3 ms·
No, you cannot license software as free or open source software while discriminating against a particular organization or field of use. You can write your own
by kragen 5y ago
No, you cannot license software as free or open source software while discriminating against a particular organization or field of use. You can write your own such license, but it will fail to meet criteria like the Open Source Definition, the Free Software Definition, and the Debian Free Software Guidelines.
Also, the DoD in particular has sovereign immunity, so if they infringe your copyright, you somehow find out about it, and you sue them for it in the US, they can just refuse the lawsuit. The best you could do in that case is something like a WTO lawsuit, which, well, I don't think you can get by with less than a million dollars in legal fees. You could sue somebody like Boeing or Lockheed Martin but you're still going to have one hell of an uphill battle there. However, those organizations would probably prefer not to spend tens of thousands of dollars to fight your lawsuit, so they may comply with the license even if they would probably win in court.
- _n_b_ 5y ago> Also, the DoD in particular has sovereign immunity, The federal government has waived its sovereign immunity via statute for specific kinds of lawsuits, including for copyright infringement via 28 U.S.C. 1498(b). There is also a school of thought that says that copyright infringement violates the Fifth Amendment's takings clause, but that has yet to be endorsed (or rejected) convincingly at a federal level. > The best you could do in that case is something like a WTO lawsuit There are WTO disputes, but these can only be brought by one WTO member (e.g., a sovereign government) against another and generally the outcome of WTO disputes does not involve compensation.
- kragen 5y agoThank you for the corrections!