8 ms·
I can't give a cite for the following I read it in either a newspaper or magazine probably 30+ years ago. There was a school district in a small town that for
by tzs 5y ago
I can't give a cite for the following I read it in either a newspaper or magazine probably 30+ years ago.
There was a school district in a small town that for the first time gave IQ tests to all of the children in some younger age group, I think around 7 or 8. The results showed a several point difference between the white kids and the Black kids. The district wrote this off as due to cultural bias in the tests.
One teacher decided to look deeper to see if there could be some other factor that could explain the difference. What that teacher found was that in this district all of the white kids lived in suburban single family homes that had been recently built, and all of the Black kids lives in decades old apartment buildings.
In particular, the white kids' homes at all been built after we stopped using lead point, and the Black kids' homes were all built before that.
The kids were tested for lead exposure, and it turned out all the Black kids and none of the white kids had high lead levels. That lead to (no pun intended) cleaning up the environments in the old apartments and treating the Black kids for their high lead levels.
This was caught early enough for these kids to prevent permanent damage, and when tested a few years later the IQ gap had largely disappeared, and the Black kids were doing as well as the white kids in school which they had not been before being treated for their lead exposure.
- pgt 5y agoSimpson’s Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox
- sjhuang26 5y agoI am wondering how this could be Simpson's Paradox.
- OscarCunningham 5y agoYou could force it into that mould by saying that the black kids were at least as smart as the white kids within the two groups (exposed to lead, not exposed to lead) but they were less smart when the two groups were combined.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> The district wrote this off as due to cultural bias in the tests. They did not rule this out? Could still have been a contributing factor.
- dahfizz 5y agoThey didn't rule it in either. They chose to ignore the results of the test instead of search for a tangible explaination.
- zweiterlinde 5y agoNot a small town, but the Philadelphia Tooth Fairy Project sounds similar: https://www.inquirer.com/philly/blogs/public_health/The-Philadelphia-Tooth-Fairy-Project.html https://www.inquirer.com/philly/blogs/public_health/The-Phil... I first learned about this from Radiolab: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/g-problem-space https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/g-pro...
- dTal 5y agoThis is an excellent cautionary tale against lazily attributing politically inconvenient data to testing bias (which remains fashionable). It may seem like an easy way out, but it also offers an excuse to simply ignore the problem, which perpetuates it.
- Aunche 5y agoBlaming testing bias is a great way to gain support from disadvantaged minorities without having to actually do any meaningful work. Conveniently, it allows allows the elite to exclude the educated bourgeoisie from their elite institutions, instead replacing them with underqualified candidates who pose no real threat to the power hierarchy.
- jjeaff 5y agoI guess. But seems to me that if you are going to claim testing bias, then you have some work to do in creating an unbiased test.
- bsuvc 5y agoNo. The plan is to eliminate testing altogether. https://edsource.org/2021/university-of-california-sticks-with-test-free-admissions-wont-replace-sat-and-act-with-new-standardized-test/663870?amp=1 https://edsource.org/2021/university-of-california-sticks-wi...
- mistrial9 5y agodefinite "maybe" on that.. the statement "it allows" is made with certainty, yet at most, that is only part of one possible scenario.. among many
- ip26 5y agoIt isn't necessarily just laziness. The first step to fixing the problem means accepting the results, which in this case meant accepting a certain racial group of (silently lead-poisoned) kids had measurably lower intelligence. I don't think I need to explain why that is a minefield.
- dfadsadsf 5y agoWhile it's uplifting story and I can easily believe that higher lead exposure for Black kids over white kids led to lower IQ results in tests in that specific case, there are no school districts in US with no gap between white and Black students. So far there has not been identified single parameter that explains White/Black gap and not for the lack of trying.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoIsn't there an IQ gap between poor people and wealthy? Isn't a large chunck of that attributable to healthcare, nutricion, schooling, stress, pollution, etc, etc.? Aren't those same factors going to show up in racial differences?
- ruined 5y agoyes, yes, yes. stress in particular has a measurable impact on cognition, behavior, and motor development. even prenatal maternal stress. https://www.nber.org/papers/w18422 https://www.nber.org/papers/w18422 parental leave, cash and food support, and other assistance during pregnancy and childhood, are probably one of the easiest policy wins towards improving outcomes for a huge segment of the population. better schools with smaller class sizes and individualized support for each student would be the next step.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoHaving it repeatedly drilled into you your entire life from birth that you'll never succeed without the pity and generosity of a few benevolent saviors among a sea of hateful racists who are this this all-powerful/privileged alien race that surrounds you (assuming you manage to dodge all the police bullets flying at you) because the system has been created to keep you down, and therefore any success you do have you owe to those people, would be extremely stressful and demoralizing. You could be on to something here. I've seen many other factors like education and wealth being adjusted for but not this. I wonder if anyone has attempted to quantify the damage this causes.
- 5y ago
- hammock 5y agoWhat is the vector for lead exposure from paint? Do we think they are all eating it, or that their parents/landlords are constantly sanding it for some reason and not simply painting over it? edit: Why am I being downvoted?
- alexilliamson 5y agoIn New Orleans at least, there is a ton of lead in the soil. When I was working for the City, playgrounds were prime targets for remediation.
- beerandt 5y agoYou shouldn't be. Lead paint in-situ isn't dangerous. Disturbing lead paint is dangerous. Mitigation/ removal of lead paint is more of a danger than the original risk.
- kube-system 5y agoNormal wear and tear?
- tzs 5y ago"Most lead poisoning in children results from eating chips of deteriorating lead-based paint" [1]. [1] https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/lead-poisoning/symptoms-causes/syc-20354717 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/lead-poisonin...
- foobarian 5y agoRight. It doesn't pass the sniff-test that a whole 1/3 of world's children would be getting poisoned through ingesting paint chips. I'm as curious as the GP about what the actual vector is, but it seems that per the article there really is not enough data to say definitively.
- woodruffw 5y agoMy understanding (from growing up in an old apartment with lead and asbestos everywhere) is that, even your children aren't picking lead chips off of the wall, they're being exposed to pulverized paint dust when they e.g. play on the floor. It's apparently especially common when children's rooms have openable windows, since windowsills shed their paint easily.
- carapace 5y agoThere used to be a whole stereotype around "lazy Southerners" that turned out to be a massive hookworm infestation! > ...victims succumbed to an insatiable exhaustion and an impenetrable haziness of the mind that some called stupidity. Adults neglected their fields and children grew pale and listless. Victims developed grossly distended bellies and “angel wings”—emaciated shoulder blades accentuated by hunching. All gazed out dully from sunken sockets with a telltale “fish-eye” stare. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/how-a-worm-gave-the-south-a-bad-name/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/how-a-worm-gave-the-so... > In 1899, American zoologist Charles Wardell Stiles identified progressive pernicious anemia seen in the southern United States as being caused by the hookworm A. duodenale. Testing in the 1900s revealed very heavy infestations in school-age children. > On October 26, 1909 the Rockefeller Sanitary Commission for the Eradication of Hookworm Disease was organized as a result of a gift of US$1 million from John D. Rockefeller, Sr. The five-year program was a remarkable success and a great contribution to the United States' public health, instilling public education, medication, field work and modern government health departments in eleven southern states.[45] The hookworm exhibit was a prominent part of the 1910 Mississippi state fair. > The commission found that an average of 40% of school-aged children were infected with hookworm. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hookworm_infection#Eradication_programmes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hookworm_infection#Eradication...
- selimthegrim 5y agoAlso changes in the way corn was processed after the Civil War exacerbated pellagra.
- carapace 5y agoAh... I hadn't heard about that: > Pellagra was first reported in 1902 in the United States, and has "caused more deaths than any other nutrition-related disease in American history", reaching epidemic proportions in the American South during the early 1900s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellagra#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellagra#United_States
- thaumasiotes 5y ago
- Scramblejams 5y agoThat lead to (no pun intended) Apologies for an OT nitpick: the past tense of "lead" is "led."
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> There was a school district in a small town that for the first time gave IQ tests to all of the children in some younger age group, I think around 7 or 8. The results showed a several point difference between the white kids and the Black kids. The district wrote this off as due to cultural bias in the tests. > One teacher decided to look deeper to see if there could be some other factor that could explain the difference. A "several point difference" sounds like an unusually narrow gap - depressed white scores, maybe? On an unbiased test with no environmental problems, you'd expect to see a gap of around 15 IQ points.
- aaron695 5y ago
- planetsprite 5y agoPeople underestimate just how much minor public health measures can dramatically improve livelihood and overall prosperity. Before the advent of iodized salt, the prevalence of goiter in certain cities in Michigan was as high as 60%. This also led to various mental deficiencies in people in those regions. It turns out this was a direct consequence of the soil in the Midwest being naturally deficient in iodine, leading to drinking water not naturally supplementing the diet of those who lived there. Iodized salt, introduced in the 1920s, almost completely eradicated goiter in the developing world. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3509517/#:~:text=During%20the%20draft%20for%20World,Selective%20Service%20regulations%20%5B12%5D https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3509517/#:~:tex....
- CheezeIt 5y ago> I can't give a cite for the following Because this did not actually happen.
- bobwaycott 5y ago> That lead to (no pun intended) … The correct form here is led, even though it ruins the potential pun. :)
- 908B64B197 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]