4 ms·
> We all assumed that governments could/would do a lot more to help. They did. The US gave out trillions in aid, more than any other country except Japan (by G
by astrange 5y ago
> We all assumed that governments could/would do a lot more to help.
They did. The US gave out trillions in aid, more than any other country except Japan (by GDP). If you were unemployed this was at least $2400/month and more if you had children - the end result is that poverty and child hunger went down in 2020 and 2021, not up like you seem to think, and everyone went shopping so hard while they were home it brought inflation back.
The reason people don't seem to know this is that journalists weren't unemployed and so have spent the last year tweeting "the government only gave us $1400 because they want us to die".
- whynotminot 5y agoIt's the strangest disconnect right now between the actual health of the average person's bank account, and the sentiment that everything is terrible. Like GP is talking about insurmountable debt, but the stats show people actually paid down debt/saved money during the pandemic. I can't disagree that doomsday journalism has a played a role here.
- dleslie 5y agoIf the USA is anything like Canada, and I don't know if it is, then there there was a "missing middle" in terms of pandemic support. Here in Canada, if you qualified for CERB, or had social spending (or other luxury spending) cut back, then you're among those who were likely to have saved more or paid down existing debt. For those who did not qualify for CERB, and did not have much pre-existing social/luxury spending, then the pandemic likely hurt them financially. And now with inflation...
- Wiseacre 5y agoOkay now compare the average person's bank account with the average rise in cost of housing.
- astrange 5y agoCost of housing numbers includes imputed rent, which is money you pay to yourself, and so makes you richer. (if you're a homeowner) IIRC a lot of new people became homeowners in 2020 or relocated somewhere cheaper, which is a positive sign. If rent is going up, that should be fixed by building more housing, which the admin is working on.
- Wiseacre 5y agoIt's a positive sign for whom? The economy? Or those struggling to purchase those homes in the first place?
- charwalker 5y agoLike most safety net items, there is a missing middle that makes too much to qualify for support but needs that support to make ends meet. I was close for most of the pandemic as the household earned just enough to miss most basic support options beyond the food bank but not enough to do more than subsist, which is incredibly depressing. Then all costs are going up so a steeper hill to climb this year barring a raise or new job. My work has great benefits/etc, and before the reorg more opportunity, so it's hard to jump.
- kcplate 5y ago> The reason people don't seem to know this is that journalists weren't unemployed and so have spent the last year tweeting "the government only gave us $1400 because they want us to die". This drove me crazy when I saw folks I know on social media expressing the same sentiment. People that I know for a fact did not lose their jobs, actually drove and ate out less (saving thousands)…or some griping and complaining that they did not qualify for the payout due to their income.
- StanislavPetrov 5y agoUnemployment benefits ended long ago, but working people have continued to suffer. People who were forced to quarantine and miss work due to government mandates don't get unemployment. Unemployment is no replacement for the millions of people who saw their children's schools shuttered for a year (or two!!) and were forced to quit their jobs and stay home to take care of their children. Food, energy, rent, health insurance - all the things people need to survive - are up massively year over year, far higher than the meager wage increases seen by some workers. The government gave out trillions. Trillions that ended up in the pockets of the country's wealthiest people, who saw their net wealth double or triple during the pandemic and corporate profits soar while working people fell further under water. Its absolutely astounding how out of touch people who look at macro numbers supplied by the FED and the White House and think that everything is swell. Everything isn't swell. There's a reason that 72% of Americans think the country is heading in the wrong direction. American household debt is at an all time high. Millions of Americans face imminent homelessness as eviction moratoriums are lifted. Its incredibly tone deaf to sing the praises of the economy when its as bad or worse than its been for many or most working people in the country in a century. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/17/world-10-richest-men-see-their-wealth-double-during-covid-pandemic https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jan/17/world-10-ri... https://www.ibtimes.com/american-household-debt-rises-all-time-high-15t-third-quarter-3334544 https://www.ibtimes.com/american-household-debt-rises-all-ti... https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/downhill-divisive-americans-sour-nation-s-direction-new-nbc-news-n1287888 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/downhill-div... https://buffalonews.com/news/local/deluge-of-eviction-cases-expected-as-moratorium-nears-its-end/article_76246282-68e8-11ec-b2ab-fbed05ecec11.html https://buffalonews.com/news/local/deluge-of-eviction-cases-...
- astrange 5y ago> People who were forced to quarantine and miss work due to government mandates don't get unemployment. Yes they did. PUA made them qualify too. Or if they didn't lose their job, there was PPP and child tax credits. > Trillions that ended up in the pockets of the country's wealthiest people, who saw their net wealth double or triple during the pandemic and corporate profits soar while working people fell further under water. No, this didn't actually happen. It looks like their wealth went up if you measure starting from March 2020 when there was a stock market collapse, sure, but poor people's wealth went up and their income has gone up significantly with pay raises since.