4 ms·
Regulatory capture through the "Fair" Credit Reporting Act. Go read it - they've legislatively exempted themselves from the standard time-honored tort! Similarl
by mindslight 5y ago
Regulatory capture through the "Fair" Credit Reporting Act. Go read it - they've legislatively exempted themselves from the standard time-honored tort! Similarly to how medical providers can nonsensically create post-facto arbitrary bills instead of needing to create contracts like every other industry.
Curiously, political pushes for reform never advocate for getting rid of the corrupt laws, but rather creating a whole new regulatory regime whose corporate giveaways will only become apparent down the line.
- cperciva 5y agoSimilarly to how medical providers can nonsensically create post-facto arbitrary bills instead of sticking to contracts like every other industry. While medical providers do seem to take this to ludicrous, my understanding is that there's an underlaying common law principle concerning actions taken on behalf of someone in an emergency, and it's not just medical providers to whom this applies.
- mindslight 5y agoYes, "unjust enrichment". But it doesn't entitle one to imagine arbitrarily exaggerated prices and demand reimbursement based on them.
- oceanghost 5y agoTwo true stories... When my partner was pregnant, the OBGYN's office would send us small little bills despite us having paid our copay's. The bills ranged from $40-$200 and did not indicate what the bill was for, listing it as something generic "misc services" for instance. I called down there once and asked what the bill was for and the person I spoke to could not tell me. So, I didn't pay any of them switched OBGYN's. Second story, the partner had incredible stomach pain... we ended up in the ER, paid the co-pay, etc. A couple months later I get a bill for 1k for seeing an out of network doctor. I call the insurance company and ask if that's correct and this is what they told me: That the hospital had a habit of sending out fraudulent bills, and that they had a legal settlement with them that they weren't even allowed to contact the patients directly. It was literally just a cash grab.
- InefficientRed 5y ago15 U.S. Code § 1681e(b) reads "Whenever a consumer reporting agency prepares a consumer report it shall follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy of the information concerning the individual about whom the report relates." I know that courts move slowly and judges are often depressingly technological illiterate, but I have absolute confidence that I could put together an incredibly convincing panel of experts who would define "reasonable procedures" in a way that would run wholly afoul of the SOP of the major credit reporting agencies.
- mindslight 5y agoSo don't let me stop you? In general courts are going to have their own standards for such things that differ from your plain language reading, and a stack of paperwork from the surveillance companies' auditors will suffice to meet it. But by all means, go for it! By my quick non-attorney reading I think you'll be arguing under 1681o, and still stuck showing actual financial damages for having been denied a loan or whatever. Point being they've legislated themselves out of the straightforward tort of libel by 1681h (e).