49 ms·
Sadly, I don't think the M1 family will clock any higher than it's already going. The rumored M1 Max Duo and M1 Max Quadro will have more cores but they'll stil
by wmf 5y ago
Sadly, I don't think the M1 family will clock any higher than it's already going. The rumored M1 Max Duo and M1 Max Quadro will have more cores but they'll still trail Intel in single-thread performance (although not enough for most people to notice).
- smoldesu 5y agoPrecisely. ARM has traditionally had issues scaling it's clock speed even when given ample cooling and power, history suggests that the only way they'll significantly improve performance is with new fab technology, engineering a better design, or expanding horizontally (eg. adding more cores).
- FateOfNations 5y agoMy understanding is that Apple isn't using ARM IP cores (i.e. ARM Cortex) but just implement the ARM instruction set architecture using their own proprietary CPU core design. Edit: Since the A6-era for CPU cores and and A10/11 for the GPU cores.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoApple has an architectural license, which is why they are so insistent on calling them "Apple Silicon" in branding instead of ARM. The only thing the Apple M1 has in common with ARM is the instruction set. The actual core design? Completely Apple. No Cortex X1s or A73s in there. Apple does use the stock ARM M3 in a few places IIRC but that's a very-low-power ~100mhz part for managing some internals. Also, as for who can push the limits of ARM, Apple appears to know ARM better than ARM knows themselves. Both based on Apple's higher-performing core designs than ARM stock, and also because Apple cofounded ARM with VLSI and Acorn, and an Apple VP was the first CEO. Edit: On that note, it's kind of ironic how every Android phone has the DNA of a company Apple cofounded and initially led.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoAlso, for every Android commentator talking about ARM, consider that Apple even named the company "Advanced RISC Machines," because they opposed having the name of a former competitor in there (because it was originally going to be "Acorn RISC Machine"). Apple also provided almost all the funding and initial leadership for the venture, while Acorn supplied most of the engineers and VLSI the silicon tooling.
- smoldesu 5y agoIt's touching that you reduce me to "Android commentator", but my point is that Apple has a lot of history to spite with their second-gen chips. Whether or not they're engineering their own cores or decided the name of ARM is irrelevant, they simply haven't proven that they can increase their desktop chip performance without packing more cores onto a die and calling it a day. If they manage to make significant single-core gains with their next-generation chips, I'd be impressed. The odds are against them, and their competitors are starting to wake up.
- zepto 5y agoNo. They have in fact increased the performance of their cores with every single generation since the A4. I think the point about Android commentators is that they may not have been following Apple’s silicon development closely enough to know this, especially if they think that the M1 is the first in the line.
- dmitriid 5y ago> may not have been following Apple’s silicon development closely enough to know this, especially if they think that the M1 is the first in the line. It's not just Android commentators. A surprising amount of people have the view that Qualcomm/Google/<whoever> will surely come up with better CPUs in a couple of years. Apple has been doing this for more than 10 years. They probably spent 4 or 5 years designing A4 before it came out. And A4 came out in 2010
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deaddodo 5y ago> Edit: On that note, it's kind of ironic how every Android phone has the DNA of a company Apple cofounded and initially led. You do realize that the ARM architecture existed for almost a decade before Apple was involved, right? From 1981-1990. Apple was involved with ARM Ltd, the company that was formed when the chip division was rolled out of Acorn; not in the design of the original chips. Apple wasn’t significantly involved until the ARM6. Considering Microsoft was as involved with the StrongARM project, most of which has long since been integrated into the mainline ARM architecture, you could argue their DNA is just as integrated. By your logic, at least. > Both based on Apple's higher-performing core designs than ARM stock ARM’s vanilla cores aren’t intended to be high performance cores. They never sought that out until the recently started X-series, which even still isn’t designed to operate in the same envelope as Apple Silicon. Their designs have always been primarily focused on power efficiency with a secondary focus on drop-in generality.
- marcan_42 5y agoI still maintain the M1 Max Quadro is a figment of media imagination. The M1 Max die is designed for precisely two-die usage. Not four. The IRQ controller has registers for two dies. The drivers reference two dies. The whole thing screams two dies everywhere. 4-die Apple Silicon machines will surely come, but not with the M1 Max die. It'll be a new design.
- phinnaeus 5y agoWhat about a dual CPU Mac Pro? Edit: thinking about this for a few more seconds, I realise this is a completely separate discussion, but I was just trying to think how Apple could accomplish the Quad branding even if internally its separate CPUs.
- marcan_42 5y agoHow would you connect the CPUs together then? There's no mechanism for that. You need a bus, IRQ routing, cache coherency, and more. Those features are there in the Max with the d2d interconnect, for up to exactly 2 dies.