5 ms·
The shuttle could cary 29,000kg to orbit, the Falcon 9 can only carry 22,000kg (30% more capacity) plus 8 astronauts (Falcon can only carry 3), and was designed
by jedberg 5y ago
The shuttle could cary 29,000kg to orbit, the Falcon 9 can only carry 22,000kg (30% more capacity) plus 8 astronauts (Falcon can only carry 3), and was designed and built in the 70s.
So yeah the Falcon is an improvement and I'm sure will be better one day, but the Space Shuttle was a huge achievement for its time, and as of today there is no lift system that can match it for both capacity and reusability.
- pfdietz 5y agoAt no point in the history of the Shuttle program would it have been a mistake to shut it down. By any metric, I'd call it a failure.
- cecilpl2 5y agoSlight nitpick - Crew Dragon currently carries 4 crew members and there's no particular reason it couldn't carry more (ie the rocket could handle it).
- avmich 5y ago> The shuttle could cary 29,000kg to orbit Sigh. Where did you get that number? Wikipedia lists 27,500 kg to LEO, but according to Guinness "With a mass of 22,753 kg (50,161 lb), Chandra X-ray Observatory telescope launched on 23 July 1999 is the heaviest satellite the shuttle has ever launched." And I suspect that if the flight required abort and won't reach orbit, the shuttle would have out-of-specification loads at landing, as the payload mass which is safe for landing is less than that.
- avmich 5y ago> the Space Shuttle was a huge achievement for its time Agree. > as of today there is no lift system that can match it for both capacity and reusability Disagree. Falcon Heavy lifts higher payloads - you don't count the orbiter mass itself, do you, just like you don't count the mass of the last stage which actually gets to LEO, right? Reusability was also lacking. SSME was made by Rocketdyne, not Pratt and Whitney, who had somewhat better hydrogen technology, so after each flight SSME had to be disassembled, tested and parts nearing faults (e.g. turbines) had to be replaced. The first stage modules, which dropped to the ocean, had to be cleaned from the sea water, which also isn't an easy rinsing. And of course thermal protection tiles had to be inspected and the broken ones replaced. X-37 is way better here.
- manquer 5y agoIt wasn't rapidly or cheaply reusable, but it was reusable yes ?