5 ms·
My answer: because most of the math we learn in school is useless. I see a lot of math homework questions on Quora, because students copypaste their homework a
by jfengel 5y ago
My answer: because most of the math we learn in school is useless.
I see a lot of math homework questions on Quora, because students copypaste their homework all the time:
What is log (3x +2)- log2 =1?
How do you prove that X^2-3 is irrational?
What are the roots of the equation x4−4x3+6x2−4x+4=0?
When on earth are you ever going to use any of that?
The word problems are no better.
In a group of 20 adults, 4 out of 7 women and 2 out of 13 men wear glasses. What is the probability that a person chosen at random from the group is a woman or wears glasses?
Mr. Tay had 20 female fish and 5 male fish in a pond. Mr. Tay’s father brought some male fish and put them in the pond. Then he found 1/5 of the fish are female. How many male fish did his father put into the pond?
In a school interhouse competition, 80% of the students turned up for the athletic competition, 60% turned up at the football match. What percentage of the students attended both functions?
These just aren't the kinds of questions anybody ever actually asks. The math required to solve them is pragmatic; are there no pragmatic examples they can come up with?
The fact that students are copypasting their homework doesn't thrill me for their ethics or their intelligence. But the fact that the problems themselves are so stultifyingly dull almost makes it seem reasonable.
- eternityforest 5y agoMaybe they should get engineers to teach math courses the way they wish they had been taught them, rather than math people who sometimes still seem to think we will be doing this without a calculator?
- jfengel 5y agoEngineers have specialty interests. I'd just as soon have it taught by a home economics department, or at worst an MBA. Things everyone should be able to do: read a bill, allocate a budget, estimate how much food to buy for 2 people versus 10 people, plan for retirement, maybe convert a recipe from metric to imperial units. Perhaps get a shop teacher. Let the future STEM majors learn the rest in their classes. It takes a long time for a lot of that stuff to pay off, and much of it remains irrelevant.
- eternityforest 5y agoGiving STEM majors a head start is helpful, and a lot of those things aren't primarily mathematical. I'm not sure what math you need to read bills in the age of specialty apps. I can't remember the last time I needed to do any arithmetic without my phone. Estimating how much food to buy for 2 people requires understanding nutrition science, whether all your guests ate at all today, how much space you have to store leftovers, etc. The only math I can think of is jus t multiplying by number of guests, But then you might have kids or people with dietary restrictions and now half your planning is just individual person by person stuff. Math won't really help you plan a budget either unless you know all the finance specific stuff, or enough fairly advanced general math that it's just all obvious to you. There's way too much estimation of real world stuff and most of the controllable expenses(for an average poor person) are impulse fast food orders and such that they already know are costing a ton. I'm not sure trust an MBA to teach... anything about economics. They are way too high on their positive mindset business optimism attitude to really understand that the cost of getting Starbucks actually is important. A lot of the "Useful real life math" is stuff that people won't use anyway, either because an app does it, or because retirement is later and doordash is right now. Is math actually the most effective tool to make someone want to stop that?