3 ms·
> Yes, you wouldn't be building a steam engine with the tools of Greek artisans in antiquity, not even the ones who built the Antikythera mechanism. Sure you c
by bluGill 5y ago
> Yes, you wouldn't be building a steam engine with the tools of Greek artisans in antiquity, not even the ones who built the Antikythera mechanism.
Sure you could. The antikythera mechanism shows more than enough skill and precision to make a small one. It might only be a toy for the rich though. I'm not sure if you could afford enough metal to make one large enough to do useful work, and even if you could the fuel required might kill it (coal wasn't really available at the time, though knowing it is useful might be enough to find and use it). The metals of the time where not up to a modern high pressure (and thus efficient) steam engine, but a large low pressure steam engine is perfectly possible.
That said, water or wind power would be a much better invention to focus your efforts on. I'm not sure how much of that they had though.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoWindmills date back to the 9th century, water wheels to the 1st or earlier.
- KineticLensman 5y ago> but a large low pressure steam engine is perfectly possible. Irrespective of whether it was possible for the Greeks to make them, what would be the economic incentive for them to build large low pressure steam engines at scale? In our timeline, the only serious application of large low pressure steam engines was pumping water out of mines, from after 1720 or so. Even with the incentive of the industrial revolution, it took almost a century to get small high-powered engines, with the first public steam train in 1825.
- xyzzyz 5y agoMilling grain, hammering wrought iron, crushing ore etc. There were plenty of uses of mechanized power even in antiquity, and the ancients realized that through use of water wheels.
- mywittyname 5y agoI don't think the OP is saying that there wasn't a need for mechanized power, just that it wasn't profitable to get that power from steam. Water wheels have no fuel costs, and very little ongoing maintenance costs. A steam engine that could be built in antiquity would be incredibly expensive in both respects. So even if the technology existed, there would be little economic incentive to use it over a water wheels, since transportation is cheaper than fuel and maintenance. As recently as 1900, steam engines were so expensive that most farmers rented equipment by the day.
- shuntress 5y agoSimple solution: Military industry. Some generals would likely find a mobile mill stone quite useful. When your centuria loot a conquered land they can now take raw grains in addition to processed flour without being tied down to the local stationary mills.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Some generals would likely find a mobile mill stone quite useful. When your centuria loot a conquered land they can now take raw grains in addition to processed flour without being tied down to the local stationary mills. Not in the slightest. The legion on the march has no use for a millstone because nobody's eating bread. They would never carry processed flour, because it spoils quickly. They carried raw grain and made porridge from it.
- shuntress 5y agoThat sounds wrong but I don't know enough about ancient roman military rations to dispute it. Do you have any sources? I thought they primarily consumed bread (both hardtack and leavened), watered down wine/vinegar, and meat (when available.)
- thaumasiotes 5y ago
- dredmorbius 5y agoKeep in mind that those were typically coal mines, that is, the fuel for the pump engines was literally immediately at hand.
- mikewarot 5y agoNo, you couldn't. It wasn't until Wilkinson had perfected his boring machine and Watt had a model of a steam engine that could not be be realized because he couldn't get a precise enough bore, that Wilkinson took it upon himself to bore the first steam engine cylinder that worked. In order to get this, there are a lot of steps involved, including the ability to sand cast and bore iron of sufficient quality to take a reasonable amount of pressure. If you got to that point, you might want to build a Stirling engine instead, it's far less likely to explode and kill people.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWatt's steam engines were vacuum engines, with power on the condensation stroke. High-pressure expansion engines didn't emerge until after Watt's patents expired in 1800. (I believe they may have been introduced a few years earlier in the United States where Watt's patents had no authority.) There was no danger of a Watt engine exploding.
- mikewarot 5y ago>There was no danger of a Watt engine exploding. I learned something new today, thanks for pointing that out.
- bluGill 5y agoI have some knowledge of machining and how to create precision from nothing, though this isn't very common. Lack of precision means worse efficiency, crude steam engines with careful handfitting can work well enough. Though this adds times, and as the other replies note it isn't clear if the Greeks had the fuel to run a modern steam engine if you gave them one with a boiler.