10 ms·
Is anybody really all that surprised by this, though? Setting Spotify's deal with JRE aside, removing the show from the platform would set an unenforceable prec
by smoldesu 5y ago
Is anybody really all that surprised by this, though? Setting Spotify's deal with JRE aside, removing the show from the platform would set an unenforceable precedent for the majority of podcasts. If we just start banning people for saying things that go against the status quo, what would we even be left with? A handful of NPR shows minus The Moth Radio Hour?
Joe Rogan is a hilariously bad entertainer and an even worse podcast host, but how could this have gone any other way? If Spotify caved, everyone would have gotten the worst of both worlds: people who don't care would have a diminished Spotify experience while every other artist gets a piece of the virtue-signalling pie, and disenfranchised podcast hosts would just go back to RSS and keep distributing their content to the exact same people.
- dools 5y agoThere's a big difference between "saying things that go against the status quo" and spreading obvious and dangerous misinformation, lies and conspiracy theories.
- dham 5y agoI don't understand this whole misinformation thing that's appeared in the last couple of years. I've seen a ton of documentaries and listened to music that spreads misinformation. Why is doing it on social media different? I'm asking an honest question. Why can't people just listen to what they want?
- notservile 5y ago
- dools 5y agoYes misinformation is nothing new. The type of bullshit I see now being promoted now on social media is no different from the bullshit that used to appear in Weekly World News or Nexus Magazine in the 90s. Hell in "So I Married an Axe Murderer" Mike Myers even does a bit about how his mother reads batshit crazy conspiracy theories and refers to them as "news". Fringe batshit crazy conspiracy theories have always been out there and have always been a space where the far left overlaps with the far right[1]. The problem is that now we have an entire class of politican, forming an increasingly powerful faction in global politics, whose pitch is based on misinformation and it's reinforced by a media network that is increasingly divorced from any sort of regulation or oversight, has the veneer of "news" and the trust that goes with it, but which is just a bunch of sociopaths in equal measures crazy, greedy and stupid, amplifying each other into authenticity. Social media has enabled this, it would have been impossible to do otherwise. Yes the writers of Nexus Magazine could publish something and sell it in the newsagent alongside Time Magazine and National Geographic, but what Social Media does is the equivalent of running Nexus Magazine articles inside Time Magazine, or worse it just lets a whole bunch of people who can imitate rational, educated thought create content that too many people fail to differentiate from actual scholarly or journalistic work. The politicians lend credibility to the shitposters, and the shitposters do the same back. Tucker Carlson, Alex Jones, Tim Pool, Russell Brand, Jordan Peterson, Ted Cruz, Judge Janine, Laura Ingraham, Peta Credlin, Rowan Dean, Pauline Hanson, Malcolm Roberts, George Christiansen, Paul Murray, Rita Pahani, Miranda Devine, Adam Creighton, you name, it, they're all the fucking same, all over the world (I've only cited US and Australia because that's what I'm most familiar with but these same cutouts appear throughout global media and politics). None of them are "telling it like it is", they're just a bunch of big greedy stinking fucking liars, or they're too dumb or too crazy to know that what they're saying is wildly inaccurate. The unifying thread of this dangerous and insidious political movement is libertarianism, which has pitched itself as anti-authoritarian but which is ultimately the most authoritarian form of government imagineable (essentially feudalism) because "liberty" and "freedom from regulation" mean very, very different things when you're super rich than they do when you're super poor. The rebellion against "regulation" has turned into a rebellion against "authority" which has in turn lead to a rebellion against ALL expertise, to the point where football players think they should be able to debunk scientists. [1] https://gen.medium.com/nazi-hippies-when-the-new-age-and-far-right-overlap-d1a6ddcd7be4 https://gen.medium.com/nazi-hippies-when-the-new-age-and-far...
- spencerflem 5y agoSpotify is explicitly paying a huge amount for Joe Rogan to be exclusive.
- savant_penguin 5y agoIf Joe's such a bad entertainer why do you think he has such a gigantic audience?
- nnx 5y agoI'm not sure he's a great entertainer either, but for sure he's a great conversationalist.
- jeffbee 5y agoBecause the median human is as stupid as a rock. As Rolling Stone illustrates today, Joe Rogan is what an idiot thinks a smart person sounds like. https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/jordan-peterson-joe-rogan-interview-climate-change-1290696/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/jordan-pet...
- edgyquant 5y agoThe average person isn’t stupid or dumb and I’ve found when people claim they are it’s usually a projection.
- happytoexplain 5y agoThe average person is not stupid, but the average person is irrational about some topic that has high visibility, usually due to tense emotions. I find that this is usually what people are referring to when they say people are "stupid" - not that they aren't clever or don't have good instincts or are low IQ.
- edgyquant 5y agoThat’s definitely the case, I just take issue with calling them stupid.
- refurb 5y agoIf only we could have the world run exclusively by smart people. Let me guess, you’d be one of them?
- Octabrain 5y ago> …and an even worse podcast host Mmm I’m interested on your reasons for saying that as I think the opposite. He lets the interviewed to talk freely and requests explanations when bullshit claims are made. He never attempts to conduct the interview to follow his way of thinking. It’s a show that surprisingly on these times, doesn’t have an agenda or ideology behind. The show feels like the classic easy going guy from the gym having a innocent conversation with someone who knows about some area. Overall, I think he is a great interviewer and the only thing I could complain is that sometimes he might brings some wacky people, but hell, I have enjoyed a lot of those too.
- nohr 5y agoHe famously does not call out anything lmao. All he does is ask them to talk more.
- steelstraw 5y agoI haven't even watched 5% of his episodes, and yet I've seen him call things out a number of times. Sometimes asking his producer to Google stuff to check in real time. I award your claim with 4 pinocchios.
- rezonant 5y agoDo you think it is conceivable that what the parent comment is pointing out is found... I dunno, somewhere in the other 95% of Rogan's content that you haven't seen?
- steelstraw 5y agoThey are just echoing popular (famous, if you will) misinformation from Twitter. The mob repeats it whenever Rogan trends.
- dham 5y agoYea he asks that Jamie guy to look up stuff all the time. That's all he does lol
- GoldenMonkey 5y agoJoe Rogan has 200 million monthly listeners. And you call him a “worse podcast host”. That is not factually objective.
- smoldesu 5y agoDonald Trump got more than half the country to vote for him, that doesn't make his 4-year tenure any more impressive.
- betwixthewires 5y agoThere are plenty of people that disagree with you on that also. Why should I view your opinion as objective over theirs?