3 ms·
> Unfortunately, instead of seeing the absurdity of that situation, many people have gone all "no true Scotsman" on it. "If you were a real Unix Developer then
by rvz 5y ago
> Unfortunately, instead of seeing the absurdity of that situation, many people have gone all "no true Scotsman" on it. "If you were a real Unix Developer then you wouldn't make mistakes like that." We don't need no stinking tools, we're Real Programmers.
That is the problem. Unix, and the 'philosophy'.
I used to like it, but it is over half a century old and as well as everything 'unix-like' it was not designed for security, especially the C programming language. Thus, with everything 'unix-like', they have imported all the mistakes with it. The same with the legacy like X11, allowing root to modify system files, etc.
Unix is dead. Might need to move on from such prehistoric systems to ones that are designed for security that are not 'Unix'.
- posterboy 5y agoIsn't it more of a slippery slope? I want to be able run whatever I want on my system. If I get malicious code, who's fault is it? Maybe my browsing habits, the tasks I want done, the time I can spend on roling my own, the documentation (haha, what documentation), the schools, or the government and AT&T? Who is this real Unix Developer? The Linux Kernel has a stelar track record, just the towers of complexity built around it are growing like the weeds. The kernel isn't making it easy, hardware developers don't play nice, and every one wannabe expert wants it to be just working. There's the actual "No True Scotsman", because capability based kernels exist for a long time now. Yet, users want something to work with, actual software that needs to be written, that doesn't even have to be in C. The expressed sentiment is entirely independent of the domain. You simply need to know what you are doing or things won't move forward. It's only consequential that those whom rely on Unixoid systems for whichever reason do express this sentiment in terms of those systems. The alternative are walled gardens, where criticizm is impossible. Because with secure boot and the like it would require breaking the system to take control.
- pjmlp 5y agoIronically, Multics did continue without Bell Labs and not surprisingly DoD security assessment for it was higher than UNIX with praise for their use of PL/I in preventing memory corruption bugs. But it wasn't available as free tapes for universities to play with, so....