4 ms·
> Free markets have a well established, well understood "tendency towards monopoly." There is actually a lot of debate about what causes this. The argument on
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Free markets have a well established, well understood "tendency towards monopoly."
There is actually a lot of debate about what causes this.
The argument on one side is, of course companies unconstrained by laws would collude with each other to fix prices etc.
The argument on the other side is, as soon as they start doing this it becomes profitable for someone else to enter the market. Is the cartel charging $40 for something that should cost $20? Go around to all the customers and tell them you'll sell to them for $25 tomorrow if they agree to a long-term contract today to buy from you at that price. Then you have enough guaranteed customers to pay off your new factory, so you can build it without being bankrupted by the incumbents slashing prices. And because anyone can do this, the incumbents don't collude to charge $40 to begin with because they know they would invite it.
Under this theory, monopolies form because of regulatory capture. The large incumbents don't want to compete in a commodity market, so they pay off the government to erect barriers to entry. Then once no one new can enter the market, they can buy each other or collude or use conscious parallelism without risk of new competitors.
It seems to me that it's kind of both. Without the second one, companies would rarely if ever get big enough that no one could compete with them. But once they are, somebody's got to break them up.
Most importantly, we need to fix the regulatory environment so that it facilitates rather than impairs competition, or it will just happen again.
- fn-mote 5y ago> Go around to all the customers and tell them you'll sell to them for $25 tomorrow if they agree to a long-term contract today to buy from you at that price. This argument seems tenuous. I see the customer's risk. Where is your risk? A source with details of this argument would also help. If you have are an economist, please mention it - I'll take the argument more seriously on your say-so.
- rendall 5y agoWhat's the risk to the customer? They get a $25 thing tomorrow or they pay the normal price.
- midasuni 5y agoThey go bust as the cartel drops to $20, so the company locked into $25 is paying over the odds compared to competitors
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> This argument seems tenuous. I see the customer's risk. Where is your risk? The purpose of the contract is to reduce your risk. The original problem was that if you built the factory intending to sell for $25, the incumbents could reduce the price to $20 or $15, i.e. below your cost. Then you could never recover your initial investment and the high probability of that happening would deter you from entering the market to begin with. The customer takes the risk because if you don't enter the market, they're paying $40 to the incumbents. > If you have are an economist, please mention it - I'll take the argument more seriously on your say-so. Professional economists have a reputation that compares disfavorably with psychics and astrologers. If an economist gives you your horoscope, make sure to get a second opinion. If the second opinion is from another economist, expect it to be different. "The track record of economists in predicting events is monstrously bad. It is beyond simplification; it is like medieval medicine." -Nassim Nicholas Taleb
- jquery 5y agoCompanies hire economists and pay them handsomely. They do no such thing with psychics or astrologers. So the market sees value in economists.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe sector employing the largest number of economists is universities. The second largest is banks. Banks are the things that keep blowing up the economy.
- random314 5y agoMatch.com continued success while actively ruining products it acquires is a stark counter example
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThey keep buying them but people keep making more of them. Where this serves as an instance of irrationality is that the investors in Match keep allowing them to spend money acquiring more products to ruin, as if This Time Things Will Be Different. What they ought to do is spin off what they already own with the hopes that someone less incompetent could potentially un-ruin some of them.
- random314 5y agoMatch.com investors are very clever and rational. Match.com business model is clear. Milk users for money with market segmentation. Building a good product will not make them any money. It will financially ruin them. The core functionality of these apps is very cheap to build, ideally these apps should be near free. What match.com does is capture the network. When a new cheap and better network appears, they offer the founders the kind of cash that simply cannot be earned by running their original network. For eg, okcupid was free. There was no way to make money from it. And then as per their plan - they ruin it.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoSo why are VCs not lining up to create a dozen new dating sites and take all of Match Group's buyout money? 1) Make a non-ruined dating product. 2) Get users. Should be easy because the incumbents are intentionally ruined and turnover is high. 3) Profit. (Match Group buyout) Worst case they run out of money and you have a successful dating product which continues to siphon their users because it's the non-ruined one. Not sure why it's so hard to make money from something like that. Sell flowers and chocolate and movie tickets to a captive audience. Do promotions for entertainment venues. Be Groupon for dating stuff.
- 5y ago
- heavyset_go 5y ago> The argument on the other side is, as soon as they start doing this it becomes profitable for someone else to enter the market. Is the cartel charging $40 for something that should cost $20? Go around to all the customers and tell them you'll sell to them for $25 tomorrow if they agree to a long-term contract today to buy from you at that price. Then you have enough guaranteed customers to pay off your new factory, so you can build it without being bankrupted by the incumbents slashing prices. And because anyone can do this, the incumbents don't collude to charge $40 to begin with because they know they would invite it. The Phoebus cartel[1] existed for quite some time, and its operation contradicts this argument. They captured the world-wide light bulb market with agreements between manufacturers. It took WWII to put a dent in it. Today, you can look at the price fixing that happens in the mobile app store and payments markets. 99% of each market is dominated by a two company duopoly. Prices in those markets have remained steady for over a decade, and any changes to pricing and terms are adopted in lockstep between Google and Apple. They've effectively captured 15% to 30% of all revenue collected in mobile apps. Neither cartel relied on regulatory capture, but both cartels recognized that without collusion, it would be a race to the bottom if they compete on price, so they became complicit in ensuring that doesn't happen. It only costs so much to make a light bulb, download an app or process payments. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoebus_cartel
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> The Phoebus cartel[1] existed for quite some time, and its operation contradicts this argument. They captured the world-wide light bulb market with agreements between manufacturers. It took WWII to put a dent in it. They had intended the cartel to last for thirty years (1925 to 1955). The cartel ceased operations in 1939 owing to the outbreak of World War II. So they didn't actually last all that long. Both organisations co-ordinated the trading of patents and market penetration. Patents are a government-granted monopoly. > Neither cartel relied on regulatory capture This is not remotely true for Apple and Google. The laws are written to allow them to exclude competitors. Why doesn't Amazon buy a bunch of iPhones and modify the software to include the Amazon App Store and then sell them to customers? Laws prohibit this. And then it's the same situation again -- copyright too is a government-granted monopoly. Finding that a monopoly exists where the government prohibits anyone from competing with them was the original theory. Let's have 14 year copyrights again and see how the monopoly holds up when Apple has to compete with a fork of the original iPhone which would be out of copyright by now.
- adrianN 5y agoEntering a market is not free. Suppose you want to start a chip business because the small handful of existing manufacturers have formed a cartel. To be competitive you need hundreds of billions in starting capital and you must be able to survive price dumping longer than the members of the cartel.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThis is the purpose of the contract. You have to spend $200B, so you go to several large customers and sign contracts contingent on your ability to supply which will guarantee you $300B in future revenue. Now you can raise funding against the guaranteed revenue and the dumping can't change that because the contracts are already signed. To prevent this the incumbents could go in and undercut you before you actually build anything, but that's not much of a cartel anymore then. Anyone could "compete with them" just by threatening to raise funding.