4 ms·
> If the government intervenes, it would undermine the free market. The "free market" without regulation is mythic ideal that's never actually existed. Regulat
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> If the government intervenes, it would undermine the free market.
The "free market" without regulation is mythic ideal that's never actually existed. Regulations are necessary to maintain healthy markets, and markets rely on states to enforce the terms that make trade and markets possible.
- badRNG 5y agoFree markets have a well established, well understood "tendency towards monopoly." A truly free market is one dominated by cartels [0] (not to be thought of as something unique to the drug industry.) The market forces that spur innovation like competition, absent a government that intervenes, best resolves competition through either ceaseless merging or subsumption of the competition. The domination of markets by cartels is seen in countries whose governments have either been effectively captured by industry or are otherwise incapable of intervening in the affairs of the market. Prior to antitrust legislation, cartels dominated industries at the dawn of the capitalist economy. Merging with competition allows both players to charge more without providing greater value, which is always the best option for both players. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Free markets have a well established, well understood "tendency towards monopoly." There is actually a lot of debate about what causes this. The argument on one side is, of course companies unconstrained by laws would collude with each other to fix prices etc. The argument on the other side is, as soon as they start doing this it becomes profitable for someone else to enter the market. Is the cartel charging $40 for something that should cost $20? Go around to all the customers and tell them you'll sell to them for $25 tomorrow if they agree to a long-term contract today to buy from you at that price. Then you have enough guaranteed customers to pay off your new factory, so you can build it without being bankrupted by the incumbents slashing prices. And because anyone can do this, the incumbents don't collude to charge $40 to begin with because they know they would invite it. Under this theory, monopolies form because of regulatory capture. The large incumbents don't want to compete in a commodity market, so they pay off the government to erect barriers to entry. Then once no one new can enter the market, they can buy each other or collude or use conscious parallelism without risk of new competitors. It seems to me that it's kind of both. Without the second one, companies would rarely if ever get big enough that no one could compete with them. But once they are, somebody's got to break them up. Most importantly, we need to fix the regulatory environment so that it facilitates rather than impairs competition, or it will just happen again.
- fn-mote 5y ago> Go around to all the customers and tell them you'll sell to them for $25 tomorrow if they agree to a long-term contract today to buy from you at that price. This argument seems tenuous. I see the customer's risk. Where is your risk? A source with details of this argument would also help. If you have are an economist, please mention it - I'll take the argument more seriously on your say-so.
- rendall 5y agoWhat's the risk to the customer? They get a $25 thing tomorrow or they pay the normal price.
- midasuni 5y agoThey go bust as the cartel drops to $20, so the company locked into $25 is paying over the odds compared to competitors
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> This argument seems tenuous. I see the customer's risk. Where is your risk? The purpose of the contract is to reduce your risk. The original problem was that if you built the factory intending to sell for $25, the incumbents could reduce the price to $20 or $15, i.e. below your cost. Then you could never recover your initial investment and the high probability of that happening would deter you from entering the market to begin with. The customer takes the risk because if you don't enter the market, they're paying $40 to the incumbents. > If you have are an economist, please mention it - I'll take the argument more seriously on your say-so. Professional economists have a reputation that compares disfavorably with psychics and astrologers. If an economist gives you your horoscope, make sure to get a second opinion. If the second opinion is from another economist, expect it to be different. "The track record of economists in predicting events is monstrously bad. It is beyond simplification; it is like medieval medicine." -Nassim Nicholas Taleb
- jquery 5y ago
- toolz 5y agoThese claims, while they might have some or even a lot of merit are demonstrably false (as they are made seemingly without exception or nuance). There is a very healthy and active black market, for example among plenty of other examples. It seems rather disingenuous to make such fantastically bold claims as statements of understood fact. I can't imagine what sort of dialog you were hoping to encourage.
- badRNG 5y agoBlack markets can be thought of as truly free markets that are free from antitrust action. These markets, if permitted to exist for an extended period of time, are dominated by cartels. "The Little Guy" doesn't get to be disruptive in black markets, because they are fully captured by cartels that will squash, subsume, or merge with any meaningful competition.
- danny_codes 5y agoDo you have any economic source or model that supports this claim? Economic orthodoxy, in all cases I've ever encountered, do not support your claim.
- toolz 5y agoAn economic source that the black market is alive and healthy? I'm not sure what you're asking for to be honest - I don't think anyone contests the fact that the black market has been growing for a very long time.
- HWR_14 5y agoI'm pretty sure there isn't a free black market. I'm fairly sure drug dealing is very regulated by armed forces in any geographic region and historically most major criminal enterprises are similarly regulated.
- Diesel555 5y agoI wish more people understood that markets include government regulation to ensure they operate in a competitive way. In a competitive market there must be so many buyers and sellers so that each has a negligible impact on the market price [1]. Obviously governments try to prevent monopolies to uphold this assumption. Regulation must also prevent market failures. Such failures occur with externalities. The most famous example being a factory that pollutes the environment thus producing negative health effects on people but incurring no cost for that damage without government intervention. Another example of a failure is information asymmetry (the doctor that recommends a procedure he knows you don't need but you trust him for his information) which is illegal. My point is, markets do include government regulation. Academic debate is not centered on whether or not markets include government regulation by microeconomics definition. The debate is how much, where, when and how. If "free market" is defined as no government intervention, it is not an accepted practice and even conservative economists would not recommend it. I think there is a reason the term "free market" is not included in my microeconomics textbook. We look for a competitive market (described by the desired result), not a "free market" (described by the methods, not the result). [1] Mankiw, Principle of Microeconomics 8th edition
- jlcoff 5y ago
- Diesel555 5y agoYou in no way responded to the content in my post. "free speech" and "free markets" are completely separate topics which may or may not be mutually exclusive, both of which are studied well academically. I make no claims on free speech. I simply provided a basic academic background to markets in microeconomics. Then you provide random sayings to try to discredit my post which have no logical connection to my content. There is a lot of ignorance in economics. And while ignorance is okay, I am ignorant in a lot of fields, ignorance without recognizing what you do not know is dangerous. This is a well studied field and America's founders even agreed government should have some say in markets. Here is a well cited source for that, search for "free markets". Of note definitions are important and clearly the authors of the link below include government regulation in a "free market" which the definition I gave and the one you responded to do not. https://www.heritage.org/political-process/report/the-economic-principles-americas-founders-property-rights-free-markets-and# https://www.heritage.org/political-process/report/the-econom...
- sithlord 5y agoI kinda agree, and kinda don't. Often regulation (sometimes unintended) creates situations where companies basically have a walled garden, without these regulations - they wouldn't be able to do what they do. Think electric companies in a lot of places, they put in regulation to protect these companies, presumably because its such a significant start up cost to get going. But somehow these utilities can continue fighting for 0 competition - from a legal standpoint.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAlso, the idea that government intervention damages the "free market" implicitly relies on the idea that the market and the government are two distinct and potentially antagonistic entities. Personally I'd argue that they're symbiotic at best; you generally don't get country wide markets without governments either purposefully creating them, or accidentally creating them in the process of trying to do something else.
- siruncledrew 5y agoI highly doubt the government's core stance is "Heavens no, we can't intervene in the free market!" when the market is not even a literal "free market" to begin with. That's more a theoretical concept than a practical implementation. To the government: i) they get a ton of John Deere lobbying dollars, ii) John Deere can always loom the potential of lost jobs over politicians' heads, iii) Farmers are not happy yet still begrudgingly using the system so things are not totally falling apart.... and, of course, iv) this matter doesn't really effect politicians personally.