3 ms·
Some gems in here (and my comments): > I want to fight for equality in full view of reality, please. Yeah, whatever you want to fight for, first look reality
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Some gems in here (and my comments):
> I want to fight for equality in full view of reality, please.
Yeah, whatever you want to fight for, first look reality squarely in the face. If whatever your thing is can't hold up to that, don't bother fighting for it, because you're wasting your time fighting for something that won't work in reality. And we all, sooner or later, have to live in reality. If what you want does stand up, then continue to hold on to reality as you fight for it. Don't pretend that reality doesn't exist as you fight for your thing, because if you do, you won't ever get to your thing being implemented in the real world.
> My old field, writing studies, is filled with academics who believe there is no such thing as being better or worse at writing, which makes you wonder why anyone is paying their salaries.
Stronger: If nobody is better or worse, then why are they the one entitled to make pronouncements? Pronouncements such as "nobody is better or worse"? And why should we believe their pronouncements? Their statements are somewhat self-refuting - their philosophy destroys the credentials by which they expect us to listen to what they say.
> We are already asking the impossible of our education system, expecting it to reward excellence and create equality at the same time. Let’s not burden it even further by pretending we don’t know some people are better and some at worse at school.
Let's ask the possible instead: ask it to take each person as far as they can go. For those who are gifted, help them to soar with their gifts. For those who are ordinary, make the most of their ordinary talents. For those who are below that, still maximize their ability to use what they have.
- Meph504 5y ago> Let's ask the possible instead: ask it to take each person as far as they can go. For those who are gifted, help them to soar with their gifts. For those who are ordinary, make the most of their ordinary talents. For those who are below that, still maximize their ability to use what they have. I think you have to define possible, because what you are describing isn't possible in our current educational model. You currently have class room with students who range from special needs to gifted in the same class. with K-12 typically having a student ratio of 30:1. There is no reasonable way, a single person can be able to manage an individualized learning plan for all of those students across that level of variance. Hell at 30:1 it's hard to manage even generic group learning, and given the abysmal pay, and non-sense localized school boards who push shit like "alternative theories to creation" as required in the curriculum. I don't know that given all that we could call what you suggest possible, as it would mean fundamentally changing the whole system. For the record, I support your concept, just don't think it's currently possible.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI said "possible", not "possible within our current approach". But maybe changing our current approach isn't currently possible politically...