6 ms·
>It’s way past time for banks to start taking responsibility for issuing fraudulent loans. That sounds nice and all, but what would that actually look like in
by gruez 5y ago
>It’s way past time for banks to start taking responsibility for issuing fraudulent loans.
That sounds nice and all, but what would that actually look like in terms of legislation? Legally speaking you're already not responsible for fraudulent loans, and the onus is on the creditor to prove that the debt was actually yours.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoLegally, yes. In practice, debt collectors (which originators of debt of all sorts will quickly dump unpaid debt onto, even medical providers who don't want to wait for patients to cough up the funds due) will take advantage of unsophisticated/financially illiterate citizens to coerce payment, even if there is no obligation to pay. The fix is straightforward: require evidence of the debt upfront, and if you're attempting to collect on debt you can't verify was agreed to by the person you're pursuing, damages are substantial (say, $1M per occurance). Make reporting of violations via the CFPB frictionless. You will see debt originators rapidly standing up robust identity proofing systems (having customers come into a branch with their IDs), and asking Congress to legislate their implementation (Login.gov and similar for private enterprise, with the end game being a usable national ID system such that Estonia has [1]). Tangentially, current risk management in this space between identity and finance sucks. I worked with someone to get liens off their Lexis Nexis Risk Solutions report (which mortgage originators use for compliance purposes with conventional mortgage underwriting guidelines as it relates to foreclosures and real estate fraud) that were on their report for almost 8 years in error. It took a CFPB complaint for Lexis Nexis to remove them with citations from an attorney to state statute, and this data isn't classified as consumer reporting, so it's almost impossible to obtain financial recourse/damages for these occurrences. [1] https://privacyinternational.org/case-study/4737/id-systems-analysed-e-estonia-x-road https://privacyinternational.org/case-study/4737/id-systems-... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29980189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29980189 (HN thread of the above link)
- londons_explore 5y agoThere are a lot of people in the USA without proper identity documentation, or who live under the identity of someone else. I know brothers who share a passport and driving license, and do just one lot of taxes between them. Tightening up identify verification laws will further exclude these people, and may be a net loss for the nation.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoWhat is the realistic solution then? Its time for Americans do the European and developed world thing and use IDs with proper identification methods. And why would you live under someone else's identity? Isn't it identity theft?
- londons_explore 5y agoMaybe because you were never given an identity at birth? Or you are in the country illegally? Or you are trying to escape debt or the law or someone wanting you dead? Maybe you lost all your id documents in a fire and don't have anything left for the government to reissue you an ID. Maybe you've just forgotten who you are due to illness. Plenty of reasons, some more legit than others, but there are a large number of people in this position.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoSomehow the rest of the world can deal with these issues. You can skip any contract the society creates with the same reasons from paying taxes to getting a vaccine.
- xienze 5y agoI always get a kick out of how the same people asking why the US can’t do things every other country does, like single payer healthcare or the metric system will have no end of excuses why the US can’t do that other thing ~every other country does: national ID cards that are used for, among other things, verifying one’s identity when voting.
- ryandrake 5y ago> Make reporting of violations via the CFPB frictionless. Totally agree.. but sending a debt validation letter is already pretty simple. In most cases you can send the scumbag collector a barely-modified form letter and that’s that. I’ve done this twice and it’s pretty painless, but in a perfect world, I wouldn’t be involved at all! Banks need to be forced to stop considering struct { name, address, birthday, ss_number, other_public_info } …to be equivalent to a person, for the purpose of issuing loans. It’s total madness, and honestly I’m shocked that this kind of fraud isn’t even more common. That and struct { acct_no, routing_no } …is enough to withdraw money from my bank account thru ACH! Also lunacy. How are banks allowed to be so crappy? Legislation, plz.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWalk out onto a public street. Ask the first 3 people you come across if they know how to send a debt validation letter. Report back. One should not need to have knowledge with consumer credit laws and regulation to navigate exceptions; it's citizen hostile and a developed economy anti pattern imho. Fail citizen safe. Agree about ACH. The Fed's FedNow instant payment system due out next year should deprecate all that is trash about the ACH rails (switching to a push from a pull model being one of said deficiencies).
- gruez 5y ago> Walk out onto a public street. Ask the first 3 people you come across if they know how to send a debt validation letter. Report back. One should not need to have knowledge with consumer credit laws and regulation to navigate exceptions; it's citizen hostile and a developed economy anti pattern imho. Fail citizen safe. By that logic, other things that are antipatterns: * most laws (do you think "the first 3 people you come across" would know the difference between murder and manslaughter?) * programming APIs (ie. the trope of programmers having to search up usages for basic library functions) * most basic life tasks (this can be literally anything. even how to cook. if your parents didn't teach you, and you couldn't search on the internet, most people would be toast).
- sailfast 5y agoThe complaint system isn’t too terrible to use - at least when I last tried it out for a credit reporting dispute. You’ll likely get a reply from the institution in a week or so, and if they don’t reply in a timely manner it’s a red flag: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/complaint/getting-started/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/complaint/getting-started/
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> if you're attempting to collect on debt you can't verify was agreed to by the person you're pursuing, damages are substantial (say, $1M per occurance) Congratulations, you just outlawed uncollateralised lending to everyone but the super rich. The core idea is sound. But link the payout to actual costs and damages.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoPropose a penalty that is sufficient to deter unscrupulous behavior but not so excessive as to cause lenders to flee the market entirely. If the penalty can be considered the cost of doing business, it is ineffective for its purpose. This is no different than applying KYC and a customer identification program to lending operations.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Propose a penalty that is sufficient to deter unscrupulous behavior but not so excessive as to cause lenders to flee the market entirely Treat it as you suggest: a KYC/AML failure. Public reporting requirements. Liability to the injured (for actual damages). And, if a pattern emerges, license restriction and eventually revocation. A $1mm mandatory penalty will force lenders to settle. (Nobody will spend $100k proving they properly made a $25k loan with a $1mm penalty if they’re wrong or unconvincing.) When customers know that, you get adverse selection. That would shut down the market.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI concede that this is an excellent start to resolving the overarching issue, and prefer the revocation of licensing for repeat offenders versus potentially unreasonable (depending on size of the org) monetary penalties. Appreciate you pointing out my suboptimal initial proposal to solve the problem. I had the usual suspects on my mind when writing that comment (too big to fail finance who buys their way out of every single attempt at accountability). Thank you.
- hnaccount_rng 5y ago
- lr4444lr 5y agoVery simple: any contract between a financial institution and a third party is rescinded and null in whole if the third party was represented by someone else, without power of attorney. Full stop. Burden of proof on the bank to ensure this. They already have a huge apparatus in place to verify creditworthiness and identity. Any attempt to collect once such a complaint is filed should be illegal before it is resolved.
- PeterisP 5y agoAs far as I understand, the major effect of identity theft on the person is the problems with their credit score and thus all kinds of other credit-related activities while the issue is being resolved. I think that at least in parts of Europe the legal solution is a requirement that lenders must get these fraudulent loans off the credit reports within a fairly strict time limit when they're contested in a simple, standardized way, so even if some investigation takes a long time, that does not affect your creditworthiness during that time.
- _jal 5y agoOne easy, but indirect, fix would be to remove the legal special casing that exempts credit reporting companies from libel laws. That would force a number of other changes, and I think they would mostly be positive. Those whose businesses depend on high-volume easy credit may disagree.
- gruez 5y ago> One easy, but indirect, fix would be to remove the legal special casing that exempts credit reporting companies from libel laws. I wonder if this can be bypassed by a warrant canary (or repayment canary)? Basically instead of having creditors report that you defaulted on your debts, creditors will just report whether you opened/closed a line of credit, and whether you're current on it. If you aren't current, then the algorithm assumes you're delinquent. Since you can't compel speech (first amendment), you'll have a very hard time forcing companies to do something.
- vageli 5y agoHas the legality of a warrant canary ever been tested? Commenters on this site often mention that the law is not executed by machine, and so it seems a court would see through this charade.
- buttercraft 5y agoIs it possible to sue for damages as an innocent bystander in these cases? I'm guessing damages are small and not worth pursuing, but is it legally feasible?
- Trias11 5y agoBofA account receiving money was NOT HIS! It would be very easy to verify and confirm for a bank. This should be the end of the story. If bank would've been on a hook - they'd look way more carefully on it.
- vlovich123 5y agoLegally speaking I had someone take out a fraudulent PACE loan which the administrative agency then used to put a lien on my property taxes and I’m still fighting to get that money back. Not necessarily a common problem, but this kind of stuff can pop up in surprising ways where the victim is left cleaning up the mess of the financial institutions involved.