to just fit better with our individualistic and consumer mindsets.
- fsflover 5y ago> Nuclear is the quickest path to green Some related links: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kitkat_new 5y agoNuclear is neither cheap, sustainable (limited resources and storage problem) nor is it quick (takes at least a decade to add it to the grid)
- lispm 5y agoI'm not sure if I would think densely populated western democracies are 'about the best place for nuclear you could imagine'. Currently the best place for nuclear are centrally run countries (China, ...) with a state-owned electricity sector (like France). Bonus points for a nuclear weapons industry or plans for those. > Germany shut their plants down Three nuclear powerplants are currently online in Germany. Their shutdown is planned for the end of the year. > Nuclear is the quickest path to green, and it's staring us right in our faces. That would surprise me. France builds a single nuclear reactor (the EPR at Flamanville) and is late 11 years (start now planned for 2023, instead of 2012). The reactor costs then around 20 billion Euros. Nuclear is slow to build-up and extremely expensive.
- futharkshill 5y ago> It'll solve all of their energy woes without becoming dependent on Russia. Could you stop being so xenophobic?
- alkonaut 5y ago"Without being dependent on countries that dont share the same view on the european security order, integrity of borders, sovereignty of countries and so on" There are many such countries, but there is only one near Europe and its easier to just say "Russia" tbf.
- derriz 5y agoThe whole world is on aggregate bearish on nuclear electricity - its share of global electricity generation has fallen from about 18% in the mid 1990s to about 10% today. The reason is simply economics/cost. In the late 1980s in most of the world, the focus of new generation capacity switched to coal and natural gas as it became obvious that the price of nuclear on a per-MWh basis is multiples of times that of NG in particular. Nuclear is not and never was cheap. The second issue with nuclear is project risk - the industry has a disastrous record for delivering late and way over budget. For example, since 1990 only three new reactors have started operations in the USA. Watts Bar 2 went live in 2016 having originally started construction in 1974 [2]. The other two: Watts Bar 1 and Comanche Peak 2 took nearly 20 years each to go live. These aren't outliers - in Europe, two projects based on the newest 3rd generation reactor design - Flamanville and Olkiluoko - started construction in 2007 and 2005 respectively and both are years over schedule and are now expected to cost 6 and 3 times their budgets respectively. Work on this particular reactor design started in 1990 - which gives you an idea of what's involved in bringing new reactor designs to the commercial reality. A coal or gas plant can be up and running in 2-5 years with no long tails. A solar PV plant or on-shore wind farm can be constructed in a year or two with little or no risk of massive delays and budget overruns. And both options deliver cheaper electricity. It's just too expensive and niche in the modern world. In the age of mass-production where wind turbines and solar PV panels are rolling off assembly lines, the idea of spending $12B (Olkiluoto) or $25B (Flamanville) for a single 1.6GW reactor seems nuts. [1] https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/world-electricity-generation-mix-by-fuel-1971-2019 https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/world-electri... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watts_Bar_Nuclear_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watts_Bar_Nuclear_Plant
- temp-dude-87844 5y agoThe situation is complicated. Some EU member states are pro-nuclear, and some are anti-nuclear. In each state, the predominant popular sentiment may not actually match the current government's policy, but it usually does. France is the most significant player in the pro-nuclear bloc, operating a huge number of nuclear power plants and exporting its technology. France is joined by less populous countries in the eastern half of the EU that operate nuclear power plants to great benefit (Slovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria, Slovenia, Czech Republic, Finland), supplying large proportions of their states' electricity needs [1] from a small number of facilities, and makes them less reliant on import of natural gas from Russia. And, it's joined by bigger countries in the eastern half that want to diversify their generation mix away from coal and not towards Russian-sourced natural gas (Romania, Poland). Opposing nuclear power is Austria, who is a fierce opponent of nuclear power on principle, but has generous hydro capacity to not have to worry about it, and also operates the biggest natural gas interconnection point in the eastern EU [2]. Austria is joined by Luxembourg: anti-nuclear sentiment is very high, it has one the lowest share of renewables in Europe, and probably imports [3] most of its electricity from the coal plants outside Cologne in Germany. They're joined by Germany, where the anti-nuclear Greens party are in the governing coalition, anti-nuclear sentiment is high, plentiful coal exists, natural gas is imported from Russia, Norway, and the Netherlands, and wind and solar have been rising rapidly. They convinced wind-dominated Denmark to support them, along with Portugal, which gets most of its energy from Algerian or Nigerian natural gas, but has significant hydro and wind generation as well. The common link between anti-nuclear countries is that they're well ahead on wind and/or hydro vs. your typical pro-nuclear country, and they have fewer geopolitical concerns about natural gas imports to tide them over until alternative generation replaces most gas. The common link between pro-nuclear countries is that they like the benefits nuclear brings to them, and some of them want more of that. [1] http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/others/european-union.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-pro... [2] https://www.gasconnect.at/en/network-information/at-a-glance/baumgarten-hub https://www.gasconnect.at/en/network-information/at-a-glance... [3] https://www.klyme.online/post/where-does-luxembourg-s-electricity-come-from https://www.klyme.online/post/where-does-luxembourg-s-electr...
- barbazoo 5y agoMany people including me have changed their stance over the years. But unfortunately the Green party in Germany has their roots in de-nuclearization and that alone is probably enough to deter them from changing their policy worrying it would cost them votes.
- merb 5y ago> I don't understand why Europe is being so bearish on nuclear. It'll solve all of their energy woes without becoming dependent on Russia. you are just clueless. > Germany shut their plants down and is now buying LNG. That's a downgrade. > Nuclear is the quickest path to green, and it's staring us right in our faces. you would need both anyway? nuclear does not change the fact that you need LNG. I often hear so many stupid arguments like yours, I wonder where do people think that nuclear means solving energy problems and reducing coal and gas? in fact nuclear solves the base load problem when there is low wind, BUT it's not the reason why germany uses so much coal. germany was always strong on coal and it was political that we neither reduced it as much as we should have. btw. even frances uses tons of lng besides a heavy nuclear user (60% at the moment I'm writing can serve up to 80% of it's energy with nuclear), in fact it's second highest energy is gas.
- echelon 5y ago> you are just clueless. > I often hear so many stupid arguments like yours Not a way to win an argument, even if you have reputable facts. I could have used the rest of your comment without the snark. I enjoy being wrong on HN. It's a quick way to evaluate and possibly update my mental model. It's just not very fun running into your type of attitude.