4 ms·
> Walk out onto a public street. Ask the first 3 people you come across if they know how to send a debt validation letter. Report back. One should not need to h
by gruez 5y ago
> Walk out onto a public street. Ask the first 3 people you come across if they know how to send a debt validation letter. Report back. One should not need to have knowledge with consumer credit laws and regulation to navigate exceptions; it's citizen hostile and a developed economy anti pattern imho. Fail citizen safe.
By that logic, other things that are antipatterns:
* most laws (do you think "the first 3 people you come across" would know the difference between murder and manslaughter?)
* programming APIs (ie. the trope of programmers having to search up usages for basic library functions)
* most basic life tasks (this can be literally anything. even how to cook. if your parents didn't teach you, and you couldn't search on the internet, most people would be toast).
- BoorishBears 5y agoYou're literally making their point. The anti-pattern is assuming people should know something domain specific to avoid harm. Should the average person need to know the difference between murder and manslaughter to avoid getting scammed into a murder charge? Should the average programmer have to memorize every API they use to avoid creating the next Heartbleed? And basic life skills is the literal opposite of your other examples...
- gruez 5y ago>Should the average person need to know the difference between murder and manslaughter to avoid getting scammed into a murder charge? While I think "legal system that everyone understands" is a laudable goal, there are too many edge cases and "bad" behaviors for that to be possible. >Should the average programmer have to memorize every API they use to avoid creating the next Heartbleed? I'm not sure why you modified my original argument. Is having impossible-to-use-from-muscle memory APIs totally fine unless they lead to security vulnerabilities? >And basic life skills is the literal opposite of your other examples... in what way? because you assume most people know how to cook? that's because it's knowledge that parents pass down because you need it daily, not because society engineered it to fail safe or whatever.
- mannykannot 5y ago> While I think "legal system that everyone understands" is a laudable goal, there are too many edge cases and "bad" behaviors for that to be possible. This is not the issue here. The issue here is whether there is a better way to handle the problem of fraudulent loans facilitated by identity theft.
- mannykannot 5y ago> Most laws (do you think "the first 3 people you come across" would know the difference between murder and manslaughter?) Personally, I think the chances are much higher of getting a working definition, and toomuchtodo could probably have said 30 people without looking implausible. At this point, you might be thinking that few don't know the precise definitions of manslaughter vs. murder, but consider this: most people (I suspect) at least have an understanding of the difference between manslaughter and murder, while not having the slightest idea of what sort of responses are available to them in the fraudulent loan scenario. Furthermore, while both probabilities are low, I doubt that the likelihood that your average person needs to know the difference between manslaughter and murder is close to the likelihood for being in the sort of situation being discussed here. > Most basic life tasks (this can be literally anything. even how to cook. if your parents didn't teach you, and you couldn't search on the internet, most people would be toast). It never occurred to me, until now, that the human race is perpetually at risk of extinction in one generation for this reason... but has there been one documented fatality, anywhere, at any time, from this cause?
- gruez 5y ago>I doubt that the likelihood that your average person needs to know the difference between manslaughter and murder is close to the likelihood for being in the sort of situation being discussed here. Okay, what about if you want to renovate your house? Is the bureaucracy utterly out of control because you can't legally make modifications to your house without getting a permit from the city? Most people know they have to get a permit, and maybe that they need to go to city hall to get it, but good luck getting a permit without asking someone working there or looking it up the internet.
- mannykannot 5y ago> Most people know they have to get a permit... Indeed.
- Retric 5y agoThat’s moving the goalposts, not knowing it’s possible to do something is quite different than needing to look up how to do something. I suspect the vast majority of people aren’t going to add a major addition to their house without having someone to do the work who knows about permits, or actually knowing about it themselves. It’s like complaining about how few people know seamanship rules when most people don’t own or operate a boat.