3 ms·
I don't think you're entirely wrong but I think there is a big question of how prone an algorithm is to gaming and what measures the company provides to adjust
by acdha 5y ago
I don't think you're entirely wrong but I think there is a big question of how prone an algorithm is to gaming and what measures the company provides to adjust it. For example, a simple chronological feed has drawbacks — your buddy in Europe posted something while you were asleep — but it also has advantages like not directing people to click-bait.
The fake news glut came from several areas where the major social media companies really weren't even trying:
1. Provide true negative feedback mechanisms: Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc. rewarded content which got clicks without having corrective mechanisms which actually worked. That provided a big incentive to crank out cheap agitprop since there was basically no way where you'd lose money as long as your costs were low enough. That also lead to a glut of ripping off other people's content, which appeared to be pretty safe as long as you weren't ripping off a major media company. They have a bit of a feedback loop now but enforcement is still quite lax and the algorithms will continue promoting things to strangers even after a lot of people mark them as junk or block the account. Not promoting things on behalf of your friends (e.g. Twitter making Likes public) or otherwise tamping down the “recommend this to other people” signal would be a good way to reduce spread without preventing anyone from seeing content they're actively looking for.
2. People could open accounts pretending to be media sources or authoritative in some way and on the off chance that the companies eventually did something, they'd just re-open a new one. A lot of the impact of fake news sites could have been reduced by requiring non-personal accounts to list verified ownership, country, etc. and other pages owned by the same entity — that'd both make it easier for people to see that Red White and Blue Breaking News is actually some random person in Macedonia and it'd increase the consequences of breaking the rules if you had to, say, burn something like a Dun & Bradstreet number rather than just creating a new page or getting another burner email address. It certainly wouldn't solve every problem but increasing the costs of bulk content-mill operations would make that business less profitable without preventing more legitimate businesses.