3 ms·
A significant portion of our economy is post-scarcity. Software, movies, tv, books, video games are all non-scarce goods forced to fit into a scarce framework
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
A significant portion of our economy is post-scarcity. Software, movies, tv, books, video games are all non-scarce goods forced to fit into a scarce framework through IP law. They are distributed horribly inefficiently as a result.
The replicator would transform most physical goods into IP so perhaps a better economy would be structured around efficient and equitable IP creation and distribution, with the few remaining scarce goods hacked into the economy similar to how copyright hacks non-scarce goods into ours.
But there's a flaw in that previous sentence. The replicator uses energy to operate, and that's still a scarce good, even in the 24th. In the 22nd, an iPhone is >95% IP, yet its price is primarily set by the value of the scarce components in an iPhone.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> A significant portion of our economy is post-scarcity. No, it's not. The economy is the system of distribution of scarce resources. Anything that is actually post-scarcity isn't part of it. > Software, movies, tv, books, video games are all non-scarce goods forced to fit into a scarce framework through IP law. No, they aren't. They are goods based around something with a high initial fixed cost and a low marginal cost. IP law exists to incentivize people paying the fixed costs. That's not post-scarcity. > The replicator would transform most physical goods into IP It might change most novel physical goods to having more of their costs as fixed costs, but high initial fixed costs are already a significant thing for novel physical goods and already addressed by IP law. > In the 22nd, an iPhone is >95% IP The 22nd is as much speculative future (or fiction) as the 24th.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoBy your definition "post-scarcity economy" is an oxymoron, and this whole discussion is moot and pointless. If intellectual goods aren't post-scarcity in the 21st century, then nothing in the 24th century is either.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> By your definition "post-scarcity economy" is an oxymoron, and this whole discussion is moot and pointless. Both parts of that are true, but the second isn't because of the first (which is a terminological issue), but that “post-scarcity”, more than just being mutually exclusive with “economy”, appears to be fundamentally incompatible with human nature; there will always be something scarce, competition for it, and disutility driven by relative deprivation with respect to it.