3 ms·

Unconstitutional seems to be a rather stretchable concept lately. Here are all the vaccine mandates in the US today: https://www.immunize.org/laws/ https://www.

• peteradio 5y ago
  Those are states laws. Generally when someone says Unconstitutional without a state qualification they mean Federal Government.
  • cies 5y ago
    That's what I meant, the basic ones like.. right to privacy, freedom of assembly, bodily autonomy.
  • klyrs 5y ago
    That's a rather pointless quibble. State laws that violate the constitution are challenged as unconstitutional, and overturned on that basis. There were antivaxers when the Smallpox virus was rampant. Smallpox is gone, because of vaccine mandates. Public schools require a whole panel of vaccines, both of their employees and students. Until now, that hasn't been seen to violate the constitution. But now, there's a supermajority in the Supreme Court, so really, who knows what the constitution says?
    • CodesInChaos 5y ago
      Not quite. Often the reason that a law is unconstitutional is that the federal government lacks the authority to regulate this, but the same law would be constitutional if created by a state government.
• VWWHFSfQ 5y ago
  USA states make their own laws. Sometimes those laws are challenged as "unconstitional" and then the Supreme Court evaluates and maybe tells them to stop. Most of the time not though. They prefer to "leave it up to the states". The recent OSHA ruling (attempt at broad vaccine mandates for Americans) for instance. The Supreme Court said they can't do that.