3 ms·
My point is that "access to a full kitchen" is not part of the federal government's definition of poverty, at least not the one regarding those who are eligible
by dalke 15y ago
My point is that "access to a full kitchen" is not part of the federal government's definition of poverty, at least not the one regarding those who are eligible for assistance.
Quite simply, it's not a basic need. Someone living in a studio apartment in NYC with a kitchenette, making $80K a year and living there because it's got a great location, is not poor. Someone who can afford to eat out for every meal, and lives in a place with many food offerings, needs no kitchen.
To test your contention, is a family of four living in the US on less than $23,000 per year - that being roughly the CPI-based poverty level using methods relatively unchanged for 40 years - not a reasonable definition of being poor in the US?
If not, what is a reasonable value, and do you have a way to determine that value which is effective for more than a few years? (Since if not, it will be highly subject to political pressure.)
- lotharbot 15y ago> "My point is that "access to a full kitchen" is not part of the federal government's definition of poverty" But it contributes directly to the definition, despite not explicitly being named. Because the definition is tied to CPI, which is tied to housing costs, which are more likely to include the cost of a full kitchen now than in the past especially for people near the bottom. I would argue that for someone in that position, having a full kitchen is better than not. Yet the CPI-based measure treats the cost of having a full kitchen as a negative (inflation), without treating the benefit of the full kitchen as a positive! You keep misrepresenting my position (and asking questions that depend on your misrepresentation). I'm not saying that people now are not poor. I'm not saying the CPI-adjusted threshold is "wrong" for defining who is poor. What I'm saying is that people who are poor now and people who were poor in the past are not directly, numbers-to-numbers comparable. It's meaningless to say that 1.2% more people are poor now than then, because there are meaningful, relevant differences in conditions between now and then that account for far more than a 1.2% difference. The noise washes out the signal.