3 ms·
Go look at the state populations in 1789. The small states and big states were roughly evenly divided between free states and slave states. Anti-majoritarian s
by rayiner 5y ago
Go look at the state populations in 1789. The small states and big states were roughly evenly divided between free states and slave states.
Anti-majoritarian structures have nothing to do with "white men." They exist in many countries, like Switzerland, where the voters are overwhelmingly white. Indeed, for most of the 20th century, the Electoral College benefitted Black people and immigrants, because rural states voted Democrat. The FDR coalition featured rural whites and minorities against affluent coastal elites.
- tptacek 5y agoWait, hold on. That logic doesn't work at all. For most of the 20th century, the Democratic party included the nation's staunchest supporters of Jim Crow. The Democratic and Republican parties of the first have of the 20th century have almost no relationship whatsoever to their modern incarnations --- we were, for much of the 20th century, effectively a four-party state, with two major factions of both major parties. The institutional Democratic party didn't even meaningfully challenge the segregationist solid south until '48, and Thurmond didn't switch parties until the '60s.
- zozbot234 5y agoIt works well enough wrt. Black people in the North, where pervasive segregation and disenfranchisement weren't as much of a factor. Mind you, the Democrat coalition GP describes was not an easy one; there was plenty of conflict between often racist labor unions and the Black minority. But the new-comer Blacks in non-segregationist states shared enough commonality of interest with non-elite Whites and immigrants that, on balance, they were willing to join that political group.
- tptacek 5y agoIf you constrict the logic to the north, then the electoral college isn't doing the thing Rayiner says it's doing; the logic stops working in a different way.
- zozbot234 5y agoRayiner seems to be saying that the electoral college ended up benefiting minorities and Blacks, compared to the alternative of not having one. You admit that Democrats outside the former south did not really care about ending segregation for quite some time (by which time the Civil Rights reforms could also count on critically important support from the non-urban-elite faction of 'Stalwart' Republicans), so I'm not sure what would change if we did not "constrict" the logic to the North. Southern disenfranchisement of Black voters simply did not face any kind of unified opposition outside the south prior to the Civil Rights reforms, least of all among Democrats themselves.
- tptacek 5y agoThe rural Democrats Rayiner says were the beneficiaries of the electoral college were segregationists. The northern Democrats who opposed segregation were not beneficiaries of the electoral college.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis applied to the 'Solid south', but there was plenty of Democrat representation in the more contested states, specifically the Midwest. By contrast, the Northeastern U.S., not generally regarded as "benefiting" from the Electoral College system, were a stronghold of elite, urban, Progressive-leaning Republicans.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not disputing that there were Republicans of the era working to end segregation; I'm disputing that the electoral college worked to the advantage of civil rights. It did not. Had a Republican won a solid south seat of the era, they'd have voted against civil rights as well (and that's exactly what happened after the failure of the Dixiecrat movement). This is a political science dispute, not a partisan one.
- zozbot234 5y ago
- rayiner 5y ago> The Democratic and Republican parties of the first have of the 20th century have almost no relationship whatsoever to their modern incarnations That's a big overstatement, which is apparent given how often modern Democrats reference FDR. The segregationist wing of the Democratic Party was still recognizably Democrats in many respects. They favored labor, they favored a bigger government that invested in infrastructure in the rural south, where many Black people lived. Italian and Irish immigrants were a major constituency. There is a reason Black people started voting Democrat in the 1930s, even though the party opposed civil rights until the 1960s. They joined the FDR coalition of minorities, rural, and working class whites against affluent white elites. The electoral college naturally puts a thumb on the scale against wealthy urban population centers. Ordinarily, that's a desirable thing.
- tptacek 5y agoI'm not lionizing the Democratic party; I'm speaking specifically to civil rights. I'm sure plenty of segregationist Democrats (and many Republicans!) favored labor rights and infrastructure, but none of that matters to the question at hand: the electoral college surely worked against the key issue for Black voters of the time, which was civil rights.
- zozbot234 5y ago> surely worked against the key issue for Black voters of the time, which was civil rights. It's not clear to me how salient the issue of civil rights in the south would have been to Blacks outside the south. The fact that they so readily joined a political coalition with labor-unions and lower-class whites suggests that issues other than racism would have been more relevant back in the day. It took a lot of raising-awareness to turn civil rights into something that could be addressed via the political process. (BTW, by and large, the "wealthy, urban population centers" disfavored by the electoral college were hotbeds of Progressive politics, which gave us great Civil Rights wins like, uh, eugenics. Or the modern focus on "white" political identity, replacing a far more intuitive celebration of national heritage (English, German, Eastern-European etc.). Back in the day, this was promoted as a way of fostering unity, but most people would of course disagree with this today. Progressive policymakers did basically zilch to oppose segregation and uplift Blacks; the issue was nowhere near their radar.)
- pvg 5y agoSwitzerland, where the voters are overwhelmingly white where the voters are overwhelmingly white. Switzerland is a curious example - they are not overwhelming men and it took them till 1971 to give full voting rights to women.