7 ms·
Don't Be So F*cking Strategic
- TomOfTTB 15y agoIt's good advice but it doesn't address the core problem. The reason "all large companies are in love with finding the right strategy" is because large companies tend to spawn large org charts and the closer people are to the top of that chart the more their job boils down to "build strategy". So not being so f*cking strategic involves far fewer executives. Meaning while the advice is good it doesn't address the actual problem which is getting those Senior VPs to either (a) eliminate their own jobs or (b) start churning out some code. Neither of which seems likely.
- Swizec 15y agoSomething tells me a whole lot of startups could do with not being so fucking strategic and Just Doing It. Actually, I think large companies can afford to be far more strategic than your average startup.
- sriramk 15y agoActually, it's the other way around. Strategy isn't some dirty word that people in suits like to toss around - it is just about deciding what you're going to do. Large companies can afford to dink around with unsuccessful, random projects. Startups have such few resources that you absolutely need to focus and hope you're down the right path. Constantly re-evaluating and 'pivoting' can absolutely be part of your strategy too.
- xtacy 15y agoFrom my very limited experience, my take away from this post is: Extremes are harmful. Be balanced. So: Right ‘strategy’ in place before doing anything Is important, but not at the expense of actually executing it and spending all the time on: reams and reams of text written... I agree it is important to have: Flexibility to do random things But not at the cost of completely doing random things without an end goal. The balance is hard to strike, but is something to strive for!
- sriramk 15y agoPost author here. This is very true. This post was me trying to figure out where the 'right way' to do things lie. Here's the problem. On one hand, you have the lessons from Google being too random and them winding up at 'more wood, fewer arrows' On the other hand, I've seen first hand the effects of a bunch of very smart people focused on one strategy - which happens to be the wrong one. If you look at Microsoft in the early 2000s, their strategy around how to deal with the web and recognizing the threat it posed to Windows is out of the book. I've seen some very smart people articulate why it's the right thing to ignore search and ads in 2004/2005. And obviously, it was horribly wrong. As someone who wants to run a company, I find it fascinating to study how companies deal with these situations and how you can design your culture to avoid it( and without the fix being 'be as talented as Steve Jobs'). I hope the post doesn't come across as bashing MSFT as it isn't about that - MSFT is a good reference model for myself personally since I saw how internal decision making worked there.
- xtacy 15y agoIn hindsight decisions always horribly wrong/right. But more than always being right, I personally think it's more important to step back and admit that you might actually be wrong and take necessary steps to correct. This summer I was at MSFT as an intern, and I was quite surprised to see some groups which take bold steps despite many criticising them. Unfortunately, the overlords with all their experience, should know better.
- thunga 15y agoStrategy should be seen as broad guidelines that help middle management make effective decisions. It is supposed to be a means to reduce communication & decision making overhead. This in turn is supposed to make the large teams more focused & effective. Strategy is a process to reach the target & not a target/goal in itself. Unfortunately, many senior executives think that strategy is all about the end goal & end up creating wrong strategies. Mostly, the middle management will hear these end goal strategies & have no idea about its usefulness. This defeats the purpose & the middle management ends up wasting more time in meetings & wasting more time instead of being more focused.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoStrategies get bogged down when they try to get to specific (which is to say they stray into tactics that are 4 years out, a definite losing proposition) So you strategy might be 'head west' which works you can evaluate your projects against that, but the strategy 'go to San Diego' would cause a project to heading for the Pacific ocean along the Oregon trail to get cancelled since it was too far north. (when in fact it would help you get to San Diego more easily once you were on the coast) The concept is exactly similar to significant digits in science, which is to say understand the experiment and the parameters to know who many significant digits you can count on and don't bother with the rest.
- v21 15y agoThis used to be Google's approach. Make a shit-ton of things, see which ones caught on, then expand them. 20% time, Google Labs etc were all expressions of this. Which they've been moving away from now - as Larry Page says, they're "putting more wood behind fewer arrows".
- sriramk 15y agoPost author here. Google is on the other end of the spectrum ( or used to be). Elsewhere in this thread, someone made a good point of trying to find a balance.
- viscanti 15y agoEric Ries might say that all startups are experiments, but when he does so, he's quoting Steve Blank. It's probably nit-picking, but it seems silly to attribute that line of thought to Ries (as much as I respect him as an authority on Lean Startup). The author should give credit where it's due.
- sriramk 15y agoApologies, I actually didn't know that Steve Blank was the source. Will update post.
- cateye 15y agoLike most words we use for business, strategy is also off course a term from the military. But people confuse the terms "strategy, tactics, technology, operations" and call it all strategy. If you have 500.000 soldiers, someone has to think about how to use this force in a smart way. Otherwise it will be a mess and nobody knows what to do or end up fight each other. There are not a lot of people in an army who can define the strategy. Within the hierarchy there are levels of strategy but then also: people executing > people thinking. In the corporate world, this is the other way around. Following the Dilbert principle, organisations are full of people "analyzing" and "researching" without any mandate or power. This results in endless meetings without any purpose. But it sounds acceptable if they call it "strategy".
- knodi 15y agoThis reminds me of the Joker quote from The Dark Knight; The Joker: Do I really look like a guy with a plan?...I just... do things. The mob has plans, the cops have plans... they're schemers. Schemers trying to control their little worlds. I'm not a schemer. I try to show the schemers how pathetic their attempts to control things really are. This is how I feel about "strategy sessions", these "strategy sessions" are almost always held by businessmen wannabes and lead to nothing but bullshit and guesses presented as facts. Just go out and do it then come back with your findings now you have facts that you can work with.
- sriramk 15y agoThat's nice. That's actually a better analogy than the one I used in my post :)
- cek 15y agoWhile I agree with Sriram's overall point in this post, I think your comment shows there is another point Sriram is making (but not explicitly): Have a plan, but know that no plan survives first contact with the enemy. Planning/strategy sessions can be very, very useful in helping to form a plan early on. They expose ideas and roadblocks and hard questions. They are a MEANS to an end and that END is NOT a strategy. It's a set of hard problems, ideas to pursue, and a framework for making decisions (and sticking to them) that is the END. So don't take Sriram's advice too literally. He's not saying "Don't plan". He's not saying "Don't ever think about strategy". What he's saying is, like everything in life, do it with moderation.
- gkn 15y agoAnd this is why I am doing a start up - and praying we are not growing large(?)
- hammock 15y agoGood strategy combined with good execution is a joy to watch (case in point - Apple over the last decade). I wonder (because I forgot) who did people used to fawn over, or hold up on a pedestal, or revere, or look up to, before Apple came out with the iPod and all this other greatness of the last decade? Who was doing it well before Apple came along and became the go-to example for everything?
- ams6110 15y agoIs that a rhetorical question? I think Bill Gates was certainly one.
- sunir 15y agoGoogle. Before them, Amazon. Before them, Microsoft. Before them, IBM. The industry always wants to emulate the current leader, forgetting that there are a myriad of different strategies available. That's because collectively, given the limited space in news headlines, we're not much smarter than a school of fish. However, individually we can each do better by reading enough history and being focused on and aware of our personal circumstances.
- rhizome 15y agoDell and Microsoft, to an extent, but Apple pretty much invented modern lifestyle computing beginning with the first iPod and OSX 10.3 Panther.
- kubrickslair 15y agoI should also add that do not try to be so f*cking revolutionary. Most products and schemes that aim to be revolutionary seldom end up being that. Apple has been an anomaly. Edit: I should also add that being inside academia, I have seen some stuff which was said to be revolutionary, and indeed did change a lot of things, but only in the narrow scope of academic research. My comment was about the direct real world impact.
- khafra 15y ago> My comment was about the direct real world impact. And also about the value of revolution to the first revolutionaries--it's common to see the first movers fall, and later opportunists capitalize on the momentum they started.
- krashidov 15y agoTo an extent, even Apple practiced the do first, plan later methodology of thinking. They were never planning on going from ipod -> touch screen iphone. As I recall, Steve Jobs has said that he was working on the iPad before the iPhone and thought damn, this would make a hell of a cell phone. Hell, I don't think a strategy session came up with the app store, It was just a creation that fit the moment.
- william42 15y agoI can't help but get a sense that the author is mythologizing and mystifying Apple. Is Apple really that unique?
- philwelch 15y agoDon’t get me wrong. Good strategy combined with good execution is a joy to watch (case in point - Apple over the last decade). The last thing you would want is people off doing their own thing and being all ‘off-strategy’ and rebellious. I think "strategic" is a little elaborate for Apple's actual plans since Jobs took over. Aside from the initial jump from computers to consumer electronics, the only actual strategic decisions Apple made were along the lines of "what products should we try to create?", "does this product still suck or should we release it soon?", and maybe the switch to Intel processors. They didn't fall into the trap of thinking about second-order shit like image or positioning or market or the economy, they just tried to figure out what would be a great product they could make, and what products and concepts were worth pursuing or not.
- ygtckr 15y agoWhich imho is a strategy.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoAre you forgetting about the decision to create Apple's entire retail division, i.e. the Apple Stores? An idea which people thought was ridiculous at the time? Or the abandonment of support for clone hardware? Or the decision to go into the media business by inventing the iTunes store -- but not to rely on media as the primary profit center, but rather as a way of driving sales of extremely profitable hardware? Or the decision to base iOS on Mac OS X, but not to make them exactly the same thing, with the same apps running on both platforms? Or the myriads of strategic decisions around the App Store, such as the strict review policy, or the pricing model? Or even the decision to keep Flash off of iOS, at the possible cost of good relations with Adobe, a company that has traditionally been a bulwark of the Mac OS creative scene? Or are you trying to deny that these are strategic decisions? (Note that this is not meant to be an exhaustive list. For example, Tim Cook's list of strategic manufacturing decisions has got to be twice this size, but it's also composed of items that remain secret, or that I don't know about or understand. But why have companies been struggling for years now to match Apple's hardware prices? That's not a fortunate accident.)
- 15y ago
- drcube 15y agoOff topic, but can we please stop pretending that an asterisk means you didn't just say "fucking"? That is pure superstition. If you're going to use a word, use it. If not, don't. Fuck.
- fastfinner 15y agoI actually think it's politer and more agreeable to use the asterisk. It's akin to presenting a photo of a bare-chest woman with the nipples striked-out with a black line. Everybody knows what is there, but it makes the picture a lot more agreeable and less obscene.
- JohnnyBrown 15y agoPersonally, I find the nipple thing pretty inane as well. I have no idea how anyone benefits from covering them up, especially when it gets to a point where the nipple is the only part of the breast covered.
- starwed 15y agoHeh, I honestly can't tell whether you're serious or not... I will agree that it is exactly the same situation.
- drcube 15y agoIf you know what the word is, an asterisk doesn't hide anything. If you don't (what are you, 3?), there's nothing to hide. I don't think nudity is obscene either, but I can see why people might want to remain private. Just because I know what a nipple looks like doesn't mean I know what YOUR nipple looks like. And of course, to a large segment of the population striking out bare breasts makes the picture a lot less agreeable.
- glenjamin 15y agoI don't really see how its particularly less "obscene", nor how someone who would normally find the picture disagreeable would suddenly find acceptance because of a token gesture censoring a small portion of the photo.
- 15y ago