3 ms·
As an occasional bitcoin holder, I don't think it's a Ponzi scheme. Who's the Ponzi schemer? How come every time it collapses it comes back bigger in a year or
by tim333 5y ago
As an occasional bitcoin holder, I don't think it's a Ponzi scheme. Who's the Ponzi schemer? How come every time it collapses it comes back bigger in a year or two?
- podgaj 5y agoYou are the Ponzi schemer. It is a combination of Pump and Dump and Ponzi. That's why it "comes back bigger".
- tim333 5y agoI think it comes back bigger each time because more people get involved. From a handful of tech geeks at the start to maybe 100m people this time around.
- cuteboy19 5y ago70% of Bitcoin holders bought in last year. A continuous stream of greater fools is necessary for its price to even remain at the current level Also, every ponzi scheme gives amazing returns, before it inevitably collapses. For example Madoff was able to give decent returns to his investors for 17 years! 'Number go up' is not a refutation of a ponzi scheme.
- tim333 5y agoYeah but with a Madoff/Ponzi scheme the thing collapses, Madoff goes to jail, it ends. Bitcoin seems more like other assets that don't make things, stuff like fiat money, gold, fine art and so on.
- DarylZero 5y agoIt literally is just fiat currency. Bitcoin is a way to make fiat currency independent of government.
- hypertele-Xii 5y ago...but dependent on the price of electricity and computers. Guess which governments have the most of both.
- it_does_follow 5y ago> stuff like fiat money, gold, fine art and so on. This comment is a great example of how little bitcoin enthusiasts tend to understand about investing. One of this things is very much not like the others. "Fiat currency" is virtually never used as an investment asset. Even in the FOREX market you purchases pairs of currency rather than just a big pile of dollars. In your 401k when you want to go all "cash" you very often end up choosing investment vehicles that track cash. The entire function of a currency is as a medium of exchange, it only has value in the process of exchanging. It makes no sense, at the individual investor level, to 'hold' dollars. If you don't understand how a fiat currency differs from gold and fine art then you absolutely should not be "investing" in bitcoin.
- immibis 5y agoYeah, it's the world's first decentralized Ponzi scheme. There's nobody to put in jail - its value just drops to 0.
- fallat 5y ago> A continuous stream of greater fools is necessary for its price to even remain at the current level. I think HN is going to need a good explanation for this. The value is intrinsic, and can go up without any activity happening... I think there are other fools scouring about here in the comments.
- dpark 5y ago> I think HN is going to need a good explanation for this. The value is intrinsic, and can go up without any activity happening... I think you need to explain this. In what way does bitcoin have any intrinsic value? And how can this value go up without activity? A currency with no activity is literally worthless.
- manfredz 5y agoIt's not a Ponzi scheme. It's a multi-level marketing or pyramid scheme. A percentage of every sale (transaction fees) of crypto goes to the other coin owners of the crypto. For every crypto coin it works slightly different. For Bitcoin, the original design was that everybody could be a miner and (potentially) receive transaction fees. Now it's in the hands of a few with the computing power.
- lupire 5y agoonly 7Billion suckers on Earth. Pretty soon you'll need aliens to buy BTC to keep propping up the price...
- immibis 5y agoBitcoin isn't even close to reaching all 8* billion people, so this Ponzi scheme has the ability to go even higher.