3 ms·
> What if sailing across the uncharted sea makes God angry? most of these examples are not structured as a Chesterton's fence type problem. If there is a proh
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
> What if sailing across the uncharted sea makes God angry?
most of these examples are not structured as a Chesterton's fence type problem.
If there is a prohibition against sailing across the seas in the town's bylaws and you do not know why it is there, then you would have Chesterton's fence. You would then do investigation until you found an old letter from the mayor about his indigestion and a bad dream that told him that sailing across the seas made God angry.
Then as making God angry is understood as not a reasonable prohibition and the mayor's indigestion not sufficient cause for anything (especially as that mayor died years ago) it would be concluded that you could then sail.
The next day God will of course smite you and everyone in the town, but thems the breaks.
on edit: fix typo, fix grammar