3 ms·
I’ve wondered recently if the US civil war really needed to happen and if the states and world would be better off if it hadn’t. We are taught it was necessary
by mixmastamyk 5y ago
I’ve wondered recently if the US civil war really needed to happen and if the states and world would be better off if it hadn’t. We are taught it was necessary as kids but after learning more I’m not so sure.
First, slavery was abolished by the late 1800s across the Americas and elsewhere. It was going to happen regardless. Brasil was by far the largest slave state, a fact few US folks realize. Other countries didn’t need a war to end it. Then there’s the death toll.
Next, too much concentration of power after WWII leading to today’s war machine looking around for things to do. The US was founded on a Union, but a Union you can’t leave is really a prison.
Today’s polarization is also supported by having a larger country with different views pulling in different directions. Smaller countries seem to get in less trouble.
- Clubber 5y ago>I’ve wondered recently if the US civil war really needed to happen and if the states and world would be better off if it hadn’t. We are taught so as kids but learning more I’m not so sure. It certainly would have been better if it didn't happen, 720K lives and countless fortunes and the decimation of 1/2 the land mass. Reconstruction was pretty horrible for ex-slaves as well. Of course slaves suffer being slaves for longer if there was no war. No one would ever know how long it would have taken to end slavery without the war, but I doubt it would exist today if things had continued without it. >Today’s polarization is also supported by having a larger country with different views pulling in different directions. I'm convinced today's polarization is a lot of theatre intended to divide. I analog it to crowds cheering different WWE wrestlers during the match, only to have the wrestlers have a beer together after the show.
- digisign 5y ago> I'm convinced today's polarization is a lot of theatre intended to divide Media definitely contributes, however this was an argument noted during the writing of the Declaration of Independence. It is real.