6 ms·
> So a linen weaver would need to work for (500 / 2×40 to 500 / 2×20) 6 to 12 days to earn the price of the simplest linen tunic So translating to modern wages
by wongarsu 5y ago
> So a linen weaver would need to work for (500 / 2×40 to 500 / 2×20) 6 to 12 days to earn the price of the simplest linen tunic
So translating to modern wages (in US/Western Europe) somewhere between $500 and $1500 for the simplest tunic, or between $7000 and $21000 for the finest quality.
That certainly puts the practice of robbers to take people's clothes into perspective.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> $500 and $1500 for the simplest tunic, or between $7000 and $21000 for the finest quality. Go look at the price for a nice suit, or a designer dress. Those numbers are not terribly high.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y ago"Not terribly high," I mean 99.5% of Americans will never spend even the lower end of that range on a single garment. It seems pretty high to me. Also you have to get pretty high up into the luxury market before you'll find a suit that costs $7,000. Armanis are synonymous with luxury suits in the public consciousness and they top out at $4,000, according to their website. The cost of those luxury items don't come from the cost of making them. They come from the fact that they are luxury items -- it's the exclusivity and signaling that you're paying for. For more on this phenomenon see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good
- dharmab 5y ago> I mean 99.5% of Americans will never spend even the lower end of that range on a single garment. Wedding dresses?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoNormal people don't buy $7,000 wedding dresses. Hell, even a lot of rich people don't.
- V99 5y agoThe 'lower end of that range' is $500, and you'll definitely spend that if you're buying a wedding dress.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> The cost of those luxury items don't come from the cost of making them. That's not entirely true, especially when it comes to haute couture. For example, clothes made by a French fashion house may take tens/hundreds of hours to make, at Western European salaries. Yes, agreed, the markup puts the cost into the stratosphere, but the point is that clothes made like this would need to cost thousands of dollars at minimum just to cover the labor (instead of the tens of thousands they sell for). I interpreted the parent's comment of "not terribly high" as meaning not terribly high when compared to modern day clothes that take a similar amount of labor. When you think about it, the amount of manual labor that would need to go into a tunic (shearing wool or picking cotton, washing and spinning the fibers, weaving the cloth, sewing and cutting the garment) is enormous without modern day machines. The reason stuff like fast fashion today is so cheap is not just that it's put together in poor countries (though that's obviously part of it), but that the total amount of labor that goes into something like a shirt or dress is in the the ~10-15 minute range, not the 30-40 hour range.
- naniwaduni 5y agoClothes made by a French fashion house don't cost a lot because they're labor-intensive to make: they're labor-intensive to make because that costs a lot.
- Ericson2314 5y agoVery useful things like big nuclear power plants and subways face somewhat similar issues, though of course the starting point has more unavoidable difficulty.
- Lorin 5y agoThis is what I was looking for in the article, thank you!
- Ensorceled 5y ago> That certainly puts the practice of robbers to take people's clothes into perspective. Also probably the source of the "they'd take the shirt of his back" saying.
- emaginniss 5y agoThe phrase is usually "he'd give you the shirt off his back." That's much nicer
- missedthecue 5y agoand it really has nothing to do with the price of clothing
- dsr_ 5y agoIt does, at least a little. If you give someone a $20 shirt, causing yourself a little embarassment, that's not quite the same commitment to charity as giving them your $20,000 car.
- missedthecue 5y agoThink of it this way; my shirt would have a lot more value to me than value to you. Therefore, if I gave you the shirt off my own back would show a high degree of selflessness. That's what the phrase conveys.
- mhalle 5y agoProbably not. "Steal the shirt off someone's back" means to take everything from a person, even the most basic and least significant item of clothing that they are wearing, and leave them with nothing.
- mynameishere 5y agoModern business suit prices in other words or thereabouts.
- samstave 5y agoWhat were the poor people wearing? How did women earn these - were linen garments a form of payment to effective prostitution? YES: Source; Kimono.
- monkeynotes 5y agoI imagine poor people wore rags, discarded material crudely sewn together.
- xyzzyz 5y agoThe poor would typically make their own clothes. This was of course very labor intensive, but back in the day, benefits from division of labor weren’t that huge, and the poor often did not have better employment opportunities (that’s why they were poor in the first place).
- ajuc 5y ago90%+ worked in farming, and in farming depending on the climate over the year you had months with nothing to do vs months with 16 hours of work a day. The whole system was designed around making sure few people starved and work was distributed around somewhat sensibly with such wild seasonal swings of labour shortage and surplus. So yeah, DIY all the way.
- burntoutfire 5y agoYep. My grandmother's family in rural Poland was still making all their their clothes (from their homegrown linen and sheep) in 1930s.
- vkou 5y ago> What were the poor people wearing? Dollar analysis like 'how much did X cost in a pre-industrial economy' is incredibly unsuitable for answering these kinds of questions. The answer is - most people weren't wage workers. Most people didn't have money. Most people were subsistence peasants, and they paid taxes, rent, and for many services in goods. What money they had would usually go towards buying things they couldn't make. Most people wore homespun. Clothing a typical Roman peasant family[1] would take ~3,000 hours of domestic labour a year - every year, most of it devoted to spinning flax. Being domestic labour, done by the family, for the family, most of it, was, of course, unpaid. Being the kind of labour that you can do on-and-off throughout the day, as you are waiting on other tasks, it was mostly done by women. [2] [1] https://acoup.blog/2021/03/19/collections-clothing-how-did-they-make-it-part-iii-spin-me-right-round/ https://acoup.blog/2021/03/19/collections-clothing-how-did-t... [2] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/distaff https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/distaff
- qwytw 5y agoAn average worker in Ancient Rome is not really comparable to a worker in a modern country (e.g he likely would had spent >50% of his income on food, so equivalent wage would probably below the minimum wage in US). The prices in Diocletian's degree don't really make much sense, e.g. for 40 Denarii you could buy ~5 pounds of beef or only 8 pounds of rye/barley. So likely the price for tunics is quite a bit higher than the real market price. Based on 1st AD prices/wages a tunic cost 15 sestertii which is equal to around 3-4 days wage (a "worker" likely earned ~ 4 sestertii per day)
- zach_garwood 5y agoThe average worker in ancient Rome was a slave.
- qwytw 5y agoThe proportion of slaves in the entire Roman Empire never rose to much more than 15-20% also by 300 AD serfdom had already started to replace slavery in rural areas.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoNo they weren't.
- helloworld11 5y agoDiocletian's price control decrees were for this reason and many others widely hated, widely ignored and widely worthless at stemming rampant inflation. (just as draconian price controls today suffer a similar fate in countries where leaders try to stem the consequences of their own economic mismanagement with arbitrary rules of fluid prices.)
- nabilhat 5y ago> That certainly puts the practice of robbers to take people's clothes into perspective. Cloth was so valuable that the words for both the robber and the extremely valuable robes they stole and plundered share a common origin: https://www.etymonline.com/word/robe#etymonline_v_15128 https://www.etymonline.com/word/robe#etymonline_v_15128
- jrockway 5y agoThis makes me want to set up a tailoring business on the side of the road and call it "Highway Robery"
- ardit33 5y agoYep, in Albanian: Rrobe, means "Cloth". Same origin. It means that 'rober' came from the meaning of 'cloth taker'.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoActually the opposite - the root refers to loot and "robbery" is the direct development from it. Robes the clothing are named after robbery the act of generic theft, not the other way around.
- causi 5y agoI wonder how the longevity compares. Would a tunic last much longer than a modern pair of jeans?
- lstodd 5y agoEven contemporary linen clothes last way longer than a random pair of jeans. It's not that onesided, good linen trousers are usually somewhat more free-fitting, and usually don't chafe as much as typical jeans models. But still. Also superior water vapor exchange is superior.
- asdff 5y agoEven a modern pair of jeans sent to ancient rome would last longer than a modern pair of genes today. All the washing and drying we do is what makes your jeans go threadbare in the knees in a few years time.
- picsao 5y ago
- narrator 5y agoThe enormous cost of clothes is why people in the bible tearing their clothes when they were extremely upset was such a big deal. It'd be like someone today throwing their smartphone in the ocean.
- f1refly 5y agoSmartphones are usually rather cheap. I think it would be more like setting your car on fire.
- BurningFrog 5y agoYou're only 1-4 generations removed from ancestors who only owned one set of clothing, not necessarily including shoes. Something that's stuck in my mind is how prosperity in India, not that many decades ago, meant that women could wash one Sari in the river without being naked, since they now owned two. When I see people complaining about too much "disposable" clothing, I am not impressed.
- tidenly 5y agoYour conclusion doesn't follow. People can be against fast fashions urge for people to constantly be cycling out their wardrobes with short-lived clothing while still supporting everything have what they need. I think that is the main argument - use what we need and no more, or at least reduce waste.