4 ms·
I really like music player daemon on Linux. Is foobar actually superior at reproducing sound?
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
I really like music player daemon on Linux. Is foobar actually superior at reproducing sound?
- JohnBooty 5y agoThe result of decoding music files is deterministic and well defined, so essentially: they will all sound the same, unless one of them is screwing something up. Some may handle sample rate conversion better than others. Foobar's FAQ says as much: https://www.foobar2000.org/FAQ https://www.foobar2000.org/FAQ
- out_of_protocol 5y agoOnly if system mixer is bypassed Not sure about linux, but on windows, macos, android difference is huge if you have some good DAC & headphones
- out_of_protocol 5y agofoobar can do bitperfect output. MPD too, given configured properly. A lot of players is missing this option (specifically bypassing system mixer), and it making sound noticably worse. On MacOS situation is dire (there are some players, but their UX is terrible, imo)
- Dah00n 5y agoNo, the quality of the sound itself isn't better. If anything a higher quality pipeline is easier in Linux IMO.
- entropie 5y ago> music player daemon I use it for like 15 years now. No other player is that versatile. Client/Server, very stable, small resource footprint. Recently I used mpd to play audiobooks and live radio streams on my headless server. MPD uses icecast to make the stream available in my local network so I can use chromecast and/or google assistants to listen to the streams. Its more or less running transparent in the background and iam very glad I found this solution.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> MPD uses icecast to make the stream available in my local network What is the latency like? I tried something like this but there was so much lag between a remote control input and player state changes that it was unbearable.
- entropie 5y agoWithin 30 seconds, more like 15. No problem.
- pferde 5y agoI too used MPD in various scenarios for maybe a decade, but sometimes last year it stopped working with pulseaudio, and no amount of tinkering seemed to fix it (other apps worked with PA like a breeze, but not MPD). So I replaced it with Qmmp, and am slowly forgetting about it.