4 ms·
1. The M1 / M1 Pro / Max Single Core Max out at around 5W. On TSMC 5nm, at 3.2Ghz. 2. The AlderLake i9-12900HK, is on Intel 7nm ( Or Intel7 ), runs with a a ma
by ksec 5y ago
1. The M1 / M1 Pro / Max Single Core Max out at around 5W. On TSMC 5nm, at 3.2Ghz.
2. The AlderLake i9-12900HK, is on Intel 7nm ( Or Intel7 ), runs with a a maximum of 5Ghz. My guess the power for single core on this chip is anywhere from 15W to 20W.
3. The Single core performance between the two are about ~5% to 20% if you are SIMD heavy.
There are lots of people in thread and the article linked comparing the system vs system ( the two laptop ) and CPU vs CPU, the two chip. I felt both of them are misguided. On System level it completely ignore the thermal dissipation which is the limiting factor. You could have fitted a GTX 3080 within a 20W cooling allowance and it will show M1 Max winning in every GPU benchmarks. On the CPU level comparing the TDP of both SoC completely neglect the design choice and components inside SoC. The 100W M1 Max includes NPU, Media Engine, 8 Channel ( Or 16 depending how you want to count them ) memory controller, SSD Controller, FPGA and GPU. It doesn't make sense to compare to i9-12900HK only on CPU and then use the total chip TDP.
And then there is the often repeated MultiCore performance( both on Android, and on PC with AMD CPU ). It is a useless number without knowing the power and core number. MSM likes to throw this number out without giving any context.
- runeks 5y ago> The 100W M1 Max includes NPU, Media Engine, 8 Channel ( Or 16 depending how you want to count them ) memory controller, SSD Controller and GPU. It maxes out at 40W, not 100W (according to the Anandtech measurement).
- ksec 5y agoI am sure the 40W is CPU only, excluding other part of the SoC. The M1 Max GPU alone could push to 60W.
- runeks 5y agoNo, they measure it at the wall minus idle usage: https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performance-review/3 https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc... But you’re right that this is not with the GPU loaded.
- ksec 5y agoIt is measured wall minus idle usage during CPU load, which is pretty much CPU load?
- ribit 5y agoThe single core power for ADL at 5Ghz will probably be closer to 25-30W (based on the desktop ADL tests), otherwise couldn't agree more.