“When last connected” is supposed to mean “if this phone is the last thing they were connected to when they were put away last time, connect to this phone when

“When last connected” is supposed to mean “if this phone is the last thing they were connected to when they were put away last time, connect to this phone when they are taken back out.” “Never” in that context would mean each time you put them in, you would have to go to your device and manually connect. Of course if that’s not working, that’s a problem, but conceptually I think the options make sense.