4 ms·
in theory, web3 has nothing to do with cryptocurrency per se, and only relies on some blockchain technology, which is itself not bound to the value of the curre
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
in theory, web3 has nothing to do with cryptocurrency per se, and only relies on some blockchain technology, which is itself not bound to the value of the currency it is used by.
however, the fact that too many people seem to think that there is in fact a connection between web3 and cryptocurrency just adds to the smell.
- hervature 5y agoHow do you reconcile the fact that most of Web3 is built on Ethereum which only works because miners ("soon to be" stakers) are rewarded for running the blockchain?
- flokie 5y agothis. the incentives are bound by the underlying tech.
- Tenoke 5y agoThere's more and more being built outside of Ethereum and the dominance has been shrinking. As to how I explain the dominance - shrinking first mover advantage.
- spmurrayzzz 5y agoeven for the other DVM-eqsue networks (solana, avalanche, et al), they still have the same constraint. the incentive to secure the network (either through PoW or PoS) is inherently tied to the underlying tokenomics, the currency has to have some value for the consensus mechanism to be successful.
- capableweb 5y ago> the dominance has been shrinking According to what? According to the global charts on Coinmarketcap, Ethereum is still around 20% of the total marketcap of cryptocurrencies (BTC being at ~40%) today, coming from growth since January 2020 (where Ethereum started at ~7.5%). By that metric, Ethereum seems to be growing, but you might have a better source/metric to share?
- thebean11 5y agoCurrency is actually a core part of it. The point of web3 is software that can natively move money around. That "money" does not need to be ETH or BTC though, can be tokens pegged to the dollar or gold or oil etc.
- Duckton 5y agoIs it thought? Can’t web3 be, for an example, patient health data in a ledger? Who says it has to be tied to a monetary value?
- thebean11 5y agoI think that's the killer feature personally (I work in the space). It has uses for censorship resistant communication and things like identity. Not sure if I see the use case in health data though.
- AlexandrB 5y agoAFAIK all transactions on a blockchain require spending some associated currency (e.g. "gas fees"). For investors, I think the killer feature is being able to make money off of every transaction involving identity and health data.
- thebean11 5y agoYes, the gas fees would be very expensive in the current state (think hundreds to thousands of dollars for a regular appointment, tens of thousands for an x-ray). There would have to be some benefit for healthcare providers to pay that and I don't see what that is..
- Duckton 5y agoMaybe not the healthcare provider, but a service that allows the patient to be in control of their health records. Control who can read and write to their own data. And is it not up to the implementor of the blockchain, to specify how difficult it is to calculate a new block? So lowering the "gas price"?
- romeros 5y agoIn practice, everything is indirectly tied to making more money 100x your "investment" in a blink of an eye. If the entire crypto/defi/nft/gamefi/play2earn etc marketcap was 0 then nobody would even bother with interacting/developing with web3. In-fact, nobody would even be interested in blockchain tech.
- capableweb 5y agoWhy are you assuming that just because something doesn't involve money, people wouldn't be interested in it? Music creation is for most people just a hobby, with zero financial incentives to engage in, yet countless amount of people make music as a hobby and release it for free via various channels. Same goes for software with free/open source software. Not to talk about BitTorrent (or it's predecessors in the P2P space) where people had the opinion of "sharing is caring" and shared data with each other, again with zero financial incentives. How do you reconcile these facts with your outlook?
- acdha 5y ago> Why are you assuming that just because something doesn't involve money, people wouldn't be interested in it? Because random hashes are not inherently interesting to most people and the core concept is built around an opinionated finance model. The only value to the blockchain network is in the ability to make transactions, and that's why all of the push around it is very heavy-handed FOMO “buy now or you'll have to pay more later” which is a sharp contrast to previous new technologies which focused on what new things you could do.
- danaris 5y agoBut cryptocurrency has no value or meaning if it's not worth money. That's not true of those other things.
- AlexandrB 5y agoI'm sure that some people would continue to run crypto nodes if it was not profitable, but the number of people doing so would drop precipitously. There's a huge portion of the crypto community (90%? 95%?) that are in it for the ROI and speculative gambling, not for running a decentralized web. As an example, I suspect no one would buy old power plants and turn them into Bitcoin miners if there was no return on investment. The operating costs of this kind of infrastructure are too high to justify as a "hobby".