6 ms·
Wisconsin Judge Rules 7 Health Care Workers Cannot Switch Jobs
- robbedpeter 5y agoThat judge is going to have the decision reversed and just told the whole world that every other decision he's made deserves intense scrutiny. What a dope!
- namelessoracle 5y ago"that every other decision he's made deserves intense scrutiny" When it comes to calculated risks, its sadly a good bet that a judge wont be held accountable. This particular case got national attention, but judges do questionable judgements all the time that flagrantly ignore the law and nothing ever happens to them. This judge didnt really make a bad bet based on the information he had about what he could get away with. And the odds that he will face any kind of adverse action are small. What is very interesting though, is that both left and right wing sources are lambasting this judge. (albeit for ideologically very different reasons) So he may actually receive some kind of adverse consequence if noise about it continues to ramp up.
- ehutch79 5y agoSupposedly this judge... according to someone on youtube.... has a history of questionable judgements
- s1artibartfast 5y agonot if they lift the injection and resolve the issue themselves, or if the two parties come to an agreement to resolve the situation
- namelessoracle 5y agothe really messed up thing is that the judge can lift it, and then any attempt to investigate/address this issue will be dismissed sense the matter is "now moot".
- namelessoracle 5y agoJudicial, prosecutorial, and police immunity really needs to be revisited. You will never ever find a Supreme Court that will rule that judges can be held accountable for what they do though. No matter how you rig/pack/arrange the Court. No Justice will ever vote to make themselves more personally vulnerable.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoHow do you solve the problem of preventing political retaliation for unpopular but morally correct decisions? For example, court decisions that dismantled school segregation and that allowed women to vote. Furthermore the other branches of government could step in when things like this happen too.
- namelessoracle 5y agoThis is a classic who watches the watchman problem. The answer might be that judicial oversight is handled by non judicial actors. Civilian oversight panels are commonly looked at as a solution for police and judges need it as well. Judicial oversight is currently in the hands of other judges who have incentives not to create precedent on cracking down on corrupt judges.
- ahtihn 5y agoMorality is subjective. Why should courts be able to overrule the population's wishes?
- otterley 5y agoUsually it's to protect the rights of minorities. This is well covered in the Federalist Papers.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoLaw is supposed to be independent of people, not a decree from royalty, and the US system is one of limited government. Legislators can't do whatever they want and the check-and-balance system is supposed to limit that.
- otterley 5y agoThis blogspam headline is misleading and mischaracterizes what’s happening. The workers certainly can switch jobs, but they (temporarily) can’t go to work for a specific provider being accused of unlawfully poaching them. The actual article being cribbed from: https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/2022/01/21/what-we-know-ascension-thedacare-court-battle-over-employees/6607417001/ https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/2022/01/21/what-we-k... (Note: I have no knowledge of or opinion about the law itself, I don't know WI labor law, and the filings aren't linked from the article; so I can't evaluate the legal merits of the case.)
- zamadatix 5y agoI don't think they are even claiming they were "unlawfully poached" (which is an extremely high legal bar for at will employees without a non-compete contract) just that they are seeking 90 more days to find replacements which makes the whole thing even more ridiculous. https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/health/2022/01/20/thedacare-ascension-go-court-over-stroke-trauma-employee-hires/6595232001/ https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/health/2022/01/20/th...
- ehutch79 5y agoThe judge can't force them to work for the original provider. That'd be slavery.
- namelessoracle 5y agoNot de jure but he can de facto. If you have bills to pay and a family to support, you can't just quit a job without another income stream set up.
- evgen 5y agoYeah, but when you become internet famous in certain circles then the income stream appears. Within hours of this hitting various sub-reddits a gufundme was in place (https://www.gofundme.com/f/thedacare-exemployee-support-fund?qid=aa789870144c2da5f66211913e8c01b4 https://www.gofundme.com/f/thedacare-exemployee-support-fund...) and has pulled in almost 60K to cover these workers for the period in which they will not be working for their former employer, just in case the order is not overturned in the next 24 hours.
- spacedcowboy 5y agoI mean, seems like they just turn up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit around all day getting paid until they get fired, then they take up the other offer ?
- tablespoon 5y ago> I mean, seems like they just turn up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit around all day getting paid until they get fired, then they take up the other offer ? These are health care workers, not retail clerks at a GameStop. If they did that it would likely mean a patient doesn't get adequate care.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoHow is it any different than if they just didn't show up because they rage quit and took jobs in a different industry?
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoAnd? If you're going to basically force someone to work for you, you get what you get.
- tablespoon 5y ago>>> I mean, seems like they just turn up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit around all day getting paid until they get fired, then they take up the other offer ? >> These are health care workers, not retail clerks at a GameStop. If they did that it would likely mean a patient doesn't get adequate care. > And? If you're going to basically force someone to work for you, you get what you get. My point is: it would be unethical to "stick to the man" in that way, because there could literally be an innocent man down the hall who's suffering because of your immediate actions. That's not a man you should stick it to. It's not OK to stop your analysis where the original comment did, before you consider scenarios like that. Imagine these scenarios: A nurse "turn[s] up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit[s] around all day" across from some patient who's laying in his own piss and shit, because that nurse refused to do her job to give him a bedpan. or A nurse "turn[s] up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit[s] around all day" across from some who dies because he didn't get his medication, because that nurse refused to do her job to give him his medication. vs. A GameStop clerk "turn[s] up with a camp chair and a good book, then sit[s] around all day" across from a customer who wants to buy a videogame but can't.
- sleepingadmin 5y agoThere was a hearing this morning. Might still be happening but I don't see this article as offering any information from this morning. I was reading this: https://www.boardmanclark.com/publications/hr-heads-up/employee-poaching-made-easier-non-solicitation-of-employee-provisions-in-wisconsin-are-subject-to-strict-requirements-for-enforceability https://www.boardmanclark.com/publications/hr-heads-up/emplo... Wisconsin seems to be restrictive even if there was a non-compete. In fact, there doesn't seem to be a non-compete. Therefore "poaching" is legal and offensive term here.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI've never understood why USAians decided it's a good idea to elect judges (or sheriffs, or DAs). Nor do I understand why it's considered OK for jurors to talk to the press after the case. From my perspective, the US judicial/LE system seems like a crapshoot.
- twiddling 5y agoCounty Coroners are elected in many places as well, which is bonkers in my mind
- thehappypm 5y agoWould you rather them be appointed? Who would appoint them?
- denton-scratch 5y agoWell, that's a good question. what seems silly about electing these officials, is that it shouldn't be a popularity contest. It should be a matter of competence, and compliance with rules. What good are laws whose effects depends on the mood of voters or the whims of the enforcer? It's not great to have lawyers appoint other lawyers. You end up with an in-group. But that kind of system does seem to give you law whose effects are fairly predictable, at least. But you have to explain how the topmost lawyers get appointed, the ones who appoint other lawyers. The US Supreme Court seems to be nominated by the Pres, and then confirmed by the Senate, which is full of lawyers. So the USSC seems to be appointed, by their juniors. Hmmm. I wondered how UKSC justices are appointed; it's rather good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_the_United_Kingdom#Appointment_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_the_United_Ki... A commission is formed, consisting of the president of the court, another senior judge who is not on the UKSC, and a member of the Judicial Appointments Commission. At least one of them must not be a lawyer. The commission is set up by the Minister of Justice, who apparently can overrule them. The PM and the Queen both have a final veto.
- crmd 5y agoSteve Lehto posted[0] a very good analysis of the legal basis for the lawsuit and temporary restraining order. He predicts the judge will lift the TRO and the lawsuit will be dismissed this week if the parties don’t settle. [0] https://youtu.be/QE5mV5V-pHs https://youtu.be/QE5mV5V-pHs
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is the legal basis for the lawsuit for those of us who cannot watch the video?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt doesn't specify.
- crmd 5y agoThe basis for the temporary restraining order was irreparable harm. The judge could not force the defendants to work at at Theta (13th Amendment - prohibition of involuntary servitude). As predicted, the judge declined to convert the TRO into a permanent injunction, but the (meritless, IMO) lawsuit can continue.
- londgine 5y agoa common argument given against stating that healthcare is a human right is that if you make a positive right a human right you will make the provider of those rights slaves. that is because they will be forced to provide that service against their will. it always sounded like a weak argument to me, after all child education is a positive right and teachers are not treated like slaves. however, barring people from working at their main competitor is a pretty good way to force them to work at their current company in order to not lose their income and their house. that argument is starting to make more sense to me now.
- scottlawson 5y agoReading this article, my first reaction is surprise at a ruling that, on the surface, appears to block people from switching jobs. That's weird right? I think most people would be surprised and confused to hear that, because it sounds bad and wrong. My next reaction is curiosity, a desire to know how such a strange ruling could make sense in the mind of the judge. Judges, of course, don't think they are making an obviously incorrect ruling, otherwise they would rule a different way. However, this article makes no attempt unwrap the situation and present the judge's reasons and rationale, and doesn't link to the court documents. I don't think this article benefits from not presenting the rationale. In fact, I think it fails to address the glaringly obvious followup question "that sounds so weird, why did the judge rule that way?"
- namelessoracle 5y agoAs medical workers, there failure to be replaced could mean an emergency room has to shut down. (or can't provide radiology services, so no x rays for broken legs) Its my understanding that as a doctor or nurse, you decide that after working 60 hours that week you want to just quit on the spot and try to find a different job due to being overworked you effectively cannot without severe legal consequences ( I dont THINK they can get jail time but they could lose their medical license for sure) unless someone is present to relieve you. I dont AGREE with any of that, but there is some thread of rationale there.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoOne can make a hypothetical where such an injunction might make sense. Imagine a sufficiently funded company (like google) wants to buy you or put you out of business. They could intentionally hire your staff and pay them to twiddle their thumbs, and hire your new staff when you replace them until you fold. This strategy of specifically targeting their workforce to put them out of business would be unethical, but I don't know if it runs afoul of business law.
- namelessoracle 5y agoLooks like the judge reversed the injunction after the hearing today. There will be no consequences to the judge or the suing hospital in the legal forum :(