17 ms·
I thought this was a really interesting article, but calling gelak "the edible red earth" seems a bit of a misnomer. Lots of things could be considered "edible"
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I thought this was a really interesting article, but calling gelak "the edible red earth" seems a bit of a misnomer. Lots of things could be considered "edible" then if you can put them in your mouth and swallow, and they don't kill you. Sounds like sooragh is basically just a fermented fish sauce, very similar to ancient Roman garum, and the soil just dyes it a pretty red (which, in fairness, the article points out).
- samatman 5y agoThat does strike me as the definition of edible, agreed. What's the misnomer? Red? Earth? "Edible dye" is a common thing to say; that's what this is, happens to be a local dirt. Lac is another thing I'd call edible, rather than, say, delicious. There are a few.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoBecause the article makes it sound like there is something special about this red earth that makes it edible: > But only one soil, gelak, is edible and a critical ingredient in the island’s local cuisine. Where my guess is pretty much all the soil is "edible", it just doesn't have the pretty dyeing properties that gelak does.
- Retric 5y agoHaving a pleasant taste is significantly stricter than simply non toxic. Eating dirt or clay can provide missing minerals in peoples diets. Most notably most salt is arguably just another type of processed soil.