3 ms·
It works well enough wrt. Black people in the North, where pervasive segregation and disenfranchisement weren't as much of a factor. Mind you, the Democrat coa
by zozbot234 5y ago
It works well enough wrt. Black people in the North, where pervasive segregation and disenfranchisement weren't as much of a factor. Mind you, the Democrat coalition GP describes was not an easy one; there was plenty of conflict between often racist labor unions and the Black minority. But the new-comer Blacks in non-segregationist states shared enough commonality of interest with non-elite Whites and immigrants that, on balance, they were willing to join that political group.
- tptacek 5y agoIf you constrict the logic to the north, then the electoral college isn't doing the thing Rayiner says it's doing; the logic stops working in a different way.
- zozbot234 5y agoRayiner seems to be saying that the electoral college ended up benefiting minorities and Blacks, compared to the alternative of not having one. You admit that Democrats outside the former south did not really care about ending segregation for quite some time (by which time the Civil Rights reforms could also count on critically important support from the non-urban-elite faction of 'Stalwart' Republicans), so I'm not sure what would change if we did not "constrict" the logic to the North. Southern disenfranchisement of Black voters simply did not face any kind of unified opposition outside the south prior to the Civil Rights reforms, least of all among Democrats themselves.
- tptacek 5y agoThe rural Democrats Rayiner says were the beneficiaries of the electoral college were segregationists. The northern Democrats who opposed segregation were not beneficiaries of the electoral college.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis applied to the 'Solid south', but there was plenty of Democrat representation in the more contested states, specifically the Midwest. By contrast, the Northeastern U.S., not generally regarded as "benefiting" from the Electoral College system, were a stronghold of elite, urban, Progressive-leaning Republicans.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not disputing that there were Republicans of the era working to end segregation; I'm disputing that the electoral college worked to the advantage of civil rights. It did not. Had a Republican won a solid south seat of the era, they'd have voted against civil rights as well (and that's exactly what happened after the failure of the Dixiecrat movement). This is a political science dispute, not a partisan one.
- zozbot234 5y agoSome of those Republicans in office were in fact from the South. U.S. Senators Joseph I. France, John Marshall Butler, John Sherman Cooper and Thruston Ballard Morton come to mind; there might have been others. Of course those were exceptions; you couldn't get a truly "solid" policy stance against segregation without other pre-conditions and reforms - in essence, attacking the damaging, backward-looking "Lost Cause" mindset at its root by fostering a truly viable and even honorable alternative. This is exactly what was not done, or for that matter even tried, post-Civil War. For better or for worse, the "Lost Cause" was turned into a self-fulfilling prophecy. The Civil Rights laws then forced the issue and the South managed to turn itself around, redefining itself around a new set of values.