3 ms·
Nelson seems to have been using a Rigol benchtop scope and some proprietary software that came with his generic logic analyzer. But from long experience I'm wa
by kragen 5y ago
Nelson seems to have been using a Rigol benchtop scope and some proprietary software that came with his generic logic analyzer. But from long experience I'm wary of investing my time in proprietary vendor tools.
Does anyone have a good overview of the free-software signal-analyzer-software/oscilloscope-software landscape? I've played with sigrok a little bit, enough to get it to decode some PS/2 signals I captured on an Arduino. OpenHantek looks pretty great over in oscilloscope-land. What else is out there, and what's better or worse, or why?
- adamzegelin 5y agoCheck out Sigrok: https://www.sigrok.org https://www.sigrok.org
- rasz 5y agohttps://sigrok.org/wiki/Kingst_LA2016 https://sigrok.org/wiki/Kingst_LA2016 to be exact. LA1016 is supported, but LA1010 seems to be even more cut down version. Indeed teardown reveals https://blog.lvu.kr/kingst-la1010-logic-analyzer/ https://blog.lvu.kr/kingst-la1010-logic-analyzer/ is using older FPGA and no dedicated memory buffer. Compare to LA1016 https://www.cnx-software.com/2014/12/30/la1016-la2016-and-la5016-logic-analyzers-cost-as-low-as-44/ https://www.cnx-software.com/2014/12/30/la1016-la2016-and-la... > 100 m @ 3 channels, 50 m @ 6 channels, 32 m @ 9 channels, 16 m @ 16 channels all <40MB/s, so its purely streaming LA like original Salea. Edit: ah, so its further optimized https://sigrok.org/wiki/KingST_KQS3506-LA16100 https://sigrok.org/wiki/KingST_KQS3506-LA16100 direct Salea logic16 clone, everything makes sense.
- satya71 5y agoHaven’t used them ever, but Red Pitaya[1] had a compelling pitch. [1] https://redpitaya.com/ https://redpitaya.com/
- hackerlytest 5y agoThanks for the link.
- erwincoumans 5y agoCheck out this DSO: https://www.tindie.com/products/earth_people_technology/open-source-digital-storage-oscilloscope-4-ch/ https://www.tindie.com/products/earth_people_technology/open... btw, some people tried to reverse engineer and rewrite the firmware for this Rigol https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/rigol-ds10xxz-firmware-re-write/?all https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/rigol-ds10xxz-firmwar...
- mcshicks 5y agoYou might try asking your question over at the eevblog forum. I have a Rigol scope and when I wanted to use a linux host I found a driver for it over there. So in terms of host side options there is quite a bit. I think this was the one I used[1]. For myself the cost and performance of the hardware usually outweighs anything else. I also have an analog discovery 2 (diligent) and it seems like they have some open source offering as well[2] (which I haven't tried). They do have a linux client for their host side which was good enough for me. [1] https://github.com/wd5gnr/qrigol https://github.com/wd5gnr/qrigol [2] https://github.com/Digilent/waveforms-live https://github.com/Digilent/waveforms-live
- rzzzt 5y agoI've read nice things... a long time ago about the Bus Pirate wrt. protocol analysis/exploration (maybe not for high speeds): http://dangerousprototypes.com/docs/Bus_Pirate http://dangerousprototypes.com/docs/Bus_Pirate
- blutack 5y agoI have a Siglent SDS1104X-E scope, it's a step up from the typical Rigol DS1* in my opinion in both use and features. I've also had the Rigol DS2x and Keysight DS3x series at work, and various Picoscope PC scopes. Stuff I find better with benchtops: - display update rates (I've caught random glitches I would never have been on a PC scope) - sample buffers - display options (persistent, colouring etc) - segmented capture modes (Siglent call it "history) - protocol triggering, which is incredibly useful for working with UART/CAN/SPI etc. Keysight nailed this. - glitch triggering - just triggering in general - realtime online protocol decode - user interface (in terms of having knobs and buttons rather than clicking on stuff) Basically, I use my scope a lot as a more powerful logic analyzer for signals using less than 4 channels. I do have a backup LA, and Sigrok/Pulseview are fantastic when required (and support a lot more protocols). But a logic analyzer is never going to show you if you've got signal integrity issues. As to why there aren't any open source benchtop scopes, good point. At least my Siglent is Zynq based with Linux for the UI/rendering/networking and FPGA for the quicker bits. The Keysight's have custom ASICs. Bunny's Novena could be a good start towards the hardware.