4 ms·
Often these kinds of things collide with the laws of thermodynamics and end up decreasing the energy the system provides to its endpoint by the same amount that
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
Often these kinds of things collide with the laws of thermodynamics and end up decreasing the energy the system provides to its endpoint by the same amount that is extracted. Not always, just often.
A classical example would be putting some thing to collect the energy generated by turning a rotating door to power lights in a lobby, it is probable that this will end up causing the people using the rotating door to expend the exact amount of extra energy that is captured by the system (probably because the easiest way to collect the energy is to put some extra resistance on turning the door)
So why do it? Well in the case of the rotating door it is easy to see why, because by having everyone give just a little extra of their personal energy (like two extra spoonfuls of cereal in the morning, and a sip of orange juice) the company manages to externalize the cost of lighting their fancy lobby and nobody even notices that the energy was taken from someone else to do it.
Put a notice about how the lobby is powered by green energy, that's really the icing on the cake.
- ekanes 5y agoIt’s a good example actually - people would like it and we could all use a little more physical challenge in our environment!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 5y ago> we could all use a little more physical challenge in our environment! The disabled and frail do not.
- dguest 5y agoComplete aside: Has anyone actually implemented this classical example? I've heard it mentioned a few times but always assumed the people floating it hadn't thought about orders of magnitude enough: a "sip" of orange juice is indeed a lot of energy, about 80 kJ [1], and if you could extract that much energy from one person every 10 seconds you'd get 8 kW, which could power a decent sized lobby if the lighting is efficient. But to extract 80 kJ over 1 m... you have to push with 80 kN, or 17 thousand pounds (or 1.4 TRex bites worth of force [2]). More realistically, if we have everyone push with an annoying but manageable 50 N (about 10 pounds), we'd get 5 W, which might power a single (dim) LED bulb. As I said, this is a bit off topic for the original post, but the common theme is that people tend to confuse "extracting some energy" with "extracting a useful amount of energy in a cost effective way" (they also tend to overestimate mechanical energy). This on top of the thermodynamic constraints you mention to start with. [1]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=energy+in+40+grams+of+orange+juice https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=energy+in+40+grams+of+... [2]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=80+kN https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=80+kN
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI don't know if anyone ever implemented the classical example, I just see it floated every few years.
- dguest 5y agoI see it every few years as well, and I'm glad I finally did the math (it's not that hard actually)! It's probably a good freshman physics example, to make people think about orders of magnitude and energy. Or a good "Fermi question" if you're one of those places that still interviews with those.
- addaon 5y agoA shortcut for this is that a horsepower is about 750 watts (745.7 or so), and that you can extract one horsepower from a fit human for a very limited amount of time before they stop humaning. You can sustain about half this, or a little less, with the correct human. These super-approximate numbers come in useful for, e.g., human-powered airplane design. (The equivalent horsepower numbers for a horse are about 15 hp peak, 2 hp sustained. Naming is hard.) So, if you're proposing a system that extracts energy from N humans at a time, and you're hoping to get more than N hp out of it... you're probably off by a bit. If you're hoping to do this without the humans noticing, you're probably off by an order of magnitude.
- beagle3 5y agoI’ve heard the story (myth?) that Edison’s house had a gate that was relatively hard to push, and which visitors asked him to fix but he refused - and it eventually turned out it was providing energy to his locally dug well, pulling some water out with every opening @ closing of the gate. Might be an urban legend.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoBased upon this[1] (so big old grain of sea salt required) it's an urban myth. [1] https://boards.straightdope.com/t/thomas-edisons-front-gate/120679/6 https://boards.straightdope.com/t/thomas-edisons-front-gate/... I also wonder at the practicality of pulling out one sporadic push worth of water out of a well. No way is that moving much water.
- sandworm101 5y agoLike this? https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2010/07/01/the-playpump-what-went-wrong/ https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2010/07/01/the-playpump-wh... Using a wheel to harness the power of people has been around for a while but often does not end well (see Arnold in the opening sequence of Conan). There was also a soccer ball generator. Kids had to be forced to "play" with that one too.
- thewakalix 5y agoAs I'm sure everyone has heard in response to the Matrix, "humans make for pretty terrible batteries".
- toxik 5y agoWe have okayish chemical energy efficiency, like 40% if I recall correctly.
- dontcare007 5y agoThe Wheel of Pain!
- pharke 5y agoThe goal is to harvest heat that is already being wasted by escaping to the environment. They aren't putting an additional load on the system unless they are foregoing insulating the pipes but there are a lot of cases where pipes are not insulated and these devices would be applicable.
- thehappypm 5y agoConsider the hot pipe example. Sounds like free energy, right? Hot pipes leak heat energy, it’s what they do. However, pipes are also usually suspended in the air, and air is a really good insulator. You put this device on a pipe, you might start wicking heat away from the pipe faster, making your boiler or whatever need to expend more energy to keep the pipe hot.