3 ms·
> One problem, other comments hint on the same thing, is that poverty is not an absolute, it's relative. Seems like you're just trying to redefine "poverty" to
by gruez 5y ago
> One problem, other comments hint on the same thing, is that poverty is not an absolute, it's relative.
Seems like you're just trying to redefine "poverty" to mean "income inequality". Income inequality is an issue that's worth tackling, but it's also important to recognize absolute standards of living conditions. We already have a term for income inequality, it's called income inequality. It's unclear why you want to redefine "poverty" to also mean "income inequality".
>poverty must be estimated with regard to access to the standards and niceties of the era
That's fine. Other commenters have mentioned tackling about starting to address "basic poverty" after we address "extreme poverty".
- coldtea 5y ago>Seems like you're just trying to redefine "poverty" to mean "income inequality". No, I'm trying to properly define property, instead of leaving it as a hazy term. And this includes income inequality, because what's considered poor is not static (see my example regarding the feudal peasant in their hut, the early 20th century immigrant family, or a modern trailer poor). >It's unclear why you want to redefine "poverty" to also mean "income inequality". It would have been "unclear" if I haven't already given several arguments for it on the comment you've replied to.
- gruez 5y ago>No, I'm trying to properly define property, instead of leaving it as a hazy term. Alright, after looking at the wikipedia article, you're technically correct in the sense that the word only means "poor", therefore people are free to define it in whatever they want (either in relative or absolute sense). However, in the context of international development, it almost always refers to absolute poverty. Even in governmental terms, the use of relative poverty is limited to rich countries. >Since richer nations would have lower levels of absolute poverty,[34][35] relative poverty is considered the "most useful measure for ascertaining poverty rates in wealthy developed nations"[36][37][38][39][40] and is the "most prominent and most-quoted of the EU social inclusion indicators".[41] Taking this into account, I'm still opposed to your initial claim that "poverty is not an absolute, it's relative". There's certainly an absolute component to it, even if countries shift to using relative measure once they get rich enough. Furthermore, since it already means absolute poverty in most contexts, arguing for it to be redefined just causes confusion.
- coldtea 5y ago>There's certainly an absolute component to it, even if countries shift to using relative measure once they get rich enough. Then perhaps to clarify things we should separate the absolute components from the relative ones? For example, I've mentioned hunger (lack of access to food), or similarly for access to healthcare, etc. Those can be quantified absolutely.
- helpfulmandrill 5y agoRelative poverty is a pretty old and standard way of defining poverty. Adam Smith, for example: > “A linen shirt … is, strictly speaking, not a necessary of life. The Greeks and Romans lived, I suppose, very comfortably though they had no linen. But in the present times, through the greater part of Europe, a creditable day-labourer would be ashamed to appear in public without a linen shirt, the want of which would be supposed to denote that disgraceful degree of poverty which, it is presumed, nobody can well fall into without extreme bad conduct.”