6 ms·
> It's clear there is a very low incidence of fraud. No, because we don't know how much fraud people got away with.
by josephcsible 5y ago
> It's clear there is a very low incidence of fraud.
No, because we don't know how much fraud people got away with.
- jfengel 5y agoWe know that people put a fuckton of effort into finding it, and came up empty-handed. So either everybody is really, really good at fraud, or the numbers are really, really tiny.
- josephcsible 5y ago> So either everybody is really, really good at fraud, or the numbers are really, really tiny. False dichotomy. The system is set up such that it's comically easy to commit fraud and incredibly difficult to detect it. Imagine a take-home multiple choice math test that says no calculators are allowed. Would you believe that almost nobody used a calculator on it just because almost nobody got caught doing so? Of course not, because you don't have to be really, really good at cheating to get away with it on a test set up like that.
- eesmith 5y agoIf it's so comically easy, how would you carry it out? How would showing id fix the problem?
- jfengel 5y agoI really hate arguments by analogy. Either the analogy is perfect, in which case the answer is no more visible than it was in the first place, or we're now arguing about the difference between the analogy and the original question. So I'm not going to get sucked into it. If you have a point to make, make it on the original question, not on one you've tuned to give you the answer that you want.
- eesmith 5y agoThe proof that there are ninjas under your bed is that you can't see them. Only ninjas are that good. How is this fraud supposed to occur? Is the ballot to citizen A intercepted, filled-in, signed with a reasonable facsimile of A's signature, and returned? Without A asking noticing the ballot never came, so asking for a second ballot? Do you think receiving multiple ballots purporting to be from A would go unnoticed by the elections office? And the list of who voted is in the public record, so if A didn't vote, and finds that there was a vote in A's name in the last election - or if someone contacts A to double-checks if A actually did vote - then that will stand out too. Must have been ninjas. Only ninjas are that good.
- josephcsible 5y ago> And the list of who voted is in the public record This is news to me, and I'm having a hard time searching for information about it. Can you link me to where this record is? > so if A didn't vote, and finds that there was a vote in A's name in the last election - or if someone contacts A to double-checks if A actually did vote - then that will stand out too. Has there ever been an election at any level that you didn't vote in despite being eligible to? Did you check this public record to make sure nobody voted as you? Has anyone ever contacted you to ask if you actually voted in an election that you did vote in? These things are all possible, sure, but they're rare enough in practice that there's plenty of gaps for fraud to slip through.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This is news to me, and I'm having a hard time searching for information about it. Can you link me to where this record is? It's public record, but it's usually available on request with agreements as to legitimate use. The exact contents differ by state, and the application may be through the state or county election office. There is a rough summary here: https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/access-to-and-use-of-voter-registration-lists.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/access... but it's not entirely accurate (e.g., it doesn’t indicate vote history—whether, not how, a voter voted in particular past elections—is available in CA, but it definitely is. e.g., the Sacramento County request form has a box to check to include it https://elections.saccounty.net/Documents/Application%20to%20Access%20Voter%20Registration%20Information.pdf https://elections.saccounty.net/Documents/Application%20to%2...