3 ms·
> A government that governs without consent of the governed is illegitimate. This is not exactly a mainstream viewpoint. > For a crystal-clear example, the so
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> A government that governs without consent of the governed is illegitimate.
This is not exactly a mainstream viewpoint.
> For a crystal-clear example, the south under Jim Crow. Unfair laws, unfair enforcement of laws, but I'd be hard-pressed to argue that many of those governments did not have the consent of most of who they governed.
But in the other direction, it's trivially easy to argue that many major governments did not have the consent of the governed. e.g. the Qing dynasty was hated by the Chinese people it ruled.
The consent of the governed is not even a theoretically valid concept as applied to large groups. You rule through force.
- vkou 5y agoYou are correct, it's possible to further expand that definition of legitimacy, to include de-facto legitimacy (I am the guy in charge, I might be in charge because I rule through fear and force, but since I am the guy in charge, I am legitimate.) My point is that it doesn't make much sense to contract the definition of legitimacy. At a minimum, if a government has the consent of the governed, it is legitimate. If it does not, well, we can split hairs about whether or not being a warlord, a king, or some other kind of despot counts.