> Suppose a cat had fingers, and basic language ability It would no longer be a cat. That's why "If you (a human) were a cat" is a problem, b/c you need to sa

> Suppose a cat had fingers, and basic language ability It would no longer be a cat. That's why "If you (a human) were a cat" is a problem, b/c you need to say what level of human/cat this hybrid creature is imagined to be. It's like that joke: "Behold! The dog with two heads! and two bodies!"