3 ms·
My 'personal bias' is better phrased as 'direct personal experience of investigating these claims in depth'. What makes you so sure these social bot campaigns r
by mike_hearn 5y ago
My 'personal bias' is better phrased as 'direct personal experience of investigating these claims in depth'. What makes you so sure these social bot campaigns really exist? Because a journalist told you?
"I don't think a serious outlet would claim you can "rewrite people's politics with hashtags"
That is exactly the claim made by some social bot research papers. Until you spend some time reading the literature I don't think it's a great idea to form strong opinions about this field.
Try watching the talk version of this paper: https://archive.org/details/hopeconf2020/20200726_2000_People_Are_Not_Bots.mp4 https://archive.org/details/hopeconf2020/20200726_2000_Peopl...
In particular the section where he starts talking about causality inversion addresses this.
"the precise scale or effectiveness isn't super important"
Taxpayers are paying for this bad research because granting bodies and academic administrators incorrectly believe that it's a large and important problem. They believe that because they can't reliably detect pseudo-scientific research, which seems pretty important to me. Our money should be spent on researching things that are both real and important.
"Social bots" is a very poorly defined term (this is one of the issues with the research field as a whole) but generally means automated accounts that pretend to be real people, but which aren't, and which are engaging on social media to influence politics. A lot of claims about social bots imply Russia has developed general AI far in advance of anything in the west and is keeping it a secret just so they can troll Twitter, which is a bizarre and absurd claim on its face - probably why it's rarely stated outright, just implied.
"Spam bot" is easier to define because there's no implication of intelligence. Just getting a link to your webshop out there is sufficient.
Tools that help firms and people manage a single Twitter/FB account aren't a part of either definition.