22 ms·
Meditation and the Unconscious
- PaulHoule 5y agoMakes me think of how Marvin Minsky thought Meditation was a bad thing.
- simmanian 5y agoWhat from the article makes you think that meditation is a bad thing?
- vishnugupta 5y ago"As far as your own inner conflicts are concerned, if you use meditation simply as a quick fix to superficially appease your emotions, you temporarily enjoy a pleasant deferral of these inner conflicts. But as you rightly say, these cosmetic changes have not reached the root of the problem. Merely putting problems to sleep for a while or trying to forcibly suppress strong emotions will not help either. You are just keeping a time bomb ticking somewhere in a corner of your mind. True meditation, however, is not just taking a break. It is not simply closing one’s eyes to the problem for a while. Meditation goes to the root of the problem. You need to become aware of the destructive aspect of compulsive attachment and all of the conflictive mental states that you mentioned. They are destructive in the sense of undermining your happiness and that of others, and to counteract them you need more than just a calming pill. Meditation practice offers many kinds of antidotes. "
- PaulHoule 5y agoMinsky thought meditation was dangerous in and of itself. (e.g. you aren't meant to inspect your own functioning) Personally I did a mindfulness practice for a while that I thought was harmful because it encouraged me to accept unacceptable situations which was already leading me to bad outcomes.
- 613style 5y ago"Accepting" in the context of mindfulness doesn't imply being passive. That's a common misconception. It's often said that passivity is the "near enemy" of acceptance, meaning one is easily mistaken for the other.
- LanceJones 5y agoThis is an underrated comment. Mindfulness is a precursor to objectifying your thoughts, emotions, sensations, and perceptions -- rather than "subjectifying" them (in other words, you are not your thoughts, emotions, etc). It doesn't at ALL mean laying down for others to kick you and taking it. They're completely different things.
- lanstin 5y ago"Do you have the patience to await right action to arise?" was a sign in my first teachers house (which we would walk by during Kinhin). Meditation's effect on your life and happiness probably varies based on what things are you are not seeing in your normal life. When I started meditating, I immediately discovered I was angry many times a day; several years later, having tried to respond to this reality in various ways, I got divorced as I found it impossible to ignore this previously un-perceived aspect of my reality. Now I am happier and more calm and so on, but the meditation definitely caused some shake up not more calm for quite some time.
- chillingeffect 5y agoglad to see this here and I would expand on it bc I think it's so important. For a long time, I, too, thought accepting Something Bad meant forcing oneself to appreciate it somehow, to reframe it as actually good, or to lie to oneself or even to "approve" of it. Just to re-iterate: those would all be unproductive, or Wrong Action, or just "bad." Instead, accepting means allowing one's self to acknowledge something happened without it driving thought to somewhere else. E.g. I was assaulted by a neighbor recently... true story... I was very traumatized for a few weeks and unable to process it well. As I slowly gathered myself up, I began to accept it. It doesn't mean I approve of it or welcome it or anything like that. I still hate the motherfucker and I'm disturbed that justice will never come for him, except hopefully he will fuck over the wrong person who is unlike me a scary person, and he'll get what he has coming. But you see how I digressed there, moving out of the present and away from the fact, moving toward a fantasy? That part is not acceptance, either. For me, acceptance is simply being able to sit still and say, "yes, my neighbor injured me for life." And to sit. and wait. and abide. and feel those urges to get mad and perhaps to get mad, but not to lose focus. When we get mad and lose focus, our minds confuse the negative feelings with our surroundings. I need to train my mind to connect the anger with what he did - not my current, comfy surroundings with a 43" 4k monitor and cool can of cranberry lime seltzer. We do this because magic happens. when we simply sit with it, our mind begins to actually process it. It's an organic version of a mechanistic process that you don't have to consciously run, but you can almost consciously obbserve. I like to imagine a fleet of trucks in a warehouse. They are carrying the heavy load of the trauma or upset in them and they need to bring it to the right departments in the brain to chop it up, water it down, separate it, dissolve, and re-fabricate it into something new. This is an automatic process our minds have apparently evolved. And it's free! But it requires some squirminess, some patience, some willingness to temporarily feel discomfort while sitting here, feeling the pain in my lower back, coming to terms with it. not appreciating it, but become capable of sitting with it. So I urge GP to circle back and consider this way of accepting, rather than someone telling you you should appreciate or thank the pain or some kind of bullshit like that. This doesn't correct or justify and evil. All this does is remove my own excess reaction to it so I can bring myself to peace by not flipping out when I inevitably recall it. Please accept my compassion for whatever your circumstances were and consider the advice of the late Thich Nhat Hanh to sit still and take it in. Let the delivery tracks in your mind do their processing and you will feel it settle and your mind will allow you to function better again.
- hammock 5y agoThat comment sounds like it applies to watching TV (or any other form of escapism) as much as meditation.
- cowuser666 5y agoCan you cite? I'm interested in this idea but it's unclear where he discusses meditation as such, rather than things like consciousness and introspection?
- adfm 5y agoMinsky had many questionable opinions. Obviously somebody consumed by avarice would have an aversion to meditation.
- TrainedMonkey 5y agoWhy is that obvious?
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- adfm 5y agoConsider meditating. Greed clouds the mind. Compassion is key. Follow your own path and it will become apparent. Or you can refer to the above comment, if that helps.
- jimhefferon 5y agoCould you say more about "consumed by avarice"? I've not heard anyone say that before.
- adfm 5y agoSure. To be consumed by avarice is to be consumed by extreme greed for wealth or material gain.[^0] [^0]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/9/20798900/marvin-minsky-jeffrey-epstein-sex-trafficking-island-court-records-unsealed https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/9/20798900/marvin-minsky-jef...
- jimhefferon 5y agoIt is my understanding that he refused the offer of sex. For instance, here is the WikiPedia (yes, I know WP can be an issue, but the link you provided is consistent with this quote): "[Ghislaine] Maxwell "directed" her to have sex with Minsky among others. There has been no allegation that sex between them took place nor a lawsuit against Minsky's estate."
- i_like_apis 5y agoI've always found it interesting that many meditation techniques involve "emptying the mind" or "clearing the mind" of thought. While practicing concentration on a single point of focus definitely seems useful for strengthening the mind, I'm not sure that practicing a state of being completely devoid of thought is necessarily healthy. I would rather meditate on being full of thought, and thinking of many things simultaneously, or meditate on focus in a high distraction environment. I wonder if there are meditation styles that embrace this?
- vidarh 5y agoConcentration meditation is in large part an exercise in the ability to focus, not on emptying the mind per se, though some traditions will use exercises that expect it. But concentration meditation is not an end in itself, but generally a tool to aid in meditating on other things, including on thoughts ariaing on your mind, bodily impulses, emotion and others.
- n4r9 5y agoI think a Buddhist might argue that one's mind is a high distraction environment.
- i_like_apis 5y agoYes, I've had much practice in focus meditation and can attest to this. Sitting in one spot and earnestly focusing on an object of meditation for 15-30 minutes is harder than it sounds. As powerful as that is (and backed by science), still I wonder about an alternative meditation that focuses on fullness or activity of thought. But I subscribe to a materialist metaphysics that assumes the mind cannot truly be escaped and the benefit of meditation is to strengthen the mind and body.
- dodecacat 5y agoMaybe this? From “Mindfulness” by Domyo Sater Burk © 2014 by Penguin Group (USA) isbn 978-1-61564-619-7 Expansive awareness meditation can end up getting you to the same place concentration meditation does (a still, present mind), but by using a different path…. You may find [it] works much better for you…. It just seems to depend on the way your mind works. [Y]ou try to open your awareness to everything. Imagine you’re waiting for some unusual or miraculous event, but you don’t know which of your senses you’ll perceive it with. Will it be a sound? Will it be a sight? Will it be a thought? Whenever you find your mind has wandered, instead of bringing it back to an object, you open your awareness back up. Any time you latch on to a train of thought or a particular sensation, you’re also closing down your awareness of other things. By opening your awareness as wide as you can, you’re returning to mindfulness of the present, just as you would by turning your attention back to an object of concentration. MINDFUL EXERCISE Sit, stand, or lie down and keep your eyes open. Widen your gaze, including what’s to the sides and above and below in your peripheral vision. (This will help keep you from getting distracted by particular things you can see.) Now watch your visual field as if it’s a movie—a slow-moving movie, perhaps, but one of those quiet, visually rich, artistic ones. Just keep watching. When you stop because you have gotten caught up in thinking, note that you have tuned out the “movie” because it’s boring, or because you think you know what’s going to happen next. Ask yourself, “When I really stop to look, is anything truly boring? Do I really know what’s going to happen next?”
- throw1234651234 5y agoThis is a valid concern. Most likely meditation doesn't do anything at all. If you trust "Western Research", e.g. reading "Altered Traits", it either did nothing, or changes were noticeable after years. Concrete example - the author (or one of) practice meditation for 2 years to reduce his blood pressure and then ended up just taking some pills for it. So it does nothing (likely), it's good for you, or it's bad for you. There is nothing saying that single-point focus doesn't just kill lateral thinking. It's not like it's working memory training or anything of the sort. Before you downvote me - ask yourself if you really know of any PROVEN benefit of meditation.
- swayvil 5y agoYes. There are proven benefits of meditation. I speak from personal experience. That is my proof. I used to do a lot of "one pointed" meditation. Then I did one pointed + vipassana. Now I do just vipassana.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>There are proven benefits >I speak from personal experience lol
- cypherpunks01 5y ago“One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious. The latter procedure, however, is disagreeable and therefore not popular.” -C.G. Jung
- leoh 5y agoI am in agreement with Jung; yet not to only make darkness conscious, but by beholding it with love and presence...
- andrei_says_ 5y agoMaking space to love the hate, rage, shame, etc... is not easy and takes conscious effort. What about all the times when your attention is busy with something else?
- dmje 5y agoThat's a large part of the point. Meditation gives you the tools to increase the quantity and quality of your attention. And let's face it, attention is probably the commodity we could all do with focusing on in these hyper-distracted times...
- throw1234651234 5y agoContext? I have no idea what this quote is trying to say.
- bobiny 5y agoI think, it implies that following an ideal (light) is futile, only seeing what is (darkness) works. The most popular religion in the world is based on fall from grace, original sin that we must attone for to become pure again. Alternative is that there is no going back and no perfect world or state of mind ahead, only the reality, which is sometimes dirty and messy and for many of us hard to see clearly.
- uptownfunk 5y agoI heard one of these "Guru's" once say in response to allegations of meditation as brainwashing: "If the brain is dirty, it needs to be washed."
- andai 5y agoWhat kind of meditation?
- Trasmatta 5y agoThat sentiment sure has a lot of potential for being a powerful thought terminating cliche for actual cults
- machinelearning 5y agoThe fact that this phrase sounds pithy and makes sense on a literal level tricks people into accepting the underlying message without critically analyzing the meaning of it. A classic Trojan horse of sorts.
- JetAlone 5y agoThis is true on an important level, but also dangerous as sibling comments point out. There's no panacea for that tension, only the particular choices made and risks taken. Do you trust a particular "doctor", or will you take your chances with the "disease"?
- monktastic1 5y agoI am surprised that Matthieu did not address this question head-on: > This brings me to a critical issue: the side effects of meditation. One could argue that a strategy consisting of closing one’s eyes when facing conflicts, in escaping from problems rather than solving them, is perhaps a suboptimal strategy. In Dzogchen meditation (which is his main practice), one does not close one's eyes or always sit in a special posture. It is engaged with real life. There is no "escaping" of any sort whatsoever. Thoughts arise as they normally do; it is only the method of dealing with them that differs (both from our usual habits and from other approaches like mindfulness as it is normally understood).
- lukasb 5y agoI think he did address it: "True meditation, however, is not just taking a break. It is not simply closing one’s eyes to the problem for a while. Meditation goes to the root of the problem. You need to become aware of the destructive aspect of compulsive attachment and all of the conflictive mental states that you mentioned. "
- monktastic1 5y agoI saw that. This quote can still give the impression that it is not closing one's eyes "to the problem," but is still about closing one's physical eyes. Or that it's about closing one's eyes to the problem for a bit (but not "a while.") I didn't see it clearly communicated that Dzogchen meditation is something does while in the very situations that WS is talking about.
- dbtc 5y agoClosing one's eyes can be very helpful for becoming conscious of subtle things, especially for those who, like me, are hyperliterate screen fiends. Sitting with good posture in a dark room also really helps. An isolation tank is good too, I have heard. But none are necessary. Just good tools when applied properly. And sometimes it's best to go for a walk, think it through, or sit for a while. Other times it's best to act without hesitation.A big part of the skill is knowing when to do what. That's my take.
- guest 5y ago
- swayvil 5y agoReality is like a dark room. Awareness is like a circle of light cast from a flashlight . Meditation manipulates that circle of light. Brightening and dimming it. Shrinking and enlarging it. I know of 2 techniques. The Buddhists call them Samatha and Vipassana.
- rakejake 5y agoWe are made of molecules and our thoughts are simply chemical reactions. The biological basis for the mind and thoughts are not well understood today. Meditation is a time-tested way to influence our body's chemistry in ways that discourage agitation, reduce anxiety and increase clarity. Just don't take it too far and hope to discover the meaning of life. Meditating for long hours is serious business and should be compared to pro-sports (in terms of commitment, training and potential injury). You wouldn't train like an athlete just to stay healthy, similarly you shouldn't meditate like its the end of the world.
- akomtu 5y agoSomeone observing Earth at distance might make a similar conclusion that humanity is made of humans and the apparent intelligence of humanity as a whole is solely the result of humans bouncing into each other.
- WJW 5y ago> Just don't take it too far and hope to discover the meaning of life. In particular, reducing agitation and anxiety is great, but that meditation can make you more tranquil does not mean it can make you infinitely tranquil no matter how hard you try. Training the high jump will allow you to make higher jumps, but even a lot of high jump training will not teach you to fly.
- nnoitra 5y agoIt can definitely shift the baseline to utter bliss for periods of months. (personal experience) and permanently according to some.
- dmje 5y agoIt's a common misunderstanding that meditation leads to tranquility, that you somehow become a calm person. In the moment it does, but the bigger picture is that it gives you tools to deal with life with more equanimity and balance. The offshoot might be a sense of calm but it's an effect rather than a cause. The "infinitely tranquil" thing needs some unpacking too, mainly because it's not exactly easy to define what that means... Are there people whose whole life has been hugely and meaningfully improved through the practice of meditation? Yes, absolutely. This in my opinion is enough. We don't always need to fly.
- graderjs 5y agoI don't want to pretend that the way I do meditation and yoga is the right way or it's going to work for someone else. But I think they should try some of it because it might work for them but it also might not because everyone's different. At the same time I don't want other people to pretend that the way they do meditation or yoga is going to work for me or is the right way. But it might work, but it also might not... because everyone's different.
- orena 5y agoIs there a podcast of their talk?
- Petrillo 5y ago[flagged]
- rpaddock 5y ago'What you can not measure, you an not improve.' What is the objective measurement of a successful meditation?