4 ms·
One problem, other comments hint on the same thing, is that poverty is not an absolute, it's relative. We would consider ourselves poor if we lived as a family
by coldtea 5y ago
One problem, other comments hint on the same thing, is that poverty is not an absolute, it's relative.
We would consider ourselves poor if we lived as a family of five in a tiny early 20th New York immigrant's appartment, even though we'd be much better off than a feudal peasant living in a straw hut with no electricity and a distant water well (the "working class" of its day), which in turn would be must better off than some early aggrarian iron age person (even an upper class one). So, in some sense, poverty must be estimated with regard to access to the standards and niceties of the era (and is therefore connected to inequality).
In another sense, poverty is also qualitative and cultural, and working as a factory cog in a sweatshop for $3 dollars might be worse than living as part of your traditional tribe (and their lifestyle) for $0 dollars. And yet, we herald people whose native lands have been plundered (or whose local e.g. farm income has been destroyed by cheaper imports) and are forced against their will and to the detriment of their lifestyle, to seek work in the cities as a triumph over poverty.
What can be measured well, is whether we have greatly reduced hunger and childbirth deaths and such metrics.
But poverty is too flexible and abstract a term to say we have "ended" it. Else we'd have already "ended poverty" when we moved from the caves to early cities and huts too - as everybody had raised their income levels and owned goods and such. And yet, poverty just reappeared in a different relative level.
- buscoquadnary 5y agoIn many of the places I have heard of the people who are moving to the sweatshops themselves are rejoicing in the change because the alternatives are subsistence farming or sex work, and staying around with their "tribe".
- coldtea 5y agoOTOH, I have heard of the people who are moving to the sweatshops, that they fought the destruction of their traditional lands and sources of income and ways of life with tooth and nail. That has been historically true from the forced industrialization of British peasants all the way to today, where many of such forced migrations plays are still on (from China and India to Chile and all around Africa) and there are plenty of books on those lamenting their forced entry into sweatshop labor, slums, etc.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe people who work at sweatshops do so because it's a better option than any other in their society.
- coldtea 5y agoIf a burn down your house and farm, and you end up working on a McDonalds or a sweatshop to make ends up, you'd do it too because it's "a better option than any other" for you. Same if your parents took you there, because the state is rigged in favor of the rich guys, which have fucked over their prospects, pocket money that would go for development and infrastructure, sold national resources for cheap to foreign companies that bribed them, and so on. What's the "better option" is not some neutral natural given state. But people who haven't experienced those things, think all is well in the best of all possible worlds, and these sweatshop guys should be thankful for the greay opportunity. (To add insult to injury, more often than not, those people live in the countries benefitting from both exploiting the sweatshop countries to underdevelopment, and from the resulting cheap sweatshop products).
- BurningFrog 5y agoThese imagined scenarios have very little to do with real life in the poor world. Living in the modern rich world it's hard to imagine, but the natural state for humanity is being a dirt poor subsistence farmer. Only since the start of Industrialism 250 years ago have regular people been systematically getting wealthier. In the early industrialized world this path to wealth also started with sweatshops. They were awful, but less awful than the earlier life, life expectancy and wealth grew steadily decade by decade, science and industry prospered, and now we can talk about this on this technological miracle. No society has gotten industrialized without going through a sweatshop phase. It is now happening across Asia and Africa, and I think it's wonderful.
- gruez 5y ago> One problem, other comments hint on the same thing, is that poverty is not an absolute, it's relative. Seems like you're just trying to redefine "poverty" to mean "income inequality". Income inequality is an issue that's worth tackling, but it's also important to recognize absolute standards of living conditions. We already have a term for income inequality, it's called income inequality. It's unclear why you want to redefine "poverty" to also mean "income inequality". >poverty must be estimated with regard to access to the standards and niceties of the era That's fine. Other commenters have mentioned tackling about starting to address "basic poverty" after we address "extreme poverty".
- coldtea 5y ago>Seems like you're just trying to redefine "poverty" to mean "income inequality". No, I'm trying to properly define property, instead of leaving it as a hazy term. And this includes income inequality, because what's considered poor is not static (see my example regarding the feudal peasant in their hut, the early 20th century immigrant family, or a modern trailer poor). >It's unclear why you want to redefine "poverty" to also mean "income inequality". It would have been "unclear" if I haven't already given several arguments for it on the comment you've replied to.
- gruez 5y ago>No, I'm trying to properly define property, instead of leaving it as a hazy term. Alright, after looking at the wikipedia article, you're technically correct in the sense that the word only means "poor", therefore people are free to define it in whatever they want (either in relative or absolute sense). However, in the context of international development, it almost always refers to absolute poverty. Even in governmental terms, the use of relative poverty is limited to rich countries. >Since richer nations would have lower levels of absolute poverty,[34][35] relative poverty is considered the "most useful measure for ascertaining poverty rates in wealthy developed nations"[36][37][38][39][40] and is the "most prominent and most-quoted of the EU social inclusion indicators".[41] Taking this into account, I'm still opposed to your initial claim that "poverty is not an absolute, it's relative". There's certainly an absolute component to it, even if countries shift to using relative measure once they get rich enough. Furthermore, since it already means absolute poverty in most contexts, arguing for it to be redefined just causes confusion.
- slibhb 5y ago"Poverty" (the word) is relative and has a cultural meaning. But it's not clear that we should care about those components of the word/concept. If the poorest person in the world has a car, a home, food, and water, are they poor just because other people have much more? Even if they are, does it really matter? We find poverty viscerally disturbing because it comes with privation. If we get to a point where that is no longer the case, poverty may still exist but perhaps it shouldn't bother us as much.
- goodpoint 5y ago> poverty may still exist but perhaps it shouldn't bother us as much No, constant psychological distress e.g. anxiety about the future is extremely relevant. For example having "home, food and water" without universal healthcare or without personal safety.
- coldtea 5y ago>If the poorest person in the world has a car, a home, food, and water, are they poor just because other people have much more? Yes. And we could ask the same for things the poorest medieval peasant had, that a caveman didn't. Would you say the medieval peasant wasn't poor? >Even if they are, does it really matter? Yes. We're social animals. Here's another way to look at it. Would it be ok if the poorest black person in the world had a car, a home, food, and water, but the poorest white people had much more? If not, why? It would be better than today, no? Because it's racism? But if the same situation is good if we omit the racial qualifiers (which makes it your example, which you claim we should consider ok), why does it turn bad when the subsets are selected racially? I'd argue it was already bad even in your original example (when the rich vs poor dichotomy didn't have the race qualifiers). It's just than in one case it's bad as class+race, and the other it's bad just because of class.
- refurb 5y agoNo it doesn’t matter. As a society we can determine what poverty is. Yes it can change over time, but there is a set standard of living that “isnt poverty”. Now if everyone in society has that standard of living it doesn’t make a different whether someone has 100x more, everyone has a set standard of living that is above poverty.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- keithnz 5y agoThere are actually qualifiers, absolute poverty and relative poverty. Where relative poverty is more about a semi fuzzy baseline whether someone has enough money that they can function in a society without extreme disadvantage, often talked about as inequality. Absolute poverty has a defined amount of $1.90 a day.
- mettamage 5y ago> that poverty is not an absolute In almost every country in the world there are people that: Are almost dying because of a lack of food Are almost dying because of being outside at the wrong time I would call that poor. I am speaking from second hand experience. And I am from The Netherlands, a country with a fairly good welfare system if you know how to deal with a bureaucratic system. There are a few people that can’t deal with that because of whatever undiagnosed issues they have. People with a low and livable income are IMO not poor, depending on if there is a good healthcare system.
- BurningFrog 5y agoYou can think of poverty both in relative and absolute terms. The article is explicitly about absolute poverty, so your arguments around relative poverty are irrelevant for it.